This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Punishment And Sentencing Essay

1149 words - 5 pages

Punishment and Sentencing
CJA 224/Introduction to Criminal Court Systems
March 26,2012

Abstract
This paper will explain and identify the various punishment philosophies within the juvenile court and its processes. Also the adult court process will be explained how they differ with the punishment philosophies. In addition, the sanctions involved, various legal factors associated with sentencing, and the aspects of the appeals will be explained.

There are four punishment philosophies which include: deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation, and retribution. The goal of each philosophy is to deter crime, however each approach is different.
The purpose of deterrence is to ...view middle of the document...

“Rehabilitation advocates argue that society owes it to itself and individual offenders to try to cure them before releasing them back into society” (Meyer & Grant, 2003). Treatment sometimes involves administering drugs, therapy, training, and educational programs. If an offender cannot be treated during the rehabilitation process, he or she shall remain in confinement and not be released in order to protect the society.
Incapacitation involves the attempt to physically restrain offenders from victimizing if others. With the use of incapacitation, crime can be prevented by separating offenders from society. Although incapacitation is not limited to jail or prison, house arrest and in-patient drug treatment programs tend to keep offenders off the streets for the interval of their sentence. In my opinion, incapacitation does not prevent crime from happening. Once offenders are incarcerated, they transfer crime from the streets into the prison. Incapacitation is to away with the victimization of others, but many offenders continue to victimize others while in prison. Once offenders have been released, nothing stops them from recommencing their criminal behavior. In addition, inmates are familiarized to new crimes, such as joining a gang, crimes that may have not been committed while they were living in a free world. Incapacitation results in the redundant confinement of many people who would not have committed a future crime.
Retribution is considered to be one of the most understood punishment theories. “Retribution is based on the concept of lex talionis (“an eye for an eye”) (Meyer & Grant, 2003). The theory of retribution is that offenders are punished to take away any advantages they might have gained from their illegal acts. Retribution does now acknowledge for punishment of innocent coalition or for the discipline of those who cannot be held responsible for their actions. For example, the mentally insane should not be punished for their actions in coherent to their mental illness. Crimes must be voluntary in order for someone to be punished for their acts. “Critics of retribution argue that “just deserts” is outdated, that as a civilized society, we have moved beyond the need for simple vengeance. And, punishing some people simply because they have done wrong does not address the underlying problem” (Meyer & Grant, 2003). Refusing necessary treatment from offenders is not the clarification to crime.
hear certain types of cases. Ordinarily, their jurisdiction is described by the age and behavior of the offender. The ages over which they have jurisdiction varies; in most states the maximum age is seventeen. It is said anyone who executes a crime after his or her...

Other assignments on Punishment And Sentencing

Leg420 Essay

1560 words - 7 pages criminal justice system is too let them correct their behavior instead of developing new criminal way of life in prisons. References Code of Virginia (CV) Titles 16.2 -18.2 (2009). McGarvey, E. L., & Waite, D. (2000). Mental health needs among adolescents committed to the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice. Dev. Mental Health L., 20, 1. Powers, A. (2009). Cruel and Unusual Punishment: Mandatory Sentencing of Juveniles Tried as

A Letter From Prosion Essay

3388 words - 14 pages PRELIMINARY STATEMENT Stephen Richards respectfully submits this Memorandum regarding his re-sentencing. The purpose of this submission is to highlight pertinent developments in the lives of Mr. Richards and his family members in the four years since the Court originally imposed a sentence of 84 months imprisonment. Mr. Richards has been incarcerated for 43 months. He has earned all available “good time” credit, which brings his

Justice System Position Paper

1481 words - 6 pages fact, this type of sentencing has been shown to make our youth offenders more violent {Hermann, 2006}. The goal here is punishment and rehabilitation, not extreme punishment. As the concept of community corrections should not be just rehabilitation but also punishment, so that the person is able to gather with other people who have chosen not to do crimes. Most of the community programs out there are focused on our youth because that is

Competing Theories

1428 words - 6 pages desserts” model of criminal sentencing, that believes when someone has been convicted and punished for a crime, they have received their “just desserts”. It is akin to a form of revenge taken by society as a whole against the perpetrator. “Retribution sees punishment as deserved, justified, and even required by the offender’s behavior” (Schmalleger, 2012). Punishment in the form of retribution helps to dissuade the victim or the victim’s family from

Impacts Of Death Row

1667 words - 7 pages Impact of Death Row on the Correction System Name Task Date Abstract When an individual is found guilty of a criminal offense and consequently sentenced to death, the individual is held in death row pending any habeas corpus or appeals, and if these fail, until the convict is convicted. Those opposed to capital punishment have contended that the isolation of a convict and the uneasiness over his or her

Criminal Justice Trends

1253 words - 6 pages States. Prisons and jails operate around two philosophies of punishment vs. rehabilitation. The past tend was solitary confinement with no concern for inmate rehabilitation or any concern for the well-being of the inmates. Most of the increase has come from the changes in sentencing laws and policies, but not in the crime rates. These trends have stemmed in prison overcrowding and financial burdens on states to oblige a fast increasing penal

Capital Punishment

1499 words - 6 pages resolve these problems by sentencing the people who would at present be sent to prison for life to the death penalty as a punishment for doing wrong. Another common point that is made is that with so many people in our prisons it actually costs us money due to taxing. And as I said before prisons are overcrowded plus every person serving a life sentence costs £400-£1000 each per week depending on the amount of security that they

Is Capital Punishment Jusitified

1262 words - 6 pages ) There isn't any research to indicate that the death penalty reduces the amount of homicides any more than life in prison does. When prisoners serving life sentences were given a survey about their preference in sentencing options, 55-60% said that they would rather have received capital punishment. This observation is proven in Michael Passaro’s case. Passaro requested the death penalty and pleaded guilty after murdering his 2-year-old daughter

Capital Punishment

1497 words - 6 pages Capital Punishment or as some people refer to it, the death penalty, is the legal process in which an accused is sentenced to death for their crimes. There is a wide range opinions regarding the death penalty and whether it is a cruel and unusual punishment or if justice is better served by means of execution. Currently the total population of state and federal death row is at 3,170 inmates. It has been greatly debated for years whether the

Capital Punishment Should Be Stopped

3503 words - 15 pages nationwide impact of its decision unmistakable, the Court summarily reversed death sentences in the many cases then before it, which involved a wide range of state statutes, crimes, and factual situations. But within four years after the Furman decision, more than 600 persons had been sentenced to death under new capital-punishment statutes that provided guidance for the jury’s sentencing discretion. These statutes typically require a bifurcated (two

Disparity And Discrimination

828 words - 4 pages criminal justice system when focusing on the sentencing of an offender when dealing with their arrest or court proccedings. Discrimination is a much wider scale with many different areas when compared to disparity. It is believed by some that disparity is the product of discrimination. “The main difference between disparity and discrimination is legal or extralegal factors; therefore, when a decision is made based on the seriousness of the offense

Similar Documents

Victimization In The Criminal Justice System

1204 words - 5 pages Victimization in the Criminal Justice System Ian Gallagher CJA/534 May 18, 2015 Lora Terrill Victimization in the Criminal Justice System In ancient times, victims of crimes, and their kin, were responsible for the sentencing and implementation of the offender. This trend did not reappear, in a more lawful form, in modern criminal justice systems until the 1970’s. Recent years have seen growth and attention in victim’s rights and advocacy

Criminal Sentencing Essay

700 words - 3 pages . As far as the purpose of criminal sentencing goes, it is imperative that all courts are on the same page and strive to achieve the same outcome. Due to the ever-changing society we live in, there has always been controversy as to what the right objective was for the criminal when it comes to punishment. For long time rehabilitation was the focus in criminal sentencing, but that proved to fail due to the increase of recidivism. Now it

Wrap Up Response Legal Paper On Corrections

983 words - 4 pages Wrap-up Q&A Response Paper Wrap-up Q&A Response Paper There are certain aspects that may impact legal sentencing, and they differ by authority; but many legal systems contain a set of suggestions for sentencing, including a least and highest possible punishment that may be added. Within that range, information of the legal offenses are often taken into consideration when figuring out what treatment might comprise sensible sentencing

Beato Bibliography Essay

407 words - 2 pages , black uniform bureaucrats use the detailed guidelines to ensure punishment in the sentencing phase which is designed to be slow, repetitive, and boring. He also gives examples such as, if your in Ohio and are caught with a DUI, you might be required to place a bright yellow license plate on your car. “Those in favor of the bill say people with DUI’s need to be put on display so they can be embarrassed of their crime.” But