This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Utilitarianism And Kant's Categorical Imperative Essay

1368 words - 6 pages

Utilitarianism and Kant’s Categorical Imperative
The issues of morality are most clearly expressed through examples of different methods of analyzing a situation. The case of Holmes, an officer in charge of a sinking ship, shows the striking differences between philosopher Immanuel Kant’s beliefs and those of the Utilitarians. After Holmes’ ship sinks, there are twenty passengers in a lifeboat that is only meant to hold fourteen people. There was no time to send out a signal for help before the ship sank, so no rescue is guaranteed and the nearest land is fifteen hundred miles away. Holmes decides to force the wounded passengers and those wearing life jackets off of the lifeboat and ...view middle of the document...

Act Utilitarianism also focuses on creating the most good for the greatest number, but recognizes the fact that sometimes there are exceptions to rules that will in fact create the most good, and in those cases the rules should be broken. For example, there is a hunter who wonders if it is morally acceptable to kill a deer. Act Utilitarianism analyzes the effects of this one action to decide if it is moral by assigning a value to the amount of pleasure and pain each individual involved will experience. In this case the hunter and his family will experience the pleasure of having food from eating the deer, many of the neighbors of the hunter will experience pleasure by having the deer off their property, and the deer’s family will experience the pain of the loss of a family member. If the outcome is that the net value of pleasure is greater than the pain caused by the killing of the deer, it is morally right for the hunter to kill it.
The example of the sinking ship and Holmes’ decision to throw people off of the lifeboat represents an Act Utilitarian belief. Holmes’ decision making process can be seen as morally right when one assesses the amount of pleasure and pain that can be expected from his actions. The lifeboat is the only method of getting to shore, and the less people that are in it the better the chance they all have of surviving since it will be less likely that the lifeboat will capsize. The boat holds fourteen people, so it is best to take exactly fourteen and no less so that the most people have the greatest chance of survival. The decision on who to take in the lifeboat can be made by explaining that those with lifejackets have a better chance of surviving in the water than those without them, so those without them should stay in the lifeboat. Also the wounded have the least chance of surviving whether or not they are in the lifeboat, so if they are thrown off more room can be made in the boat for the healthy ones with a greater chance of survival. There are twenty survivors total, and if Holmes can almost guarantee the survival of fourteen of them, this ultimately creates much more pleasure and much less pain. Even though the other passengers might die, the pain they endured in their struggle, and the pain of their family and friends who mourn their death becomes outweighed by the pleasure created by the survival of the others. Holmes’ actions can be said to produce the greatest certainty and extent of pleasure, which is the aim of Utilitarianism.
When accepting this view of morality Holmes would not seem to be guilty of murder if any of the passengers he threw in the water were to die. This is because he was doing what he believed to be morally right, and he was attempting to save the most lives in order to ultimately create the most happiness. It would not have been morally better for everyone to die together, because then that would create the least...

Other assignments on Utilitarianism And Kant's Categorical Imperative

Slavery In The Chocolate Industry Essay

3469 words - 14 pages action that the individual chooses in his situation is what he believes (and would accept for) anyone else to replicate providing that the latter person is in an identical situation at the time of his action (79). Applying Kant's first categorical imperative to the cocoa farmers, it is surmisable that they would also will for anyone whose existence was under threat to resort to the same measures as they. However, the imperative does not succeed

The Ford Pinto Case From A Utilitarian And Deontological Perspective

885 words - 4 pages good behaviour is through good intentions, so an act is morally right if you meant to do the right thing by doing it, both in terms of inner motivation and in the consequences to the rights of others. He said we should all act according to a series of categorical imperatives, and that is the road to moral rightness. Kant gave three formulations of a categorical imperative. The first formulation states that you should act as though you want the


1541 words - 7 pages life for people. Another side to ethics which is different from Kant's view is utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is about promoting happiness and pleasure with having the absence of pain. The main goals for utilitarianism is for pleasure and the freedom from pain. These are the only things desirable as goals because any other thing that may be desirable is because it is pleasurable and does not have any pain. This also says not only to think of your

Business Ethics

1356 words - 6 pages : Utilitarianism - Focuses on the consequences of one’s actions or decisions Justice - Focuses on fairness in the distribution of benefits and harms (distributive justice) and in the application of processes (procedural justice) that result from one’s decisions or actions. Deontological Approaches - Focus on “universal ethical principles” e.g., human rights, Kant’s Categorical Imperative. Act Utilitarianism is… Consequentialist i.e., The “rightness” or

The Movie “Blood Work” Deontological And Utilitarian Analysis

2174 words - 9 pages Categorical Imperative route almost every time. In the beginning of the movie, we are introduced to the main character in his post-op condition and while he is being dragged towards a testing room. He notices a child in a room with his father by his bed-side and immediately starts to wonder why the child had not received the heart instead of him. This is a highly moral, gallant way of thinking and falls right in line with the basic Deontological

Public Affairs

3492 words - 14 pages the nature of law ❖ Control: Possibly exceptions (cultural differences in ordering society) limits and avoid offending other. It is harmful to ordered society. (4) Immanuel kant: deontology ❖ Primary domain: Actions – what should I do? ❖ Principle: The categorical imperative, act only on the maxim principle which you could be willing to have everyone act upon and other versions. ❖ Source value: rationality and the

Exploring Psychological And Ethical Egoism

347 words - 2 pages Exploring Psychological and Ethical Egoism I disagree Kant’s philosophy when he assumed his criticism of speculative reason that whatever is universal and necessary in our knowledge must come from the mind itself, and not from the world of reality outside us. Like Utilitarianism, Kant’s moral theory is grounded in a theory of intrinsic value. But where the utilitarian take happiness, conceived of as pleasure and the absence of pain to be

Business And Management Kantian Ethics

1704 words - 7 pages Kantian Ethical Analysis Kantian ethics are perhaps one of the world most loved branch of ethical philosophy. It is to some extent the Eden lost of moral philosophy, for it argues that moral requirements are based on established standards of rationality, reason and dignity embedded in Categorical Imperative and whereas, immorality is somewhat a violation of moral philosophy and is not embedded in Categorical Imperative, which is self

Introduction To Business Ethics

4762 words - 20 pages person is inclined to lie and in which lying would lead to unwanted consequences. According to Kant, it is not an action that is moral or not, but the subjective principle, or maxim, that underlies it that determines that is the determining factor. If the belief and intent align with the categorical imperative, the actor is considered to have behaved ethically even if unintended negative consequences result. Kant developed several versions of the

Social, Legal, And Ethical Issues In The Information Age

5310 words - 22 pages clearly the facts; (2) define the conflict or dilemma and identify the higher order values involved; (3) identify the stakeholders; (4) identify the options you can reasonably take, and (5) identify the potential consequences of your options. 5. Identify and describe six ethical principles. The six ethical principles include the golden rule, Immanuel Kant's Categorical Imperative, Descartes' rule of change, the Utilitarian Principle


1313 words - 6 pages unethical part of the given case are that there are over 400,000 members worldwide that pay annual dues. They receive a very small fee for being web based providing their votes and input. The ethical problems that need questioned are: how much are they getting paid? What information are they researching to help the organization? Why are they web based? Where does all the money go that is paid by members? Immanuel Kant’s categorical imperative theory

Similar Documents

Resisitinf Organizational Level Essay

1521 words - 7 pages Utilitarianism "According to act-utilitarianism, it is the value of the consequences of the particular act that counts when determining whether the act is right. Bentham's theory is act-utilitarian, and so is that of J.J.C. Smart. One objection to act-utilitarianism is that it seems to be too permissive, capable of justifying any crime, and even making it morally obligatory, if only the value of the particular consequences of the particular

The Golden Rule Vs. Categorical Imperative

1509 words - 7 pages a way that benefits others while also benefiting themselves, they are not acting truly moral according to Kant’s definition. For example, doctors help cure diseases and save human lives for profit. Although they save human lives, the fact that they profit off of that act makes it not wholly moral according to Kant. Kant believes, under the categorical imperative, that all humans should be treated as ends, not means. By this, Kant explains that

Blood For Sale Essay

1262 words - 6 pages develop an emotional bond with the patient. The third consultant tries to assess this matter from the points discussed in Kant's Categorical Imperative. This individual states that the perfect duty does not allow a person to sell blood as the basic duty of a human being is to help others. If it were universal, then every person in this world would intent to sell his blood to the patients in need. This violates the basic norms of the perfect duty

Ethics Essay

878 words - 4 pages consist of commands. They think that what makes morality to be justified and true is the positive outcome to human beings. Deontological Deontological theory has at least three important features. The first is duty should be done for duty's sake. Meaning the rightness or wrongness of an act or rule. Secondly, humans should be treated as objects of intrinsic moral value. Finally, a moral principle is a categorical imperative that is