Steve Forbes Essay

1246 words - 5 pages

Case Overview and Product Description
In December of 2011, 14 year old Anais Fournier purchased and consumed two 24 oz Monster Energy drinks within one 24 hour period. This is the equivalent of 6 servings for an adult. She went into cardiac arrest the night of December 17th and died the evening of December 18th. Her parents sue Monster for damages on the basis of Strict Liability and Negligence.
Monster is sold as dietary supplements instead of food item, so it is not as strictly regulated. It is marketed as a supplement that increases energy, promotes focus, and helps with weight loss. The drink contains an excessive amount of caffeine and other drugs that combine to increase heart ...view middle of the document...

The 48 oz of Monster did not spill in Ms. Fournier’s mouth and cause the fatal damage. She made a conscious choice to drink extremely large quantities to induce drug like effects to her own physical and mental state.
What defenses can Monster assert against the claim that its beverages are unreasonably dangerous?
Under the doctrine of Strict Liability, a product must be considered unreasonably dangerous, which means it does not meet the reasonable expectations of the ordinary consumer, in order for a plaintiff to recover damages. The plaintiff asserts that Monster drinks have an unreasonable level of caffeine. As a food item the caffeine is unreasonable; it has the same amount as multiple cups of coffee. However, Monster drinks are sold as food, but as dietary supplements. Each 24 oz can contains 240mg of caffeine, within the daily limits for the average adult. It’s intended use is for adults who need an unnatural boost for a night of parties, a night of work, or a day at the gym. For well hydrated and reasonable adults, one Monster drink is suitable for casual consumption and is not dangerous.
Monster Energy is not intended to be used by 14 year olds. According to the Investor Place article by James Brumley titled, “Monster Beverage-Linked Deaths: Tragic? Yes. Lawsuit-Worthy? No.”, teenagers are attracted to abusing anything that can alter their physical, mental, and emotional states. This is evident in high rates of alcohol use, premature sex, drug use, and thrill seeking behaviors by teenagers. Teenagers engage in these behaviors for the pleasure of living life on the edge. For this reason, teenagers cannot be considered reasonable people. Ms. Fournier, by no means the average and reasonable consumer, consciously abused the drink. Monster cannot be held accountable under Strict Liability for the abusive actions of a thrill seeking teen.
Are there any defenses based on the element of proximate cause?
Proximate Cause is an element of causation, which is necessary to prove both Negligence and Strict Liability. It defines events that are substantially related to the injury of the plaintiff. In order for there to be proximate cause, the event must be something the defendant could have reasonably foreseen. Anything that has happened in the past with substantial frequency falls in the scope of foreseeability. According to the NY Times article by Barry Meier titled, “F.D.A. Posts Injury Data for 3 Drinks,” there have been 5 fatalities involving Monster Energy as well ad thousands of ER visits. The numerous accounts of harm caused by Monster Energy were likely a result of product abuse. Due to numerous accounts of product abuse, it becomes foreseeable.
What duties,...

Other assignments on Steve Forbes

Brand Audit On Samsung Essay

2468 words - 10 pages conducted our survey and did our primary research,we realized that the company is known for its traits but it is still in the process of becoming synonymous with a “brand personality trait”.We would like to mention here that Samsung has made a strong name for itself as “an innovative brand”. Marketing to Support the Brand Positioning Forbes ranks Samsung on number nine while its biggest competitor i.e Apple is ranked at number one.It’s

Case Study Of Apply

7638 words - 31 pages headquartered in Apple California located in California, U.S. Apple was established in April 1976 by Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak and was incorporated in January 1977. The company designs and later sells consumer electronics, personal computers and computer software. The Macintosh range of personal computers, iPod, iphone and the iPad are among the Apple’s best known products. Some of the software sold by the company includes Final cut studio that

Nfl Concussion Litigation

8282 words - 34 pages ’ – Moves Forward in Philly Legal Newsline.” N. p., n.d. Web. 2 May 2014. Fainaru-Wada, Mark, and Steve Fainaru. League of Denial: The NFL, Concussions, And The Battle For Truth. New York: Crown Archetype, 2013. 280-82. Print. Farrar, Doug. "Judge Anita Brody Denies Preliminary Approval for NFL Concussion settlement | Audibles - SI.com." Audibles SIcom RSS. Sports Illustrated, 14 Jan. 2014. Web. 02 May 2014. Fenno, Nathan. “Ray Easterling’s Death

Mgt216

714 words - 3 pages The first ethical issue presented in the ethics game simulation was whether to warn consumers about the contaminated product and what information to provide consumers about the contaminant. The second ethical issue was whether to sell a product that does not meet U.S. safety requirements in a foreign market that has lower safety restrictions. G-BioSport was not required to meet prior approval from the Federal Drug Administration before they

Economy Effect Of Marijuana

277 words - 2 pages Modern American History by Alan Renga 2nd Mid Term! You will be given 3 Short Essay questions and 20 Multiple Choice questions deriving from this list! 80 points total! The 1920s Warren Harding then Calvin Coolidge Tea Pot Dome 1st Red Scare Immigration Restriction, Sacco and Vanzetti Langston Hughes, Marcus Garvey, KKK Prosperity, advertising Prohibition, Al Capone Flappers, Clara Bow, Rudolph Valentino Babe Ruth, Jack Dempsey

The Vc Shakeout

2033 words - 9 pages —VCs posted average quarterly returns of 22%. Research by University of Chicago economists Steve Kaplan and Antoinette Scholar found that VC funds outperformed the S&P 500 on a capital-weighted basis over the same time period. But the value proposition of the VC industry toward its two clients—investors and entrepreneurs—has since weakened. For one thing, VC has never recovered from the commercialization of the internet, which brought a

Hospitals Paper

6014 words - 25 pages I hope to provide in this paper a comprehensive understanding for what the term “hospital” has become. Hospitals are an extremely complex system that man has created and shaped and reshaped throughout history. My goal in writing and researching this paper will be to provide those who read it a clear understanding on how the hospital system got to where it is today, and to shed some light on the many organizations that affiliate with and

Course Syllabus

2610 words - 11 pages [pic] COURSE SYLLABUS Semester: Fall, Year: 2012  College Mission Statement Richard J. Daley College provides high-quality education which leads to academic success, career development, and personal enrichment that fulfill diverse community needs. Mathematics Department Mission Statement Our mission is to deliver excellent service and to provide learning opportunities by offering a wide range of mathematics courses, which will help our

Management

1477 words - 6 pages Boeing Management Planning Heather Oetzel MGT 330 October 22, 2012 Joe Cheng Abstract Boeing is known as “the world’s leading aerospace company and the largest manufacturer of commercial jetliner and military aircraft combined ("The Boeing Company: About Us", 2012). Every company uses different types of management techniques including how the planning function of management is used. Planning allows organizations to develop how the

Assisted Suicide

1015 words - 5 pages Should physician-assisted suicide be legal? While I believe if one chooses to end his or own life through physician assistance for reasons that they chose, the choice should be up to the individual. Physician-assisted suicide should be at one's discretion. “Assisted Suicide, also called Voluntary Euthanasia, is currently a contentious issue in many countries. Because Euthanasia is legal in a few modern democracies: the Netherlands, Belgium

Tanglewood Case 1

797 words - 4 pages Tanglewood’s staffing strategy requires the organization to make key decisions about the acquisition, deployment, and retention of the organization’s workforce. In order to accomplish this, Tanglewood’s must make thirteen decisions regarding its staffing levels and its staffing quality. One of the first decisions that Tanglewood needs to choose is to acquire or develop talent. Tanglewood should try to develop their current talent because one

Similar Documents

Marketing Research Essay

1342 words - 6 pages | J.C. Penney’s Re-Marketing Plan | Did the company wait too long and make too fast decisions in re-marketing its brand? | | Aaron Dritz | 6/5/2015 | According to Forbes Magazine, in 2013, roughly 540,000 new businesses are started each month. Sadly, in most cases more businesses will end up being shut down in the same time frame (1 Nazar). In order to be the small 1/3 who will remain in business for 15 or more years, it is

Who Is Shakira? Essay

734 words - 3 pages Who is Shakira? Shakira, listed number 53 on the Forbes lost of most powerful women has been a big influence in the music industry. Her songs always top the charts and she is well known for her different way of singing. She is an inspiration to many people especially those of Hispanic descent, giving them hope that they as well can become like her. Shakira has stated in one interview "I have no idea of where I want to go musically, but I'm

Bill Gates Essay

1304 words - 6 pages William Henry "Bill" Gates III (born October 28, 1955) is an American business magnate, philanthropist, investor, computer programmer, and inventor.[3][4][5] Gates is the former chief executive and chairman of Microsoft, the world’s largest personal-computer software company, which he co-founded with Paul Allen. He is consistently ranked in the Forbes list of the world's wealthiest people[6] and was the wealthiest overall from 1995 to 2009

Dota Addiction Introduction Essay

2451 words - 10 pages is a free-to-play game, supported by micro-transactions. It was first announced on October 7, 2008, and released on October 27, 2009. League of Legends was generally well received at release, and has grown in popularity in the years since. According to a 2012 Forbes article, League of Legends is the most played PC game in the world in terms of the number of hours played. Disrupts - To