This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Statutory Interpretation Essay

1746 words - 7 pages

Statutes would be interpreted frequently by courts in modern time, Owing to the defect of ambiguity or language in legal terms, defect of statutes. Some amount of interpretation is necessary when the word of statute is ambiguity, sometimes, the content of statutes have a straightforward meaning. But the ambiguity of the words in the statutes must be solved by courts, it is true that have some ambiguity or have a unclear meaning of statutes' words in most case. Statutory interpretation allows the judge to have a clear meaning of what is meant by the statutes. Hence, statutory interpretation is an important process when the case is judging by court and courts would seek to interpret the ...view middle of the document...

Lord Reid said: "we often say that we are looking for the intention of Parliament, but that is not quite accurate. We are seeking the meaning of the words which Parliament used."(Lord Reid, Black-Clawson International Ltd v Papierwerke Waldhof-Aschaffenburg [1975]) When judges deal with cases, many words need to be given their straightforward meaning in the context of Act and cases. Judges may look for the words'primary or the most suitable meaning. Alternatively, Judegs may seek help to a dictionary that would give a definition of words.For example, In Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd; Hunter v London Docklands Development Corporation [1997] A.C.655, Where in Hunter Lord Cooke used the Concise Oxford Dictionary to give the defintion of " occupy". Whereas, although the word of statutes will be given their ordinary meaning by the courts, but regradless of whether this produce an absurd result, "If the words of an Act are clear then you must follow them even though they lead to a manifest absurdity. The court has nothing to do with whether the legislature has committed an absurdity. " (Per Lord Esher, R v. Judge of the City of London Court [1892]) if they find out the meaning that is not conformity with intention of Parliament, the Jedges will not refer to the meaning.Under this status, the golden rule will be used by courts. The golden rule is that give words their literal meaning, if this would lead to an absurd result, another interpetation would be given, Two forms of golden rule: Narrow appliaction is that the courts can only choose between the possbile meaning of word or phase, if this word only one meaning that must be taken. Another is wider appliaction, If words have only one ordinary meaning but that meaning would lead to an absurd result, the courts can use the golden rule to modify the words of a statute to avoid absurd result. For instance, In the case of Ex parte Walton [1881] 17 Ch.D. 746, the statute of s.23 of the Bankruptcy Act 1869 was used in this case and the court interprted it. The bankrupt person vested in his trusstee, however, the trustee denied the burdensome property in bankruptcy. The s.23 of the bankruptcy could be interpeted that the trustee denys property even if this would affect the third party rights for property. the court felt this interpetation that is not conformity with intention of Parliament, they considerred that the statute must be modified and read as means that the thired party rignts will not be hinderred if the property is disclaimed.
The Purposive approach and mischief rule are similar, they try to build the legal meaning of words that were used in a statute and this meaning is that Parliament seek to have. The mischief gives more discretion than the golden rule and literal rule. But judges need to consider four points when applying the statute: Firstly, what was the common law before the making of the Act? Secondly, what was the mischief and defect for which the common law did not provide? Thirdly, what...

Other assignments on Statutory Interpretation

Law Discuss On Religious Act Essay

7364 words - 30 pages such manner, as it may direct. Commencement: The operation of this Act in any place may at any time be suspended by the Government by notification in the official Gazette. 2. Interpretation-clause: In this Act, unless there be something repugnant in the subject or context,- "parent" includes the father and mother of a legitimate child, and the mother of an illegitimate child; "guardian" means any person to whom the care, nurture or

Case Essay

9859 words - 40 pages conditions, qualifications or restrictions, they so state. The arguments of the petitioners are not inferable by necessary implication from the statutory provisions which are presumed to be complete and expressive of the intendment of the framers, a contrary interpretation on whatever pretext should not be countenanced. A bit of legal history on this contestation will be helpful. The jurisdictional rule heretofore was that writs and processes of the so

Frustration Of Contracts

4948 words - 20 pages be focusing on the historical evolution of the doctrine, the grounds of its application, theoretical effect and its interpretation and implementation by English and Indian court in the complete term paper. Evolution of the doctrine Prior to the formation of this doctrine the rule of absolute and positive contract was applied to cases of breach of contractual obligation irrespective of the cause which rendered the performance of the contractual


4883 words - 20 pages set of postulates or basic concepts. The principles have developed on the basis of experience, reason, custom, usage, and to a significant extent, practical necessity’’ (APB 1970, para. 139). This interpretation of accounting convention is consistent with the idea of social norms (Sunder 2005a). An early statement on accounting conventions is also one of the best. Gilman (1939) identified two characteristics of accounting propositions that

Case Summaries

3319 words - 14 pages notepaper as partner. Also acted as a partner within the firm Held: Relationship between parties under 1968 agreement satisfied statutory definition of partnership in the Partnership Act The partnership was continued without any express new agreement Partnership – The relation which subsists between persons “carrying on a business on common with a view of profit” The plaintiffs salaried partnership was a partner within the Partnership Act

Wills And Intestate

4349 words - 18 pages of testator although not necessarily in the presence of each other. (11) Following the case of Re Gibson pearce J considered that witnessing is exclusively a visual act. Thus a person with impaired vision could hardly be a competent witness. Saying that’s my will might allow for an interpretation that the testator could acknowledge his own signature if this was pointed out to him, in accordance with s9 Wills Act 1837. (12) It is established

Itc Report

5844 words - 24 pages statement. The analysis is done by properly establishing the relationship between the items of balance sheet and profit and loss account the first task of financial analyst is to determine the information relevant to the decision under consideration from the total information contained in the financial statement. The second step is to arrange information in a way to highlight significant relationship. The final step is interpretation and drawing

Code Of Research Conduct

8954 words - 36 pages the relevant ethics committee(s) and all relevant statutory regulatory authorities before they commence; 3.2 The safety of all involved in the research process, ensuring that the research is carried out in accordance with health and safety policies and legislative requirements; 3.3 Ensuring that research is conducted in a suitable working environment with appropriate equipment and facilities; 3.4 The probity of the financial management

Consumer Behaviour And Insurance

8708 words - 35 pages Life Assurance Companies Act, 1912 was the first statutory measure to regulate life business. In 1928, the Indian Insurance Companies Act was enacted to enable the Government to collect statistical information about both life and non-life business transacted in India by Indian and foreign insurers including provident insurance societies.The Insurance Amendment Act of 1950 abolished Principal Agencies. However, there were a large number of

Hofstede-Culture Dimension

9257 words - 38 pages 69 64 27 33 25 27 80 73 90 89 Masculinity Index 54 43 60 70 72 58 21 40 43 19 52 45 61 22 Long-Term Orientation Index 23 30 31 -10 a Based on IBM survey data, b Based on reanalysis of IBM survey data (Hofstede, 1993) c See also Kopper (1993), d Based on my interpretation of Rokeach Value Survey scores collected by McCarrey, Edwards, and Jones (1978); of work goal importance scores collected by Jain, Normand, and Kanungo (1979); IDV


9300 words - 38 pages SOS) or, to break into a net or conversation, the word “emergency”. 3. Avoid spreading rumors. During and after a disaster situation, especially on the phone bands, you may hear almost anything, unfortunately, much misinformation is transmitted. Rumors are started by expansion, deletion, amplification or modification of words, exaggeration or interpretation. All addressed transmissions should be repeated “word for word”, if at all, and only

Similar Documents

Legal Encounter 2 Essay

412 words - 2 pages work in. (2) Quid pro quo, in which Sam used to maintain power over Paula after the broken relationship between them abusing his power as a supervisor. (3) The violation of the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA). Sam used the gender of Paula as an excused to allow her transfer to another department where Sam would not have control of Paula. The violations above have both statutory and case law, the statues in place assist the courts, and however it is the case law that determines the interpretation of the case at hand. Because many statues have different interpretation, many judges use other cases in similar situations to determine the proper ruling.

Qualified Rehabilitation Expenditures Essay

1697 words - 7 pages . The taxpayer’s defense in this case was built largely on the stance that statutory language was misaligned with original Congressional intent and that the IRS was interpreting the original legislation too narrowly. I agreed with the Taxpayer’s view in this case thanks in large part to the relevant Nalle case decision she cited and the precedential value it had coming from the U.S. Court of Appeals. The taxpayer also presented

At Will Employment Essay

4012 words - 17 pages them. Common Law Exceptions to At-Will Employment At-will-employment can be beneficial to employers as it allows for easier termination of employees.  However, there are exceptions to this rule and not following these, either subtly or blatantly, can be cause for employees to take legal action. Both common law and statutory law provide the exceptions to the at-will doctrine.  Several court cases have set the foundation for the three major at

Mine Essay

1219 words - 5 pages THE CONSTITUTION OF SWAZILAND STATUTORY INSTRUMENTS 1968 No. 1377 AFRICA THE SWAZILAND INDEPENDENCE ORDER, 1968 Made 26th August 1968 Laid before Parliament 30th August 1968 Coming into Operation Immediately before 6th September 1968 At the Court at Balmoral, the 26th day of August 1968 Present, The Queen’s Most Excellent Majesty in Council Her Majesty, by virtue and in exercise of the powers in that behalf by the Foreign