This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Utilitarianism Essay

1497 words - 6 pages

Theodore Rapanu
Introduction to Ethics - Utilitarianism
WC: 1406
TA: Jonatan Sennai Larsson

Utilitarianism is the view that actions are morally right if and only if they maximize utility, where utility is defined as the balance of pleasure to pain. In this sense, utilitarianism is hedonistic – it considers pleasure to be the singular good, and pain the singular bad. Pleasures and pains are episodic, and the magnitude of their effect on utility is dependent on both duration and intensity. Utilitarianism is universalistic, so the pleasures and pains of all beings capable of sensation are considered and weighted equally. Finally, utilitarianism is consequentialist. In other words, ...view middle of the document...

Humans ought to have higher aspirations than a simple maximization of pleasure. To further illustrate this objection, Nozick presents the idea of an experience machine – a device that is able to simulate experiences that are indistinguishable from reality. This machine has knobs which regulate the intensity and duration of the pleasure they generate. Nozick then supposes that a dictator is given the option of connecting his subjects to experience machines with the pleasure intensity and duration turned to the maximum. According to Nozick, the dictator is obligated to connect his subjects to the experience machines under a utilitarian framework, as this would maximize pleasure (and therefore utility). Nozick claims that this result is intuitively wrong, as being connected to the machines would rob subjects of the things that make life worth living. He concludes that utilitarianism is therefore ‘the doctrine of swine’. In fact, Nozick’s experience machine argument is poorly formulated.
If we take the experience machine as Nozick constructs it (as a device delivering raw pleasure), its use does not in fact maximize utility. The experience of pleasure results from an increase in the level of particular neurotransmitters in the brain. A constant influx of these chemicals (as would be delivered by the experience machine) would disturb homeostasis, and neurons would respond by desensitizing. That is, the individual receiving the machine’s raw pleasure would become less and less responsive to the point of satiation. This process is equivalent to the development of drug tolerance or the experience of an unpleasant odor slowly fading after prolonged exposure – as the brain becomes accustomed to a continued stimulus, its response diminishes. At this point of satiation, ‘maximum pleasure’ becomes the new norm for the subject, and utility drops to zero. Put simply, pleasure cannot exist without a less pleasurable point of reference. Some degree of pain may actually be necessary to maximize utility. Connecting individuals to this type of machine would be immoral under utilitarianism.
One might respond by introducing modifications to the machine – say we allow the individual to select their experiences (or vary them in a manner which maximizes utility). Rather than producing a constant euphoria, the machine might generate more authentic and rewarding experiences. Individuals could experience the same sensory and intellectual pleasures they would have in the real world, only inside the machines. The machines might enable the users to live the same life they would have normally lived – perhaps this is the path that generates the greatest utility anyway. A complaint that even these perfect simulations limit users to a ‘man-made’ reality which lacks depth is simply a mischaracterization. A perfect simulation is undetectable to the subject – he misses nothing by being connected to the machine, and the dictator is right to connect his subjects (or at the very...

Other assignments on Utilitarianism

Compare The Similarities And Differences Between Virtue Theory, Utilitarianism, And Deontological Ethics

665 words - 3 pages Ethics Essay Sandra Faye ETH/316 March 6, 2012 Irma Flores-Brothers Ethics Essay Ethics is the science of right and wrong in human action.” (Boyle, 2009, Chapter 1, Living in a World of Values). The overall purpose of this paper is to compare the similarities and differences between the three major approaches in normative ethics; virtue theory, utilitarianism, and

Ethics Paper

781 words - 4 pages completely removed from our life, such as an exotic vacation. Other pleasures can be long-lasting and can broaden our horizons, such as obtaining a degree. People should seek the higher intellectual pleasures rather than those lower pleasures obtained through sensation in order to truly achieve happiness. Utilitarianism is a belief that tends to view the total well-being of society as precedence. There are two types of Utilitarianism beliefs and


369 words - 2 pages Act Utilitarianism Act Utilitarianism defines moral right and wrong in terms of specific acts. To determine the right action for a particular situation, we must consider our possible choices of action and determine which choice would produce the greatest overall utility in its outcome. In assessing an act’s effects or outcome, we must consider both the utility and disutility as these relate to the scope, which includes all those


645 words - 3 pages 1 Virtue Theory, Utilitarianism, and Deontological Ethics. Judith Glowinski ETH/316 - 4/16/2013 MARY CARTER 2 When comparing the similarities and differences between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontology we find that they all deal with how one judge’s morality and ethics. These theories all include judging in different aspects, whether it is in the moment, what happens after, or over a lifetime. The ethics and

Comparing Ethics And Morality

413 words - 2 pages good character traits, such as kindness and generosity. These character traits will, in turn, allow a person to make the correct decisions later on in life. (Cline, 2013) Utilitarianism is the morally correct course of action that affects the greater good, without a regard to benefits or burdens. According to utilitarianism, morality is a matter of the non-moral good produced that results from moral actions, rules, and moral duty are instrumental

Week 2

404 words - 2 pages Week one reading helps understand and compare the similarities and differences between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. As we include a description of the differences in how each theory addresses ethics and morality. Then concluding in a personal experience to explain the relationship between virtue, values, and moral concepts as they relate to one of the three theories. “Utilitarianism is the theory that

Ethics Essay

716 words - 3 pages know what to belief and who to follow. Throughout this paper, I will discuss the similarities and differences between virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. These similarities and differences will include a description of the differences in how each theory addresses ethics and morality. They will also include a personal experience to explain the relationship between virtues, values, and moral concepts as they relate to one of


1541 words - 7 pages I wanted to approach both Kantianism vs. Utilitarianism for those who are not students of ethics words like utilitarianism and Kantianism may sound little foreign but for those are trying to tackle the world of ethics then these two represent important viewpoints. There are many similarities between utilitarianism and Kantianism but some can confuse some people. However, there are important differences between the two philosophies that I will

Evaluate A Utilitarian Approach To Abortion

1333 words - 6 pages Abortion, the deliberate termination of a pregnancy, has been the subject of discussion and controversy for many decades. Utilitarianism is the chief teleological ethical theory today which considers the consequences of an action; such as abortion. This ethical approach to abortion is useful because it determines that “an action is right if it produces the greatest good for the greatest number”. It considers the hedonic calculus, designed by

Resisitinf Organizational Level

1521 words - 7 pages Utilitarianism "According to act-utilitarianism, it is the value of the consequences of the particular act that counts when determining whether the act is right. Bentham's theory is act-utilitarian, and so is that of J.J.C. Smart. One objection to act-utilitarianism is that it seems to be too permissive, capable of justifying any crime, and even making it morally obligatory, if only the value of the particular consequences of the particular

Ethics Essay

919 words - 4 pages Ethics Essay Sharon Batts ETH/316 February 10, 2014 Professor Heller Ethics Essay Ethical growth is an important instrument needed in today’s society. Virtue, deontological, and utilitarianism theories have similarities and differences. Each theory relates to morals and ethics in precise ways, just as virtue, values, and morality have a precise relationship with one another. Virtue theory relates to ethics by identifying the character

Similar Documents

Utilitarianism Essay

1910 words - 8 pages Is Pleasure, really the only thing in life we should focus on? For thousands of years, several moral agents have tried to construct multiple ethical theories that could potentially help other moral agents with the difficult and complicated task of determining what is morally right or wrong. In this paper, I will explain the fascinating ethical theory of Utilitarianism and discuss about two very influential people to Utilitarianism, who are

Utilitarianism Essay

406 words - 2 pages Using utilitarianism to analysis both costs and benefits of Ford may be considered as a moral and immoral action and this belongs to each person and each customer. Therefore, before making the last decision that whether redesign or not to ensure bringing the greatest benefits for the greatest people Ford’s managers should do several steps below. First, they should examine preference of customers to research what they want. Then, they collect

Utilitarianism Essay

992 words - 4 pages  Utilitarianism Essay Shirnel Charles Grand Canyon University: PHI-305 Ethical Thinking in Liberal Arts Instructor John Wise September 21, 2014 The Story of Ethics states that the point of the Utilitarian theory is to conceptualize exactly what is good life by “bringing about consequences of a certain sort that is the greatest happiness for the greatest number” (The Story of Ethics). The Story of Ethics also states that the Utilitarian

Utilitarianism And Kant's Categorical Imperative Essay

1368 words - 6 pages Utilitarianism and Kant’s Categorical Imperative The issues of morality are most clearly expressed through examples of different methods of analyzing a situation. The case of Holmes, an officer in charge of a sinking ship, shows the striking differences between philosopher Immanuel Kant’s beliefs and those of the Utilitarians. After Holmes’ ship sinks, there are twenty passengers in a lifeboat that is only meant to hold fourteen people