Philosophy Of Paying College Athletes Essay

1464 words - 6 pages

One of the most debated topics across all Division I colleges nationwide is whether or not college athletes should be compensated for their impact on the revenue of the school from sports. Many schools call sports the “front porch” of their campuses, bringing in the bulk of their revenue, creating nearly free advertising, and attracting students that would otherwise not attend their school. A 2009 court case brought this issue to light when a former college player sued the NCAA and EA Games for using his name in a video game and not paying royalties. The case is headed towards an NCAA payout, and many athletes are joining the plaintiff side as allowed by courts, as their names were used as ...view middle of the document...

As I read through the article, many of the schools mentioned were the likes of Notre Dame, Boston College, Oklahoma, UCLA, Michigan, and Texas. I would agree that these schools make a ton of money on sports and can understand the idea to pay their athletes, but how can we do this when there are also other level schools that are Division I but do not make the insane amounts of money that those types of schools do? It is simply unfair to allow some Division I athletes to be paid and others not.
The theory that I believe relates to this idea is Spencer’s “Social Darwinism”, the theory that might makes right and survival is best for the fittest. I think the idea of paying college athletes relates to them being the fit students within a university and some people thinking that those most fit deserve a reward. Both theories argue that competition is the reason of improvement, but I think that both theories: paying athletes and Social Darwinism, fail to have technical views on the impact of the theory and that is why they both fail. Just as Social Darwinism fails because of changing context, paying athletes is not right because of the existence of change. How can we assume that a school’s football team and basketball team will remain successful programs years into the future? If we decide to pay athletes and then a top program’s team becomes sanctioned, like some do, or a school begins a downturn and the program loses relevancy, how will that effect our payments to the players? What would happen if college sports as a whole become increasingly unpopular due to the existence of concussions or loss of interest? The simple fact is that paying college athletes assumes there is a constant line of improvement, and that is very naïve. One of the best critiques of Social Darwinism says that someone is not always the fittest because of skill or intelligence. There are many other factors and situations, and I think this relates to the paying of college athletes. The suggestions talk about previously seek to only reward certain individuals at certain top programs, which would be unethical according to this critique of Spencer’s Social Darwinism.
Another problem inherently with this issue is how the goals of major athletic programs seem to be different from the missions of the universities they represent. Although some of these athletes are on track for professional careers, while enrolled they are students in academic universities or colleges first. The athletic program is a part of the academic institution, not the other way around. A quote from a player mentioned in the article that I thought was powerful said he was an “athlete-student” not a “student-athlete” as the NCAA wants people to believe. 1 We hear of so many cases where universities baby athletes in the classroom, giving them favorable treatment so they are allowed to suit up on game days. Paying players would make even more of a mockery of education. This is not to say that sports cannot teach...

Other assignments on Philosophy Of Paying College Athletes

Research Paper

410 words - 2 pages To be an athlete is something that God as put inside us as human beings you can’t teach talent. But to become a student athlete there’s a price you have to pay, it comes with hard work, big responsibility, maturity, and self- discipline. Everybody wants to play on Saturdays and Sundays but it starts in the classroom first that’s why we are labeled as STUDENT athletes first because, you can’t do one without the other. Most athletes don’t have a

The Future Is Not Just A Game

1399 words - 6 pages student. Even colleges and universities treat the elite athletes differently. The average GPA needed for the student athlete to attend college is 2.5 and the average ACT score needed is 17 (Griffin). Non-athletes have to have an average GPA of 3.0 and an ACT score of around 21. Middle and high schools and also colleges will have tutors and or special learning centers to help star players to stay eligible. With all this extra help it still comes

Financial For College Students

641 words - 3 pages of scholarships that offer comprehensive resources with current award listings. (GoCollege.com, 1977 - 2011) After doing all of the research it is possible to attend college without having to come out of pocket with any money. In my experience, I have gone to college and had to drop out because I could not afford it. After paying back my loan I decided to go back and further my education. I decided to do some research and asked questions. I have

Perception Of The Athlete In Modern American Society

2059 words - 9 pages as much as their ability to run, jump, etc…) which is not very different from what we picture the ideal athlete as today. Webster’s dictionary defines athlete as “Any one trained to contend in exercises requiring great physical agility and strength; one who has great activity and strength; a champion” which is a very vague definition when you look at the variety of different types of athletes we have in the U.S. Does a thin, toned Olympic

College Courses

369 words - 2 pages There Should Not Be Any Required Courses In College  There are many arguments to support the abolishment of core classes in college. One reason is a financial one: a great bulk of tuition money that the students pay to college is for their courses. It is not right to have the college take this money and make the student's decisions for them. The students should have the right to make this  decision on their own. This does not only make for

Concussions In Sports

3182 words - 13 pages , which is why concussions are such a serious topic in sports. How can a normal person who is not nearly capable of playing professional be plagued by concussions? He had to quit college football his junior year, after what he thinks was close to his 10th concussion. He now suffers from poor memory, and cannot maintain focus for a long period of time. His life has been severely altered by concussions, and unlike all professional athletes He made no

Why College Education Is Important To Me

705 words - 3 pages “Why college education is important to me”. By Janelle D. Crichlow EN110 Achieving Academic Excellence Ashworth College A college degree is important for a variety of reasons for both the young and the old, namely to develop or improve one’s trade skills, to experience different cultures and to increase one’s educational background in order to attain a higher paying job. For me, a college degree is important because it will help me to

Divorce

409 words - 2 pages Feross Harajli Rodgers English 093-48 10-19-13 Success In College As time goes on, the life of a college student becomes progressively more difficult. Taking notes, studying, organizing time, and being confident plays a huge role in a student’s life. Procrastination is another thing that can hold back a college student. Becoming a college student is not about just getting good grades; it is about having a positive mindset, which will help

Business Environment

733 words - 3 pages toward their products and try harder to do the best. Furthermore, competition will lead our country in progress. So , what other competitors do will make Subway company do their best in order to achieve their goals. Owner Owner is the person who own the company or who have the share of the company by paying dividend. As we stated before, the more customers choose Subway company, the more profit Subway company make so that the owner or the

The University In Chains

1165 words - 5 pages universities, since 911 this militarism has spread beyond the walls of the university into mainstream society. The concept of militarism is the dominance of the military over the state or the broader culture, militarization is more fundamental and pervasive part of a basic military philosophy and its underlying assumptions. The author contends that the two meanings are becoming one and is now used as solutions for everything from “drugs, crime

Lat1 Final Paper

3215 words - 13 pages activity in the prefrontal cortex,” this region of the brain is responsible for “complex thinking, decision making, and correct social behavior.” However this increased prefrontal cortex “brain activity” did not occur in the more sedentary kids as it did in their active peers (as cited by The Medical College of Georgia, 2011, p.1). Student – athletes are able to solve academic problems easier because they are provided with the necessary techniques

Similar Documents

Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

2122 words - 9 pages uniforms enough? Should schools really pocket all that money they make in revenue from the sports teams? Many moral, ethical and legal issues can be raised in the idea of paying college athletes to play, on both the pro and con side of the issue. Should an athlete receive a full ride scholarship and also be paid from the school to play? Many big universities may be able to handle such a thing, but what about the small colleges that do not receive

College Cost Being Affordable To All

1967 words - 8 pages college degree. Research has revealed that most high school seniors may be extremely concerned as regards to the college cost of tuition; nevertheless, 80% of seniors consider a college education to be a minimum prerequisite for a decent employment. There may be issues that come forward with regards to college education; the first issue may be whether college is even affordable. The key problem that families face may be the intricacy in paying

College Athletics Essay

791 words - 4 pages basketball analyst and attorney at law said, “It is not immoral for the N.C.A.A. to make money off of athletics. But it is profoundly immoral for the N.C.A.A. to restrict athletes from receiving compensation while everyone else profits.” (ESPN) Regardless if you agree or disagree whether college athletes should be paid, the NCAA’s oppressive system is corrupt and needs to be reformed sooner rather than later.

Psychology Essay

1427 words - 6 pages Rodriguez as an idol for everyone who strives to be the best at what they do. As a college baseball player at Umass Boston I have seen some of the hardest working athletes imaginable, but for most of them being as successful as Alex Rodriguez is completely unreachable. Each and every one of us is born different with different talents and abilities, and the best we can do is maximize our potential. The only way to accomplish this is with hard work