This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rhetorical Analysis – Other Voices, Other Rooms

1045 words - 5 pages

In this essay, “Other Voices, Other Rooms”, Professor Gerald Graff offers that education at a university could be exciting and rewarding for students. However, it applies to those who have developed the skills at summarizing, weighing arguments and synthesizing conflicting points. Unfortunately, not all students possess these skills and as they start getting confused they will care more about appeasing the professor in order to obtain good grades. In return, they will give their professors whatever they want even though it seems contradictory to their beliefs (339). Graff believes that not all college students possess the skills necessary to be successful and that professors are only making ...view middle of the document...

He says, “Only later did it dawn on me that studying different centuries and clashing theories without having them brought together had made things much harder since it removed the element of contrast” (340). Graff says that contrast is fundamental to learning and in order to fully grasp the concept, and the subject needs to be understood in relation to other ideas. In his second example, in attempting to strengthen his argument, Graff uses an academic reference, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas S. Kuhn. Kuhn says,
“Both the literati and the scientist have remained largely walled up within their clashing assumptions about objectivity, the smugness of which might have been punctured had these parties been forced to argue with each other in their teaching” (341). Even though Graff and Kuhn share the same thoughts, Kuhn’s reference does not provide any evidence to support his claims. He then introduces Gregory Colomb, which his reference again doesn’t add credibility; it detracts from the essay because readers have to read the text several times just to get through this part of the writing. Graff says, “Imagine trying to write and academic paper when you send that almost anything you say can be used against you and that the intellectual moves that got you an A in existentialist philosophy may get you a C minus and a dirty look in Skinnerian behaviorism (342)”. He goes on to say, “When students fail to identify a cultural literacy item on a test, the problem may be not that they don’t know the information but that they don’t know that they know it, they may have learned it in a context whose relevance to the test question they don’t recognize” (343). Unfortunately, Graff does not offer supporting studies or evidences that validate his claims. This portion of the essay was dry and difficult to understand; it seems that he loses the earlier gains he had in supporting his argument. Lastly, Graff successfully uses a very relatable analogy that sums up his essay, which the majority of this audience can either relate to or conceptualize. Graff compares students trying to learn a series of unrelated courses to someone attempting to learn to play...

Other assignments on Rhetorical Analysis – Other Voices, Other Rooms


1007 words - 5 pages is controversial. Proponents argue that it teaches students how to organize their thoughts clearly in writing; opponents characterize its structure as rigid and repetitive. [edit] Academic essays Longer academic essays (often with a word limit of between 2,000 and 5,000 words) are often more discursive. They sometimes begin with a short summary analysis of what has previously been written on a topic, which is often called a literature review

Goal Programming Essay

1181 words - 5 pages assume all the above weights equal 1 and all other weights are 0. Implementing the Model    w5 w1  w   w 3  w  w   4 4 MIN : d1  2 d 2  d3  d4  d4  d5 5 10 15 25,000 25,000 1,000,000 Subject to: X1  d  d  5 X 2  d  d  10  2  2  1  1 Small Rooms Medium Rooms Large Rooms  4  4 X 3  d  d  15  3  3 400X1  750X 2  1,050X 3  d  d  25,000   18000X1  33000X 2  45.150X 3  d 5

Reading Workshhet17

602 words - 3 pages ] ------------------------------------------------- Many people think that sex discrimination is no longer exists because they got a news about women who got high-level appointments in academia or the other position, for example, HP, etc. But it is still few cases that women have a leadership positions of Fortune 500 and there are still barriers and glass ceilings in the office. Also, there are some cases about talented women in the workplace could not promote

Novo Nordisk

558 words - 3 pages than agree of follow along with everything. Another thing she said was that rhetorical reading is not a magical technique for producing sophisticated papers. I think she is correct because it has happened to me when I am supposed to do like a document based question where I have to read and analyze something it is harder for me to first understand and then try to ask questions about it to myself and think about how this can lead to further

Social Studies Mini Lesson

561 words - 3 pages , encyclopedia, Pictures of the various buildings and rooms in the White House. Objectives: Students will have a greater appreciation of the White House. Be able to explain the history, some of the furnishings, and the uses of various rooms in the building. Activity: Provide students with pictures of various rooms in the White House. Each student will chose a room to visit in the pictures. From there students will be ask to research what that rooms


252 words - 2 pages In 2010, I worked for an international hotel as sales manager in China. At that time, the manager of housekeeping department is Mark who comes from US. One morning, the boss gave me a task that leading new employees to visit the different rooms of the hotel. Moreover, one of the rooms which in the top floor with view had a highly value of visitation. The problem is the customer of the room had not checked out. However, he had left the hotel. At

Case Study

1303 words - 6 pages schedules that didn’t always fit with cafeteria serving hours. Three other findings from the survey were of concern to Kershaw: (1) the large percentage of students with cars, (2) the large percentage of students with refrigerators and microwave ovens in their rooms, and (3) the number of times students ordered food delivered from off campus. Percent of students with cars on campus Percent of students having refrigerators or microwaves in their

Aung Ann Suu Khi And Martin Luther King

297 words - 2 pages recognition for what they did for the people. Aung San Suu Kyi’s excerpt “In Quest with Democracy” and Martin Luther King’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail”, surpassed other writings in their employment of rhetorical appeal of pathos, ethos and logos; which is why they achieve persuasion on the other people to join the course for just institutions. Aung San Suu Kyi in her writing expresses her desired for democratic Burma which had over many decades

Human Resource

3638 words - 15 pages recruitment. On the other hand it takes a time a lot. It is important to note, that each company should use the recruitment method best suited to them. 3.1 Recruitment Recruitment is the process of attracting, finding and selecting a best qualified candidate for a job opening, in a right time with cost effective manner. It includes analyzing the requirements of a job, attracting employees to that job, selecting applicants, hiring, and

Homework Week 8

1145 words - 5 pages built. Customers will know what level of the room will be and reserve a room on AirBnB without any concerns in the future. AirBnB need to build up their brand with a quality and economic image. Since the strong competitors of AirBnB are other hotels, which have clean and comfortable standard rooms, and sometimes hotel rooms have attractive offers as well, if AirBnB want to be competitive, they should work more on their listing quality to show


265 words - 2 pages many other literary and rhetorical devices, oxymorons are used for a variety of purposes. Sometimes they are used to create some sort of drama for the reader or listener, and sometimes they are used to make the person stop and think, whether it's to laugh or to ponder. Examples:  "I can resist anything, except temptation." - Oscar Wilde  "I like a smuggler. He is the only honest thief." - Charles Lamb Synecdoche *Synecdoche is

Similar Documents

Analysis Of The Ways Of Speaking And Other Cognitive Behaviors Of The Patients Of Broca's Aphasia And Wernicke's Aphasia

4654 words - 19 pages Analysis of the Ways of Speaking and Other Cognitive Behaviors of the Patients of Broca's Aphasia and Wernicke's Aphasia. An Empirical Study Submitted in Partial Fulfillments of the Requirement for the Course: Sociolinguistics and Psycholinguistics of the Masters of Arts In the Department of English Language and Literature Jatiya Kabi Kazi Nazrul Islam University

Style Analysis Essay

602 words - 3 pages Julia Pezzullo Period 1 4/4/14 Style Essay This passage from The Great Influenza describes the scientific process and how a scientist must have the courage to “embrace” uncertainty to make the unknown known. Through the use of metaphors, analogies, and other rhetorical devices, the author further conveys a scientist’s tedious process to reveal a newfound truth. Barry begins by contrasting the strength and conviction of certainty with

Sylabus For Rhetoric Essay

3351 words - 14 pages research you use in your Academic Argument essay. In this paper, analyze an essay selected by your instructor from the reader or another essay you select with the approval of your instructor.  To begin your analysis, look at the different rhetorical choices evaluated in the first three chapters of our text, and other writing strategies we have discussed in class, such as the writer’s backing of a claim, use of evidence, logic (or logical

Rhetorical Analysis Of An Article

1620 words - 7 pages intriguing facets is the rise of in depth analytics to create a new, more accurate era of basketball statistics. In an article for The Atlantic, Terrance F. Ross elaborates on the topic and the controversy surrounding it to during his brilliantly written piece entitled “Welcome to Smarter Basketball”. However, it is more than just the words themselves that give the article its desired effect. Several rhetorical strategies are imperative to Ross’ success