The Role Of Ethics In Business Evolution

1680 words - 7 pages

The Role of Ethics in Business Evolution
Reconciling works of Managerial Literature, Business Ethics Writer and Catholic Social Teaching, Domènec Melé argued that a firm should be considered as a wholesome person and suggested the ethical implications of his view (Melé, 2012). The concept that a firm should be regarded as a legal person, and not just a profit seeking entity, was brought forth by the House of Lords in the (Salomon v. A. Salomon & Co. Ltd., 1897) case, paving the way for modern firms. Melé’s argument was revolutionary in that he considered the firm a wholesome person, bearing moral responsibilities for communities that it may potentially affect. This response paper aims ...view middle of the document...

However, the idea that individuals will place the firm’s interest above theirs could have been more compelling. Apart from quoting numerous papers, Melé included a case study on Southwest Airlines done by Jody Gittell in 2003 to provide evidence on this behaviour. Gittell’s case showed how the employees of the firm, from management to front-line workers, cared for each other and placed the interests of others within the same community above theirs. Nonetheless, it is only one case study against many scandals such as Enron, Worldcom and the 2008 Chinese Milk Scandal. However, Southwest Airlines differ from Enron et al. in that relationship with employees is one of their two main commitments. The other commitment is the relationship with customers. Probing further, I came to pass with a causality dilemma. Should we regard a firm a human community because it values relationship or should we require firms to value relationships and hence, ethics, because it is a human community.
Fortunately for me, the next part of Melé’s paper uses the latter to convince and challenge managers of firms to change their management philosophy to the one based on the “community of persons” model. It begins with discussing what it means to be a community, and later on, a “community of persons”, and then concludes with the ethical implications.
In the Managerial Literature section of the paper, cooperation is being emphasized as the ideal core of management. Power-with management and transformational leadership, both considered paradigms of management, pivots around cooperation. Solomon, a Business Ethics writer, stated that working interrelations will determine the efficiency of the organisation. Personally, I agree with his view and I think that it is value adding relationships that creates value adding activities. Thus, efficiency of the activities in the organisation depends on the efficiency of the relationships.
Philosophically, being a community means helping people you associate with, empathising with them. Melé accepts the Aristotle’s view that humans came together not for the sake of self-interests, but for the preservation of another’s interest that would contribute for the common good. The common good will upheld will protect every individual’s self interest in the community.
The three types of unifying relationships, utilitarian, emotional and virtuous, presented yet another view of human interactions (Melé, 2012). I think there is a fair chance that the reasonable person would regard a utilitarian approach as self-serving, and emotional as altruistic by virtue of the words used. In fact, the author meant it the other way round. Utilitarian involves working with others towards a common goal for the utility of the community, and thus, is not entirely self-serving in nature. A virtuous relationship brings about a common goal for the common good of the community, and since there is a chance that the common good will benefit the individual, albeit...

Other assignments on The Role Of Ethics In Business Evolution

Ethics In Business Communication Essay

459 words - 2 pages Ethics and Credibility in Business Communications In 2009, Toyota was accused of ignoring safety concerns in regards to faulty brakes and acceleration pedals which sent the car manufacturer into a public relations crisis. Toyota continued to blame the sticking pedals on faulty floor mats, not electrical error and was found to delay the recall process in order to save money. In order to avoid a massive recall, Toyota ignored Consumer complaints

Importance Of Business Ethics Essay

1408 words - 6 pages about good and evil by means of which we guide our behaviour. However, for his presentation he used the terms interchangeably for his examination of local businesses in an attempt to shed light on the development of the moral values and business ethics of Jamaican corporations. "In understanding Jamaican business ethics or moral values it is important to trace the evolution of the morality of local businesses that have a long history to observe the

The Role Of Women In The Church

773 words - 4 pages DeRon N. Collins 2/25/13 Short Essay 3 Theology 202 B-26 The Role of Women in the Church Since women entered public ministry and became pastor’s debates on this issue has raged like a wild forest fire. I have been studying the bible now for over thirteen years and I have seen God move through people throughout the bible and have not seen anyone or thing God could not use. I have seen God use prostitutes in the lineage of our Savior

The Role Of Leaders In Innovation

1051 words - 5 pages What drives a successful business? Motivated employees, a strong business structure, strategies, and capabilities to name a few factors. But the most important factor of a successful business that puts all these together is an innovative leader. Innovative leaders motivate employees, form a strong business structure, come up with strategies and make them form into a reality or final product. I. How leadership models support innovation in

Role Of Government In The U.S

549 words - 3 pages I am a nurse and I run my own home healthcare business, and I believe that healthcare is an indispensable part of our society. I believe that healthcare is a right because all people should have access to healthcare and the stability and security that comes from knowing you will be treated if you are in need. Healthcare is a right because all people should have access to healthcare and security in knowing they can be healed. It could be deduced

Business Ethics Study Poerty In America

1606 words - 7 pages Week 3 Case Study 3.3 Poverty in America Stacey Curry Business Ethics Upper Iowa University Professor Kalai McHan TRY TO TURN POVERTY TO POSITIVE In the time of the Great Depression back in 1930’s, where a time where four million Americans had fallen into poverty. Then in 2008 the economy experienced a serious economic meltdown crisis and recession, at this time 44 million adults now live below the poverty line officially defined as an

The Evolution Of Fire Investigation

480 words - 2 pages The Evolution of Fire Investigation and Its Impact on Arson Cases Journal Article by Kevin Weitzel Arson investigation is an ever changing field of science and crime investigation. Arson investigators need to be highly educated in their field and unfortunately most are not properly educated resulting in many high profile cases being unfinished or citizens being wrongly convicted. This paper will cover an article by John J. Lentini

Role And Functions Of Business Law

843 words - 4 pages The Role and Functions of Business Law Tanisha Haynes LAW/421 July 18, 2013 Ms. Lindsey Cole The Role and Functions of Business Law When people hear the word law, one will think of the laws in which people have to abide by on a daily basis. There are several different variations to the laws; there are states laws. Each state has their own rules for their citizens to follow. Then there is the Federal law, which governs the government

The Role Of The Engineer In The Value Chain

1541 words - 7 pages Demand Chain are researched and in the second part, a particular industry sector will be taken into consideration to shed light on the role of engineering and by that reveal the importance of engineering in the management of Value Chain. (Porter 1985) Introduction Nowadays enterprises are facing a number of issues to maintain and expand their business. With those that manufacture goods or provide services should be aware of the importance of Value

The Role Of Imagination In The Romantic Poetry

303 words - 2 pages , external and internal experience. Or as William Wordsworth would say that ‘[...] poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings.’ The poet therefore assumed the role of the mediator between man and nature. The role of the poet was arguably in place to showcase beauty, truth and the endless possibilities that tradition had previously encased. Within this new enlightened form of expression in literature, the imagination had been elevated to a

The Influence Of Law In Business

936 words - 4 pages The Influence of Law in Business Practice Intro to Business & Technology March 23, 2014 The Influence of Law in Business Practice There are several laws in the United States that are meant to set a standard for fair, balanced, and competitive business practices. These are, by design, a way to ensure that trade- international as well as domestic- is done in a reputable and progressive fashion. There are many aspects that come in to

Similar Documents

The Evolution Of Business Essay

1390 words - 6 pages The Evolution of Business Jennifer Sterkenburg OMM 640: Business Ethics and Social Responsibility Instructor Whitten September 4, 2013 The Evolution of Business Since the term “business” became a word everyone was familiar with, the purpose and principle behind business ethics and values was created. Even though no one in this day and age can be 100% sure how businesses were created, and how entrepreneurs were able to provide a sense of

The Role Of Business Economics In National Development

2924 words - 12 pages economic and social progress required to impact the well being of the average Nigerian given that over half of Nigeria‟s population live on less than one dollar a day. Nigeria is also one of the top three countries in the world that have the largest population of poor people. In addition, Nigeria remains off track on achieving the Millennium Development Goals THE ROLE OF BUSINESS ECONOMICS IN NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT Following this introduction on

Business Ethics In Workplace Essay

489 words - 2 pages Business ethics in workplace Nowadays in many workplaces managers have to deal with several ethical and moral issues such as harassment, theft and equality. Along with the management role, managers have to make sure they maintain a good amount of moral and ethical values. Managers have to show fairness to all employees. Harassment is one of the biggest ethical and moral problems managers are faced with today. Also, it does not matter what

Ethics In Business Essay

819 words - 4 pages Ethics in business: Author: Institution: Introduction. Ethics have been defines as the discipline that differentiates between what is good from what is bad. Ethics are a set of moral principle or value. Ethics assist individuals to make moral decisions when faced with any kind of situation. In business, ethics assist individuals in applying ethical considerations when making any decisions. Ethics regarding the carrying on of business have