Miracles Essay

458 words - 2 pages

Hume defines miracles as ‘violations of the laws of nature’ which leads him to reject their existence, as by definition, they are beyond the realms of reasonable belief.
In defence of miracles, Swinburne challenges some of Hume’s practical arguments. Hume claims miracles only occur among uneducated and ignorant people, suggesting a lack of convincing testimony. Swinburne questions how you define when people are educated and what level of education is required to give ‘reliable’ testimony of a miracle, underlining Hume’s vagueness.
It could mean that people lack a familiarity with science as Hume suggests, but this fails to explain why many people who are clearly educated still attest to experiencing miracles. However, historical evidence ...view middle of the document...

Instead of this being contradictory, they perhaps simultaneously verify the belief in a common benevolent God, validating miracles.
Furthermore, Hume’s definition of a miracle is criticised as he places emphasis on the fixed and universal nature of natural laws. Swinburne introduces the argument of miracles being compatible with laws of nature, as laws are just generalisations. Instead, he calls miracles ‘counter instances to a law of nature’. For Hume the rigidity of these laws makes a miracle violating them very problematic. However, taking Swinburne’s approach, if natural laws are indeed expressions of probability, then a counter-instance to these laws does not necessarily involve a violation of the laws of nature. Thus Hume’s original definition is weakened as perhaps a more suitable alternative argues miracles are just different from events that have previously been observed and do not break some rule that must be obeyed. Perhaps then miracles are not impossible but unusual occurrences which increase our understanding.
The philosopher Ward reinforces this criticism, asserting that Hume’s definition implies there is something wrong with believing in miracles. It could therefore be argued that it is more suitable to deem miracles unlikely rather than impossible. However, Hume would respond that a sensible person would still choose the likely interpretation of an event rather than the unlikely. Following this judgement, miracles are simply illogical. Moreover, Mackie stresses that Hume simply meant that a miracle was an exception to the normal processes of nature, and this does not show a misunderstanding of the nature of the laws of nature.
These criticisms can be challenged with the support from

Other assignments on Miracles

Gospel Essay

325 words - 2 pages would ‘lose’ that right. Someone who has experienced a recent loss of a loved one to cancer or some other horrific death may question the Word. They may ask how a loving God could allow such suffering and pain. Their emotions can block the Word from entering their heart. There are some who attempt to reason away the miracles of the Bible. They try to use their intellect to defeat any argument a Christian has as to the validity of the

Islam Worksheet Essay

322 words - 2 pages speaking Jews and Christians. Basic Concepts of Islam The basic concepts of Islam include: 1. Allah (GOD) 2. Prophet hood a. Prophets i. Miracles b. Angels 3. Divine Books 4. The Qur’an 5. The Hadith or Sunnah 6. Pillars of Islam 7. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) 8. Arabic Language 9. Clothing 10. Food 11. Calendar 12. Economic, Social, and Political System of Life Practices of Islam Fundamental to Islamic doctrine and practice are "The Five Pillars." These constitute the five basic...

St. Padre Pio

419 words - 2 pages received the gift of Stigmata. The news of this spread all over the world and people flocked to witness this miracle. Scientists had examined the wounds over and over but could never come up with an explanation. He had performed many miracles which included curing a blind little girl. Pio was also rewarded by God with other magnificent gifts such as the gift of perfume which was the beautiful odor of roses that marked Padre Pio’s presence and Pio’s

Prayer Of A Worship Leader

436 words - 2 pages answering our prayers and the little miracles we have experienced in our Lives. We would like to praise and thank you for arranging our time to be with you today, to listen to your words and share the gift of wisdom to our dear sisters in the community. Dear Father in Heaven, we thank you for the wonderful gift of using Handmaids of the Lord family as a vehicle to bring us closer to you. And we would like to pray that you give us the grace to

The Son Of God

1017 words - 5 pages his old age, he decides to tell us about it too so that we might believe this movie tell the story of Jesus birth, His miracles, His teaching, His torture, His death and His resurrection. It is good to tale again for the sake of some people who may not have yet heard it because they don’t go to church, who may never read the Bible, through this visual storytelling become a way of knowing Jesus and how He come to life. As such Jesus is kind

Db2 Educ 205

607 words - 3 pages him. This is what Piaget relates our Ethnics, politics, and moral issues to. At this stage, we are more mature in our spiritual walk that we can know, feel, experience, and reason that there is a God because of the creation of the world, or the miracles that we see. This may also be a stage where a person denies Christian worldview and turns to another worldview.

Aimee Semple Mcpherson

603 words - 3 pages through her ministry, many people were saved, healed, and delivered. There were many instances where she would see miracles of people being healed, not because she was seeking those things, but God would start to heal the people. Eventually, her ministry was booming and she was being called to many places to lead revival/evangelistic meetings. She then moved to Los Angeles, which in due time built the church now called Angelus Temple. Aimee

Stem Cell Treatment

726 words - 3 pages ethical to use human embryos to procure embryonic stem cells? 2. Medical miracles don’t happen by themselves. Conclusion: Capriana In conclusion, stem cell treatments are a type of intervention strategy that introduces new cells into damaged tissue in order to treat disease or injury. Many medical researchers believe that stem cell treatments have the potential to change the face of human disease and alleviate suffering

The Discussion Of Discussion

975 words - 4 pages is intrinsically possible, not to do the intrinsically impossible. You may attribute miracles to Him, but not nonsense. There is no limit to His power….It remains true that all things are possible with God: the intrinsic impossibilities are not things but nonentities. It is no more possible for God than for the weakest of His creatures to carry out both of two mutually exclusive alternatives; not because His power meets an obstacle, but because

A Different Shot

997 words - 4 pages survived this horrible ordeal. By changing “unconsolable” to “eloquent” and “though it couldn’t save her” to “and the fireman saved her”, the poem now has a happier light. Now it is easy to see the second point of view, where the photographer isn’t being selfish. This new version gives the photographer the credit he deserves. He is now showing the miracles that can happen in Creve Coeur instead of the tragedies. Now the reader may think about how

Economic Systems

686 words - 3 pages contribute to the common good of the state to make this type of system work. “Miracles” of Communism Everyone had a job. While everyone had a job, no one worked. While no one worked, the rates were 100 percent satisfied. Although the rates were 100 per cent satisfied, stores had nothing. Although nothing has been in stores - everyone had everything. Although everyone had everything, everything was being stolen. Even then everything was being

Similar Documents

Miracles Essay

357 words - 2 pages 
Why! who makes much of a miracle?
As to me, I know of nothing else but miracles,
Whether I walk the streets of Manhattan,
Or dart my sight over the roofs of houses toward the sky,
Or wade with naked feet along the beach, just in the edge of the
Or stand under trees in the woods,
Or talk by day with any one I love--or sleep in the bed at night with
any one I love,
Or sit at table at dinner with my mother,
Or look at strangers opposite me

Miracles In The Bible Essay

718 words - 3 pages Miracles in the bible N.T. Miracle # 1 Two Blind men cured Matthew 9:27-31 N.T. Miracle # 2 Blind man healed Mark 8:16-26 N.T. Miracle # 3 Centurion’s servant Matthew 8:5-13 N.T. Miracle # 4 Deaf and dumb man Mark 7:31-37 N.T. Miracle # 5 Demon cast out of boy Matthew 17:14-21 N.T. Miracle # 6 Demon possessed man Luke 11:14-22 N.T. Miracle # 7 Dumb spirit cast out Matthew 9:32-33 N.T. Miracle # 8 Ear

Jesus Essay

723 words - 3 pages Joann Juarez CWV-101 February 16, 2014 Dr. Ron Woodworth Jesus In the film Jesus we follow his path through the world. Throughout the film we learn about the Messianic Prophecies, Jesus’s miracles, his death and resurrection. I believe learning and understanding this topic can help me be successful in my life. Understanding why Jesus was chosen to come to Earth, his miracles, and learning his sacrifices for us will help anyone

Is God Good ? Essay

1287 words - 6 pages good’ is by creation in genesis 1 and 2 which shows God either creating the world or how he is crafting everything, also in the bible of how God has preformed miracles and in todays society. In the bible there are many passages, which say ‘God is good’ for example in James ‘every good thing bestowed and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation, or shifting shadow’ this is clearly