This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ratio Analysis Under Different Accounting Rules

1255 words - 6 pages

Comparing different companies under different rules, or comparing one company in different time period can be complicating and often misleading when differences in accounting methods are not captured. In this essay, I will start the analysis by examining each firm’s change in accounting methods compared to their previous year. Then I will move on to comparing the three companies’ ratios to conduct analysis of each company based on the DuPont Method. In addition, I will also look at how changes in accounting methods affected Seven and I holdings’ results in 2013 when compared to 2012.
Finally, I will conclude my analysis on how comparable it was under different accounting methods ...view middle of the document...

As written above, there is no significant change in accounting methods for Walmart and Sainsbury. There were changes to Seven & I holdings’ accounting methods, however when comparing the three companies I will use original number as I think that would be more objective, and later on examine Seven & I Holdings’ number individually with and without the effects of the change.

Ratio Analysis

* For Seven and I Holdings numbers are not adjusted in above chart

Return on Equity is a ratio used to measure a company’s profitability based on how much profit the company made for the money invested to the company, hence calculated as Net Income divided by Shareholder’s equity.
Comparing the three companies, Walmart has the highest ROE, more than twice of Sainsbury and more than three times of Seven and I holdings. Amongst stock market participants, Japanese companies are known for its low ROE especially compared to American firms and in case of seven and I holdings, it is consistent with that notion (on a side note, 7&I Holdings’ ROE goal is 10%).

DuPont Method
It is clear that Walmart has quite a high ROE compared to other two companies, however, if we compare three companies by just looking at their ROE, but we don't know what is driving that high ROE.

With the DuPont method, ROE can be divided into three parts:
ROE = (Profit margin) x (Asset turnover) x (Leverage ratio)
= (Net profit/Sales) x (Sales/Assets) x (Assets/Equity)

In general, it is fair to say that consumer retail business doesn’t have a big profit margin compared with big profit margin industry like financial industry or mining industry. So for firms to achieve high ROE, they must maintain a high asset turnover and high leverage ratio.
With the DuPont Method, we can clearly see that Walmart’s high ROE is driven by its high asset turnover and leverage ratio rather than profit margin as there is only about 1% difference in profit margin.
In addition, looking at ROA in each company, we can also see that Walmart has significantly higher ROA compared with others. ROA is used to measure how effectively a firm is turning its invested capital to earnings. Combined with the above DuPont analysis, it is reasonable to say that Walmart is exceling in generating more profit with less capital compared with other two companies.
On a side note, another reason could be that Walmart is using LIFO under inflationary economy based on GAAP, which could be increasing the Net Income compared to Sainsbury (FIFO under IFRS) or Seven and I holdings (FIFO under Japan Standards).
However, at the same time, Japan has been in deflationary economy so in theory Seven and I Holdings’ usage of FIFO can increase their net income as well, so we cannot conclude whether Walmart’s usage of LIFO has significant impact on their Net Income or not.


Other assignments on Ratio Analysis Under Different Accounting Rules

Verifone And Ncr Essay

5191 words - 21 pages Page 5 VI. VeriFone Governance Structure Page 5-7 VII. NCR Governance Structure Page 7-8 VIII. Restatement Page 8-12 IX. Business Risks: The Company Page 12-13 X. Accounting Policies and Disclosure Practices Page 14-16 XI. Financial Statement Analysis Page 16- 18 XII. Conclusion Page 18-19 XIII. Exhibits Page 20 XIV. Reference Page 21 Executive Summary

Accounting Essay

4883 words - 20 pages over the past century. It is useful to reflect on these foundational issues in isolation from the debates on specific standards and financial reporting practices. Perhaps the Financial Accounting Standards Committee of the AAA can help stimulate further reflection and discussion on these issues by sharing its thoughts and analysis. The following sections are written in that spirit. STOCKS VERSUS FLOWS Stocks and flows are the most obvious and


2060 words - 9 pages Cariboo Industrial Case Solution We have calculated relevant ratios analysis in regards to Cariboo Industrial (“CI”) liquidity, assets management, long term debt paying ability and profitability. Below are the summary of our work: Liquidity Ratio: Current ratio of CI for the 2001, 2002 and 2003 are 2.03, 0.42 and 0.21 respectively. The ratio figures indicate CI ability to pay it’s short term liabilities commitment. If a ratio figure is

Term Paper - Ratio Analysis. Accou

1408 words - 6 pages RSM1320 – Financial Accounting FINANCIAL ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES (RATIO ANALYSIS) KEY POINTS TO KNOW 1) Financial analysis is ultimately contextual and purpose-driven. In other words, there is always a reason why you are performing the analysis. You need to be clear about the objective of the analysis. 2) The tools and techniques that you use will depend on your purpose. As we discussed earlier, analyzing the company as an investment


5111 words - 21 pages of their ability to generate streams of revenue, a distinction is traditionally drawn between internally generated and purchased goodwill. The former should not be brought to account because it is impossible to do so within the accepted rules of double entry bookkeeping and historical cost based accounting. On the other hand, there is no difficulty in bringing purchased goodwill to account, but controversy has always existed as to how to treat

German Costing

995 words - 4 pages -type accounting, cost center accounting, product cost accounting, and contribution margin accounting for profitability analysis. Cost-type accounting separate different costs types such as labor, materials and depreciation. GPK also includes interest as a cost type. Each cost type is decomposed into variable and fixed costs along with the assignment of costs to cost centers. Below is a table of data from the International Business & Economic

Fin534 Week 10 Assignment 1

2335 words - 10 pages Financial Research Report Introduction For investors and business owners, financial analysis poses significant importance as it evaluates the company’s performance in measureable aspects. In financial analyses financial ratios are considered important in analyzing the position of the company. It analyzes important areas of the business performance such as liquidity ratios, debt ratio, and profitability of the business. This report aims on


4128 words - 17 pages . Generally accepted accounting principles or US GAAP are the accounting rules used to prepare financial statements for publicly traded companies and many private companies in the United States. Generally accepted accounting principles for local and state governments operates under a different set of assumptions, principles, and constraints, as determined by the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB). In the United States, as well as in other

Hr Assistent

363 words - 2 pages analysis knowing that in all in accounting can help a company keep score in dollars, stake holders may desire further analysis on those set of numbers. In accounting ratios allow stakeholders to determine how well a company operates in specific segments the base purpose and importance of a ratio analysis allows for much deeper review overall and comparison of a company’s operations. The difference between a comparative and ratio analysis are that in a

Ki Title Dibo

7040 words - 29 pages | Sampling Technique | 20 | 9.0 | Ratio Analysis | 21-26 | | Ratio | 21 | | Descriptive Statistics | 22-23 | | Correlation Analysis | 23-24 | | Regression Analysis | 24-26 | 10.0 | Limitations of the study | 27 | 11.0 | Findings and Conclusions | 28 | 12.0 | References | 29-30 | INTRODUCTION Banks play a very important role in the economic development of a country as they circulate money between productive and unproductive sector of the

Company Analysis

6691 words - 27 pages is foreign. This bank, with its internationally spread high reputation and the service and techniques bringing enhanced value to the customer, has become a major threat to all the local banks in Sri Lanka including BOC. 3.2 Ratio analysis Khan and Jain (2006) highlight the importance of ratio analysis in terms of drawing the inferences regarding the performance of a company. There are several measures under ration analysis a company could

Similar Documents

Finance Essay

3708 words - 15 pages portion of its current assets consists of cash and accounts receivables. Accounts receivables are highly liquid and can be converted into cash quickly. From this analysis, it is clear that the analyst should not only see the current ratio but also the composition of current assets. Limitations of current ratio Current ratio suffers from a number of limitations. Some are given below: 1. Different ratio in different parts of the year: Some

Ratio And Financial Statement Analysis

2513 words - 11 pages company’s efficiency has not significantly declined in the last year. The efficiency analysis ratio suggest that, there is a different trend in liquidity and profitability ratios from the seen indicators. The turnover inventory in 2007 has deteriorated slightly by 3.00 to 2009 2.90 values. Comparably, it has impacted the current inventory from 122 to 127 during similar period. Therefore, holding inventory in that period suggest that, the firm is

Week 5 Reflection Summary Essay

401 words - 2 pages investors as it provides them with important and detailed information that could turn out to be the determining factor as to their decisions to invest or not to invest in a particular organization. Therefore, it is not uncommon to find unethical behavior in accounting as unethical practices come in different forms and different situations that might lead to unethical practices in accounting include are misleading financial analysis in order to obtain

Financial Ratio Analysis

6669 words - 27 pages Bangladesh. They export their products in different countries of the world. The report covers the ratio analysis as well as index analysis of income statement and balance sheet of these companies. After calculation, interpretation and evaluation have also been provided based on their financial condition. 2.4 Limitations of the Report The limitations of the report are as follows: Sometimes it is difficult to understand a few accounting and