Mr. Friehling – A Future Auditing Case Study

1215 words - 5 pages

David Friehling will quite possibly be a future case study in auditing textbooks and courses throughout the United States. Mr. Friehling was the auditor for Bernard Madoff, who was recently convicted of running the largest Ponzi scheme ever uncovered through his business, Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities, LLC (BMIS). Mr. Madoff claimed to actively oversee more than $65 billion in private investments (it was later revealed that roughly $823 million remained of the more than $170 billion that went through his accounts over the years).(1) Mr. Friehling flagrantly and purposely violated provisions of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants’ Code of Professional ...view middle of the document...

They have an obligation to serve public interest, honor public trust, and be independent in fact and appearance when providing auditing and attestation services. The Code of Professional Conduct also declares that any member CPA “assumes an obligation of self-discipline above and beyond the requirements of laws and regulations”.(4) Mr. Friehling clearly violated every one of these AICPA requirements

The AICPA is also responsible for organizing peer reviews of members’ audit records. Mr. Friehling lied to the AICPA for years telling them that he did not perform audits. According to New York law, this enabled him to not be subject to peer review, which would have undoubtedly revealed his deceitful auditing work. This loophole has officially been closed – New York’s State Senate passed legislation in January 2009 that requires peer review as a CPA licensing requirement.(5)

Rule 101 – Independence, of the AICPA Code proclaims that covered members are prohibited from owning any stock or other direct investment in audit clients because it is potentially damaging to audit independence. Mr. Friehling freely violated this rule by owning investment accounts with BMIS worth more than $14 million. He and his family withdrew more than $5.5 million since 2002 (money that is surely gone by now, but that other investors would be very happy to have returned to them).(6)

Mr. Friehling also violated Generally Accepted Auditing Standards.(3) The General Standards state an auditor must maintain independent in mental attitude in all matters related to the audit and that the auditor must exercise due professional care in performing the audit and preparing the report. This did not occur. The Standards of Field Work state that an auditor must adequately plan the audit. They must obtain sufficient understanding of the client and their internal controls to assess the risk of material misstatement due, among other things, to fraud. Lastly, they must obtain sufficient appropriate evidence by performing audit procedures as a basis for their opinion regarding the financial statements being audited. None of this occurred. The final section, Standards of Reporting, requires the auditor to state when Generally Accepted Accounting Principles have not been consistently observed. This also did not occur.

The SEC probed Mr. Madoff’s business on numerous occasions for sixteen years. Despite many blatant warning signs, not once was there an investigation that uncovered the fraudulent auditing being performed. Regarding the SEC, Madoff was quoted in a jailhouse interview as saying that “it never entered the SEC’s mind that it was a Ponzi scheme,” and also that he had “too much credibility with them and they dismissed” the idea of a Ponzi scheme.(7)

The SEC contends that from 1991 through...

Other assignments on Mr. Friehling – A Future Auditing Case Study

Canter's Behavior Management Cycle: A Case Study

1413 words - 6 pages Canter’s Behavior Management Cycle: Case Study Grand Canyon University- EDU 450 October 5, 2013 When a teachers have a class with one or more disruptive behaviors it can be hard on teachers and students that come to school to teach and learn. According to the reading, “Effective teachers know that by motivating students to grasp directions quickly they can stay focused on instruction, which is critical to the learning process, and less

Ethics Case Study - Student Gets A Better Job Offer

992 words - 4 pages Ethics Case Study - Student Gets a Better Job Offer Step 1: Recognize: Define the ethical problem from all perspectives. • The student did not tell company B after accepting to work there that he already accepted to work company A. • The student did not notify career services office about any of this. Step 2: Clarify the Facts • The student agreed to work for company A at the beginning, because he did not hear from company B (yet

Urban Outfitters Continuing Case Study 4 - Marketing A Business

1144 words - 5 pages Urban Outfitters Continuing Case Study 4 Marketing a Business Felicia Lee Introduction to Business BUS 100 May 30, 2011 Abstract Marketing is a process which a company draws potential consumers/customers’ interest towards its goods and services. This process involves activities such as research, promotion

Victoria Chemicals Case Study 1 Victoria Chemicals (A) Mba9005 Ashley James

1935 words - 8 pages Project Risk and Cost Management Case Study Diamond Chemicals PLC (A): The Merseyside Project Group Members: Divya Yadav, Lamia Nafees, Ashwin Chadaga, Deeshanu Sharma Executive Summary This summary report provides an analysis and estimation of capital budgeting proposed that is being proposed to the Senior Management in Diamond Chemicals. The goal of this project was to save energy, improve

Week 3 Case Study You Tube, The Internet And The Future Of Movie

733 words - 3 pages system for a new employee effective and efficient self-service solution. Name the software solution in the customer’s case The software solution in the customer’s case is Microsoft Dynamics AX 2012. Microsoft Dynamics is said to be a line of integrated, adaptable business management solutions that helps companies make business decisions with greater confidence. The project team learned about the Microsoft Dynamics AX 2012 and decided to work

Case Study For Dell Inc In Appendix A

266 words - 2 pages Answer the following questions using the annual report of Dell, Inc. in Appendix A. a. Who is responsible for the preparation and integrity of Dell’s financial statements and notes? Management has the primary responsibility for the preparation and integrity of Dell’s financial statements and notes. b. In which note does Dell report its significant accounting policies used to prepare financial statements? Note 1 is where Dell report its

Accounting Scandal Of Worldcom

951 words - 4 pages that they were not doing anything illegal by Mr. Sullivan. To be honest, the error of recording operating expense to capital expense is one of the most visible ones in accounting and might be regarded as a stupid error. However, such a big external auditing firm as Arthur Anderson could not uncover this fundamental fraud. For that reason, it took three auditors from the internal audit department headed by Cynthia Cooper to uncover the fraud

Healthsouth- Summary

362 words - 2 pages overlooked the fraud at HealthSouth. Central to the investigation was the issue of what role Mr. Scrushy played in “cooking the books.” However, as the case unfolded, it highlighted many other issues such as: The role of Board of Directors in corporate governance; the role of the auditors; the effect of conflict of interest between an accounting firm and its consulting arm on auditing; whether the relationship between an investment bank and a

More Ants

995 words - 4 pages More Ants, More Audits by Jennifer Galang YOU contributor RUMMAGING through heaps of paper, I unexpectedly found a copy of my article, "Ants and Audit," which told my experiences with my first tax season as an auditor. Just a few months after it got published, here I am -- still a soldier ant working for the biggest auditing firm in the country -- getting down and dirty with working papers that desperately needed filing. Living my dream

Should Audit Firms Be Required To Rotate On Public Companies

1560 words - 7 pages To: Professor Moffit From: Lloyd Johnson Date: February 26, 2015 Re: Should Companies be required to rotate their auditing firms on a regular basis? As an accountant entering the modern business world, a case instilled in our minds is the Enron Scandal. For accountants, this was an embarrassing scenario and by effect brought numerous reforms, laws, and regulations. Many of these rulings are apparent in the present corporate setting. The

B2B Sale And Negotiation

915 words - 4 pages statistical methods of sales forecasting? 4. What is the importance of sales quotas and what are its different types? Section-B Case Study Mr. Dillip Gangadharan is the vice-president (sales) of MRF Tyre Company, who is negotiating with Mr. Chandrapal Singh, the Vice President (Purchase) of Maruti Udyog Limited the leading car manufacturer in India, for a contract to deliver tyres for the new car line called ALTO in the Indian market

Similar Documents

A Case Study Jane

511 words - 3 pages A Case Study-Jane A Case Study-Jane The description of the story was that Jane was constantly beaten from her father as a child. She was very confused as there was no explanation as to why he was beating on her. She was beat on by her husband 3 years into their marriage. The explanation of Jane’s beatings from her father was that she was being “naughty”. As for her husband he beat her for “challenging him”. This wasn't an acceptable

How To Write A Case Study

470 words - 2 pages Here's How: 1. Investigate and Analyze the Company’s History and Growth. A company’s past can greatly affect the present and future state of the organization. To begin your case study analysis, investigate the company’s founding, critical incidents, structure, and growth. 2. Identify Strengths and Weaknesses Within the Company. Using the information you gathered in step one, continue your case study analysis by examining and making a

A Social Worker Case Study Summary

355 words - 2 pages A Social Worker Case Study Phoenix A Social Worker Case Study The social worker in the case study displays characteristics of an effective helper. An effective helper has accurate empathy for her clients (O'Hagan, 2007). The helping relationship begins with the development of trust and empathy. The worker seems to understand the clients’ pain. Compassion and understanding assist the

Consensual Relationship Agreements: A Case Study

2144 words - 9 pages Consensual Relationship Agreements: A Case Study Zachary -- Dr. Kimberly A Carter BUS520 Leadership and Organizational Behavior April 22, 2012 Consensual Relationship Agreements: A Case Study Introduction A consensual relationship agreement is a written contract between coworkers used by their employer to publicly disclose a romantic relationship. The purpose of this contract is to protect the employer from future litigation in the