This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Role Of Independent Director Essay

7427 words - 30 pages

It is widely accepted that the presence of independent directors in the boardroom improves the quality of corporate governance. Accordingly, corporate governance mechanisms all over the globe, including in India, focus on 'independent directors'. The Companies Bill 2011 includes number of new provisions related to independent directors. It includes a 'Code For Independent Directors' (Schedule IV). According to the Bill an independent director is a director other than a managing director or a whole-time director or a nominee director, who is not a promoter and who fulfils certain conditions specified in the Bill. Primarily he/she does not have any pecuniary relationship with the company or ...view middle of the document...

Usually, every board endeavours to achieve consensus in taking decisions. In absence of consensus, the majority view prevails. Therefore, even if all the independent directors agree that a decision is against the interest of non-controlling shareholders or other stakeholders, they together cannot block the decision. At best, they can record their dissent. This might protect their interest, but fails to protect the interest of affected stakeholders. Minutes are accessible to auditors. But an auditor is not expected to comment on business decisions because evaluation of those is beyond the scope of audit. However, if the dissent note relate to a 'related party transaction', the auditor might take cognisance of the same.
The only alternative is to resign from the board. Resignation of an individual with high stature will signal the market that something is wrong in the governance of the company. The market will not notice resignation of someone who does not enjoy the celebrity status. Moreover, market's memory is short. Therefore, resignation of an independent director may not benefit non-controlling shareholders and other stakeholders.
Should we expect independent directors to play the role of whistle blowers? Should they inform regulators their reservations about decisions taken at a board meeting? It is a debatable question.
Let us accept that independent directors cannot monitor the executive management. At best they provide checks and balances and enrich boardroom deliberations.
For example, Mr. Keshub Mahindra, the highly respected industrialist, could not prevent the Bhopal disaster caused by negligence of the executive management, while he was the non-executive chairman of UCIL. Similarly, in case of Satyam, illustrious independent directors could not prevent fraud perpetrated by the management. J M Financial founder and investment banker Nimesh Kampani could not prevent the Nagarjuna Finance scam.
In the above scenario, independent directors should not be held responsible for the misdeeds of the company, provided they have applied due diligence in carrying out their responsibilities. The public rage against directors in the cases of AMRI and UCIL reflects that there is a huge expectation gap - the gap between what independent directors can do and what stakeholders expect them to do.
This gap is created because we have hyped the role of independent directors. We presented them as semi-god, who is not ordinary person. Fact is that most independent directors are ordinary persons with competencies to manage companies. Therefore, they cannot improve corporate governance by magic touch.
In case of UCIL, the Court found Mr. Mahindra guilty of causing death by negligence (section 304 A of IPC). Courts should review such decisions. If, the present position continues, it will be difficult to get experts willing to join boards as independent directors.

Independent Director
The origin of independent directors should be discussed from the...

Other assignments on Role Of Independent Director

Doc Doc, Docx, Pdf, Wps, Rtf, Odt


Wallace Case Essay

1471 words - 6 pages strategic decision, must have background diversity and independence, must have auditing, compensation and nomination committees, they should also have a financial versus strategic controls analysis, must strengthen the internal management and accounting control systems, establishment and use of formal processes to evaluate the board’s performance, creation of a “lead director” role and lastly, the director election must be made by majority rather

Lessons From Bearing Case

1026 words - 5 pages ? Leaders: * Lack of knowledge, they did not know anything about the activities * They didn’t not change the management for the new business * Blindly depend on external people without proper test * Profit gained shared among management as bonuses, lead to further greed, monetary benefits * Hire Leeson who is only a bookkeeper * Employee incompetent people for the job * No monitoring, lessen is left independent to handle

Charles Schwab

387 words - 2 pages brand was caught in threats from full service brokerage firms and deep discount Internet brokers. 4. Adding to that there are technology advancements during 90s that enabled customers to invest securities online, while becoming independent of brokers. In response to this company offered broad range of financial services. 5. By 2004, revenues are flat and net income declined by 39% in just 12 months. 6. Company was not providing good

The Man

1259 words - 6 pages Erlinda Kintanar Alburo is a prolific contemporary Cebuano language scholar and promoter of the language. She is the Director of the Cebuano Studies Center of the University of San Carlos, Philippines. She is an active member of Women in Literary Arts (WILA), and writes poetry both in English and cebuano. She teaches on the anthropology of linguistics. Works: * Cebu Provincial History Project. Cluster 1 editor * Sinug-ang: A Cebuano

Repercussions In Recruiting Incompetent People

293 words - 2 pages HR manager had shortlisted the CV s and called only 3 candidates for first interview. Two candidates were selected for final interview in rush manner. Final interview wasn’t conducted in the fixed date and it was postponed because of Marketing Director and his team wanted to attend for an Exhibition. Final interview was carried out 5 days after the exhibition by CEO and Marketing Director and Mr. Anton was selected as the new Brand Manager. Mr

Baosteel Group - Governance With Chinese Characteristics

2044 words - 9 pages common grounds to establish a single company. Besides managerial problems the consolidation would also raise issues concerning status and “face”. If the company Bayi for instance would be merged with Baoshan it would have been degraded from being independent to a grandson of the Baosteel Group. As hierarchy is still an important concept deeply enshrined in Chinese culture this might be problematic and have adverse effects on the company’s

Nicholas Piramal India Limited

335 words - 2 pages This 4 page paper is based on a case study supplied by the student. Nicholas Piramal India Ltd (NPIL) has acquired Avecia. The post acquisition merger is going badly, with a clash of cultural styles. The paper assesses how and why there are problems and looks at the way the problem may be resolved. The bibliography cites 2 sources. Michael Fernandez, director of special operations in the pharmaceutical company Nicholas Piramal India Limited

Analysis Of Competition Law In Kenya

2032 words - 9 pages . This makes it extremely hard for the authority to operationalize. Further the same section is absolutely silent on the role of the Director of Public Prosecution who is vested with the prosecutorial powers. Under Article 157 of the Constitution, there is established the office of the Director of Public Prosecution. The Director of Public Prosecution may institute and undertake criminal proceedings against any person before any court (other

A Situation In Which A Nurse Can Be Held Liable For Negligence

1020 words - 5 pages arranged supervision of a physician. Nursing has evidently matured into an increasingly specialized, advanced, sophisticated, and independent profession hence expanding the roles of a nurse. Resultantly, the liability for fundamental nursing negligence has moved to its professional counterpart, which is malpractice liability. Nevertheless, obstetrical nursing is the field of nursing that is highly taxing since it involves the most delicate tasks

Ldr/531 Quizz Week 3

1643 words - 7 pages department director before any change can be implemented. Peter is most likely to be a part of the ________ type of small-group communication networks. *chain network star network mesh network all-channel network 13Which of the following terms best describes the process that occurs when two or more parties decide how to allocate scarce resources? Integration Association *Negotiation

Similar Documents

Marketing Mix Essay

409 words - 2 pages Katherine L. Tan Director and Treasurer Kingson U. Sian Director Kendrick Andrew L. Tan Director Alejo L. Villanueva, Jr. Independent Director Miguel B. Varela Independent Director Dina D.R. Inting Chief Finance Officer, Corporate Information Officer and Compliance Officer Dominic V. Isberto Corporate Secretary Rolando D. Siatela Assistant Corporate Secretary Annual Stockholders Meeting: Business Development: Reference:

Corporate Governance Essay

950 words - 4 pages RBI. IIBM Institute of Business Management 1 Examination Paper d. The particular level of liquid ity maintained by commercial banks. 6. This committee was set up in January 1995 to identify good practices by the confederation of British Industry (CBI) a. The Paul Ruthman Committee b. The Greenbury Committee, 1995 c. Cadbury Committee, 1995 d. The Hampel Committee,1995 7. ______________, plays a significant role in the growth of the corporate

My Paper

452 words - 2 pages McDonald’s have 8 current and expected government policies and regulations, including taxes and regulations in place to address issues related to externalities. First, is the audit and non-audit Service Policy? The purpose and Applicability of Policy is under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, the Audit Committee of the Board of Directors is responsible for the appointment, compensation and oversight of the work performed by the independent auditor

Good Corporate Governance Essay

1723 words - 7 pages unfettered powers. Disclosing the division of responsibilities assists those affected by corporate decisions to better understand the respective accountabilities and contributions of board and management of the particular company. that understanding can be further enhanced if the disclosure includes an explanation of the balance of responsibility between chairperson the lead independent director and the chief