This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Thinking Through Language Essay

1088 words - 5 pages

GE1132 Mind, brain and language 09.03.2015
Semester B 2014/2015
Rianne Okkema, 40070660

Mind, Brain and Language
Thinking through language (Bloom and Keil 2001)


My little nephew of two years old has begun talking in Frisian, the native language of people from the northern part of The Netherlands. For many people from this part of the country, Frisian and Dutch are their mother tongue because Dutch is the official language of The Netherlands. A lot of children, like my nephew, begin learning and speaking Dutch only when they enter school. In a couple of years my nephew will start his school life; will the change of knowing not one, but two languages in this young age ...view middle of the document...

The last distinction is about the effect language is said to have. I would say that language has a big effect on somebody’s life. Without any language, even your natural language, you wouldn’t be able to communicate and participate in any community.
When talking about the effects and non-effects of cross-linguistic differences, a couple of problems occur. For example, a scientific study of Whorf claims that differences in color word vocabulary cause difference in color perception. English speakers use two words for the color green and blue; speakers of a language that describes a color with a single word should be less sensitive to the distinction. However, cross-cultural research has revealed that this prediction is false; all people perceive and categorize color the same way. Another study of Alfred Bloom (1981) argued that counterfactual thought is more difficult in Chinese than languages such as English. Constructions like ‘if X were to do Y, then Z would happen’ have no easy translation. It turned out, however, that there were serious problems with the experimental design of this study, which made this argument invalid.
Next Paul Bloom and Frank Keil discuss the universal effects of language on thought. They have a look at the proposition in which natural language gives rise to an alternative representational medium with which to think, like inner speech, arithmetic reasoning and memory. Peter Carruthers (1996) has suggested that certain types of thought, such as casual reasoning and social cognition, require the support of an internalized language. Knowledge of a natural language cannot be necessary for all causal and social reasoning, since non-linguistic creatures, such as babies and chimpanzees, have competence in these domains. But certain developmental phenomena may be explained by this proposal. In other domains, however, the original inner voice proposal may have considerable benefits. It seems likely, following Dehaene (1997), that the ability to reason about the larger numbers requires language. To understand that if you remove two objects from twenty objects, eighteen will remain is impossible without the possession of natural language. Without language, all that remains is the approximate accumulator mechanism that humans share with rats and other animals.

Opinion
Paul...

Other assignments on Thinking Through Language

Language Essay

2341 words - 10 pages fact, human being learns language from he or she was an infant. An infant is first exposed to language through sounds generated by the environment and languages spoken by the adults surrounding him. As I observe my 9 months old son, he starts babble when he was 6 months old now he is more talkative event tough he can only say baba papa mama or dada. But I always replying what he says in order to make him feel respected, to teach him Bahasa and I

Comm Essay

874 words - 4 pages nonverbal communication would be the tone of a person’s voice, body language, or even eye contact. Nonverbal communication may be difficult to express through things such as text messaging or e-mail but people have used symbols which can represent a certain type of emotion like using all capital letters or over exaggerating punctuations. In Ch. 7 of Working in Groups, it explains that scientist believe that men and women think differently

Heat Burget

2416 words - 10 pages . Convergent thinking is useful in situations when there is a single best correct answer and the answer can be discovered through analyzing available stored information. Multiple choice questions on school exams are examples of convergent thinking. Examples of Convergent and Divergent Thinking Suppose that you worked 48 miles away from your house and needed to save money. You talk to your friends and find out that 12 of your coworkers save $60

Communication Collaboration Reflection

743 words - 3 pages Communication Collaboration Reflection SOC/110 September 15, 2014 Communication Communication at its very basic form started with gestures and grunts. Over the centuries it has taken more paths to communicate with different cultures and backgrounds. Music, pictures, writing, talking, and even sign language have bridged gaps that were once hard to overcome for some people. But body language has always been a constant, you can

English Advanced For Business B

1581 words - 7 pages case 4 My language use & development 5 Recommendations 5 Conclusions 6 References 7 Appendices 8 Appendices 1 8 Appendices 2 10 Appendices 3 12 Executive Summary Firstly, the report analysed participation and group work in two parts. It has expressed that how to be participation in a group and theorises or experiences of group works. Following that, it has discussed evaluation of group study and individual development

Verbal And Nonverbal Communication Skills

995 words - 4 pages through our body language are two totally different things. When faced with these mixed signals, the listener has to choose whether to believe your verbal or nonverbal message, and, in most cases, they're going to choose the nonverbal because it's a natural, unconscious language that broadcasts our true feelings and intentions in any given moment. The way you listen, look, move, and react tells the other person whether or not you care, if you’re

About Research

1540 words - 7 pages • Especially avoid the use of abbreviations – For (a bad) example: ”EEG, EMG, and ECG has not been used in HCI to analyse user’s ability for CMC via these methods. I will not use these not so much but EEG could be used.” TAUCHI – Tampere Unit for Computer-Human Interaction Language • Write allways how things are, were, or will be • Writing through negative sentences creates negative implications in the reader • In science we are to say and find

Learning As A Social Process

2077 words - 9 pages through biologically determined learning stages, Vygotsky called attention to the ways in which social environments influence this learning process. Vygotsky proposed the idea that learning and development take place in the interactions children have with peers as well as with teachers and other adults. These social interactions develop language—which supports thinking—and they provide feedback and assistance that support ongoing learning. In a

Active Listening

1005 words - 5 pages up straight or lean forward slightly to show your attentiveness through body language. 2. Maintain eye contact, to the degree that you all remain comfortable. 3. Minimize external distractions. Turn off the TV. Put down your book or magazine, and ask the speaker and other listeners to do the same. 4. Respond appropriately to show that you understand. Murmur (“uh-huh” and “um-hmm”) and nod. Raise your eyebrows. Say words such as “Really

Different Types Of Intelligence

2108 words - 9 pages ” or rounded. Furthermore, it is true that most of the intelligences in Gardner’s list can be developed. For instance, people can attend workshops to develop interpersonal skills that involve teaching and counselling. In the same way, a scientific way of thinking can be developed through practice, training and exposure to the language and conventions of scientific thinking. 3rd view: Intelligence can be developed. As seen in the above comment

Explain The Role Of Effective Communication And Interpersonal Interaction In A Health And Social Care Context

1796 words - 8 pages going to say about how you feel or what you are thinking about. You put your thoughts or language you send the message- you speak, or perhaps sign or write, or send your message in another way. Message received, the other person has to sense your message, they hear the words or see your symbols. Message decoded, the other person has to interpret or decode your message. This is not always easy as the other person will

Similar Documents

Thinking And Decision Making Essay

1623 words - 7 pages can result in significant consequence or benefits. Many thinking styles exist with many similarities and dissimilarities. Persuasive, creative and scientific thinking styles offer techniques for problem solving. Individuals using various forms of critical thinking may be unaware of the techniques employed. Strength in problem solving is gained through exploring and learning about three of the many thinking styles. Comparing and Contrasting

Introduction To Cross Cultural Psychology Essay

1502 words - 7 pages Introduction to Cross-Cultural Psychology University of Phoenix Introduction to Cross-Cultural Psychology Culture plays an important part in one’s life as it relates to the field of psychology. Culture enables one to define him or herself and differ from one to another, and helps one survive. Culture facilitates self-expression, through language

Nature Of Thought Paper

740 words - 3 pages .   Memory is another significant factor of the thinking process. Memory assist individuals decipher information that has been stored in the short and long term memory. It also assists with processing information in multiple situations and recognizes concepts that has taken place in the past and build our future.   The final part of thinking, the medium, is considered the most vital and is the part that transfers into the brain. Language is part

Code Mixing And Code Swicthing In Learnin Activities

3940 words - 16 pages CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION 1.1. Background of the Study Language is important to communication between human. Many students speak more than one language in their classroom activities, even if their study about English language. During their learning activities, they switch or mix between two or more than language. Even the differences between two languages are great, there is a possibility to mix and switch the languages. For example