This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tort Case Essay

555 words - 3 pages

Case Facts
Geraldine Cruze was struck by large pieces of the ceiling in her apartment. She then rushed to the Jacobi Hospital Emergency Room reporting abdominal pain. After seven hours, the hospital released Cruze. She returned home and rested. However, the hospital failed to detect that Cruze had suffered four broken ribs, a lacerated renal vein and other internal injuries. Despite the pain and difficulty of breathing, Cruze herself did not notice these serious internal injuries, and she believed that she was recovering. Cruze was in fact bleeding internally. Over the next three days, she bled to death. Cruze’s attorney sued the hospital for medical malpractice and the landlord for negligence.
From The Hospital’s Perspective
The potential liability for the hospital is the neglect of the plaintiff’s internal injuries. The hospital is ...view middle of the document...

It would be very difficult for the hospital to defense from these two aspects. In order to minimize the liability, the hospital could argue that it did not breach the duty because the plaintiff only reported abdominal pain. It performed effective treatment regarding abdominal pain. The death of the plaintiff did not result from the abdominal pain. The hospital had no reason to check the patient’s ribs and renal vein in an abdominal pain case. The hospital could also state that there might be other reasons, which finally cause the death of the plaintiff. It might be that the plaintiff’s improper lifestyle worsened her internal injuries. The plaintiff also ignored her pain and difficulty of breathing. She is responsible for not return to the hospital for further physical examination.
From The Landlord’s Perspective
The potential liability for the landlord is the neglect of the defective ceiling, which is the direct cause of the injuries of the plaintiff. The landlord has the responsibility to provide a safe and livable environment to all his/her tenants. The plaintiff’s attorney would argue that the defect of the ceiling resulted in the injuries of the plaintiff. A negligent party who harms another is responsible for all consequences of the injuries, even later malpractice during treatment.
Among the four elements of negligence, owe a duty of care and injury to another are two elements showed very obvious in this case. It would be very difficult for the landlord to defense from these two aspects. In order to minimize the liability, the landlord could argue that it did not breach the duty because it has no reason to check tenant’s ceiling on a daily basis. The tenants have the responsibility to report any defects noticed in the apartment to the landlord. The landlord could also state that defective ceiling did not directly cause the death of the plaintiff. The hospital and plaintiff herself were both responsible for the death.

Other assignments on Tort Case

Dorchester Democrat Sentenced To 6 Months In Assault Case

517 words - 3 pages Soriano-Mills had called the sentence harsh. In other words, this case has to do with assault and battery. The meaning of battery is to touch someone unlawfully. The definition of assault is the attempt to try to commit battery. Assault as a tort and a crime are different. A victim of a tort must know that the person that had committed the tort, meant to commit harm. Trying to commit harm is necessary when trying to establish fear. Assault

Contract Law Essay

5420 words - 22 pages | Assignment Title | Contract and Negligence | Assignment Number | 05AOCANFB- Y/601/0563-13 PKISL7002 | Hand In Policy You must complete this assignment on time. If u experience difficulties, you must inform your tutor accordingly. Late Work Policy Consideration will be given to students who have valid reasons for late submission (eg, Illness) Plagiarism In case of plagiarism, college regulations will be applied. You must declare

Business Law

725 words - 3 pages Introduction Within our second week of class discussion, we learned valuable information relating to business torts. Our main objectives that we were to acknowledge upon completion this week includes identifying potential tort risks that that arise in the business context. In addition, we learned the importance of applying the risk management to mitigate business risk. We also learned how to differentiate between types of torts, and when

Contract Administration Log Book

3519 words - 15 pages when there is a contract between both parties however the claimant seeks an advantage in framing the claim in tort. The most significant difference between contract and tort is the time period within which each claim must be brought before it’s barred by the limitation act of 1980. In many situations this results in an action in tort being the only way a case can be pursued. 6. Contractor’s/employers obligations 7.12 Terms of

Good Luck On This

352 words - 2 pages , claiming that his right to privacy had been violated when his emails were intercepted Tort (invasion of Privacy) III. Legal history of case The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. The court was not persuaded by the arguments and granted Pillsbury's motion to dismiss. IV. Issues on appeal. The employee’s privacy interests against the employer’s need to discover



Tax Research

924 words - 4 pages and professional reputation and for his mental suffering, would need to pay taxes for his compensation? Can Murray avoid reporting his award as Adjusted Gross Income? What portion, if any, can he deduct from his Adjusted Gross Income? These are all issues that arise when Murray was awarded his compensation for damages caused by his employer after being released. ANALYSIS: This case concerns what gross income is, accordingly gross income as

Law Of Business Association

1019 words - 5 pages a company, there is a Under S119 separate legal entity between the company and its member. Like the case Saloman v Saloman& Co Ltd. Under S119 a company comes into existence as a body corporate at the beginning of the day on which it is registered with the name specified in its certificate of registration. Under S124 a company has the legal capacity and power of an individual both in and outside this jurisdiction. Four consequences from

Foul Ball

596 words - 3 pages Foul Ball 1. What argument would you make on behalf of Emily that the owner of the baseball park had a legal obligation to protect her from wild baseballs? The land, for which the baseball park is on, is a public place. A public invitee is one who is invited and enters the land for the purpose for which the land is held open to the public, in this case a baseball field. The owner of this public land has a duty to protect his invitees

Case Study Coimplaints

1990 words - 8 pages . Thereafter, staff members pressured him to withdraw from the course, telling him that, "the only option is an Internet course.” The staff explained that the organization shared the facility with a charter elementary school, and they were concerned young students might witness something inappropriate. This type of case should be classified as an intentional Tort with Libel or Slander that would be attach to it. The unfortunate incident that


1222 words - 5 pages facts. However, the fact pattern that is depicted in the case scenario discloses an element of intrusion which is an electronic, physical or mechanical intrusion in another person’s private space (McWay, 2010). This form of tort requires that the complainant show that there was a wrongful intrusion into private concern. In essence, the invasion of privacy encompasses a person intruding into the private activities of another in a manner that

Similar Documents

Tort Essay

679 words - 3 pages Torts Shapo (2003) stated "A tort is a civil wrong in the sense that it is committed against an individual (which includes legal entities such as companies) rather than the state. The gist of tort law is that a person has certain interests which are protected by law. These interests can be protected by a court awarding a sum of money, known as damages, for infringe- ment of a protected interest. Alternatively, by the issuing of an injunction

Tort Law Essay

2334 words - 10 pages financial due to damage of this personal so that it is a compensate for the commission of the tort. Basically the Tort Law involves violation of the duty that is fixed by the law. According to the above Bolam medical case as I mentioned above will comes under this law because the doctor negligence due to violating of his duty and responsibility to identify the patient treatment requirements. For example the duty of the doctor responsible as

Bugusa Essay

256 words - 2 pages Yes a tort was committed it is defamation, because the company put out a statement to a third party the specific name of this defamation is called defamatory declaration which is defamation that happens when a person or company creates a fabricated, poor announcement about a third party, that assaults his or her personality. Scenario: WIRETIME, Inc. (Steve and Walter)-Stephanie Discuss any liability BUGusa

Case Study

1253 words - 6 pages Introduction: Aim The aim of this article is to examine the role of the Law of Tort in business activities assessing particular forms of tortuous liability and apply the elements of the Tort of Negligence. Scope It includes the nature of general tortuous liability,the nature of employer’s liability,the application of the elements of the Tort of Negligence and vicarious liability. Background to study Case study No. 1 Facts: A bus