This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Macro Econ: Science Or Not? Essay

671 words - 3 pages

David Lenz

Macroeconomics: Science or Not?

After reading both articles about macroeconomics and whether it is a science or not, I am intrigued by both writers’ ideas. In the article, “What is economics good for?” by Rosenberg and Curtain, they discuss that economics should not be considered a science but instead a craft, saying that “the Chairman of the Federal Reserve must, like a first violinist tuning the orchestra, have the rare ear to fine-tune complexity (Rosenberg and Curtain, 1).” By saying this they are implying that in order to have a strong grasp on economics and know what you are doing, you must step away from the hard math and instead use wisdom and a strong, “gut feeling.”
In the second article titled, “The Real Trouble with Economics,” written by economist Paul Krugman, he argues against Rosenberg and Curtain stating that they have missed some important facts about how recent crisis were handled and that economics is in fact a science. In the ...view middle of the document...

If I were in office when the crisis hit, I would have used Krugman’s idea that macroeconomics is a science, by using the AD/AS model. By looking at the model I would be able to see which way the demand curve needed to be shift and based off that, which policy, contractionary or expansionary, to put in place. The AD/AS model does not tell the exact remedies that are needed in order to perfectly adjust the economy but similar to other sciences, it is a model that can lead you in the right direction, and that is where personal knowledge and intuition steps in.
After reading both articles, I believe that the financial crisis in 2008 was more of a political crisis rather than an economic one. My reasoning for this is that the leaders in the financial sector created an idea that they could create paper assets whose value would be determined by housing prices, and believed that housing prices would continue to rise without a hiccup. Without using models or data collected, this method backfired completely on the economy and leads me to think that the leaders of the financial system, who were key word, elected, created this idea without the use of economics as a science. Austerity policies are so popular because they are ways for government to get what they want. If the models were closely accessed and further looked at, it would show that these policies are not in the best interest of the economy or population as a whole.
So to answer the main question of whether macroeconomics is a science, I return to Krugman’s article and agree that, macroeconomics is indeed a science. I can support this by comparing macroeconomics to astronomy. Both sciences have a large set of data, going back decades, even centuries, and models conducted through that data. Macroeconomics has politics however, people thinking they are right no matter what the data holds, and that is what mixes up the two sciences. Macroeconomics as a whole, no matter the politics, is critical to the welfare of society and is a science.

Sources Cited
Krugman, Paul. "The Real Trouble With Economics." The New York TImes. The New York Times Company, 27 Aug. 2013. Web. 4 Nov. 2014.

Rosenberg, Alex, and Tyler Curtain. "What Is Economics Good For?" The New York Times. The New York Times Company, 24 Aug. 2013. Web. 4 Nov. 2014.

Other assignments on Macro Econ: Science Or Not?

Sdi Macro Environmental Analysis

1466 words - 6 pages macro environment analysis include new innovations, the frequency of technological change and new platforms or software used by companies and consumers. Failing to keep pace with technology can put a company behind competitors. Changes to consumer products will also drive this change, as consumers will have certain expectations of technology from products offered by a company. Environmental factors include the items that affect the common living

The Economy Of Uk Essay

2897 words - 12 pages . Reference:  

M2 Assignment 2012

490 words - 2 pages analyses of the macro environment. (Jooste et al., 2012, Chapter 2; or Du Plessis et al., 2009, Chapter 2). The students have to identify FIVE trends in the macro environment that impact on micro breweries. A trend is something that changes in the macro environment, for example:  Rise in disposable income  Customers search for value for money  Rise of black middle class  Rise of social media  Rising costs.  Environment protection/‘green


335 words - 2 pages , but the word as it will be - and naturally this means that there must be an accurate perception of the world as it will be. This, in turn, means that our statesmen, our businessmen, our Everyman, must take on a science fictional way of thinking, whether he likes it or not or even whether he knows it or not. Only so can the deadly problems of today be solved. "My Own View," The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, Holdstock, ed., 1978 Asimov on

Go Tomorrow

566 words - 3 pages ECON 250 ECONOMICS OF POVERTY Views of Inequality and Poverty Reading: Schiller, Chapter 1 Review of Graphs: PDF file (blackboard) Today’s Topics • • • • • Hot issues Analytical framework for causes of poverty The complexities of measuring well-being How poverty is related to inequality Using Graphs: A review Hot Issues • What is poverty? • Poverty in America – – – – – Who are the poor? why are they poor


257 words - 2 pages seeking employment. If the government guaranteed an income, the people that don’t really want to work would stop looking for a job which would drop them from the labor force. If they are not part of the labor force then they are not counted in the unemployment rate. I don’t think a cost of living adjustment should apply for those that are unemployed. If the government income is not enough to support the individual or a family

Acton-Burnett Case

4336 words - 18 pages (aside from being designated as the head) over the task force. The task force was a formality in the Keene & Baker’s eyes, thus they concluded the area that needed to be studied was marketing division (market managers made final forecasts based on info from prod mgrs, VP of sales, VP of manufacturing, & econ forecasts from VP of econ). At this point Keene & Baker never gave much thought or importance to the task force therefore they were just

Management Organization

702 words - 3 pages . Organization theory originally focused primarily on the organization as a unit, as opposed to organization behaviour, which explored individual and group behaviour within the organization. This perspective is sometimes also called “macro-OB”. 3. Two Types of Decisions- a. Programmed Decisions Routine Automatic processing b. Non-programmed Decisions 4. Satisficing- Choosing acceptable alternative to resolving a problem or pursuing an opportunity

Access To Quality Healthcare Paper

1746 words - 7 pages United States. Besides, the demand for registered nurses and changes in science is already exceeding supply in U.S. nation, including more implications associated with other ethical dilemmas. Healthcare Labor Shortage People have to realize that progresses in medical technology, increasing expenses and market forces provide to the financial decline of many rural healthcare organizations. In reality, small rural

Pest Analysis

526 words - 3 pages when conducting a strategic analysis or doing a market research, and gives an overview of the different macro-environmental factors that the company has to take into consideration. It is a useful strategic tool for understanding market growth or decline, business position, potential and direction for operations. Social factors include the cultural aspects and include health consciousness, population growth rate, age distribution, career

Task Environment

269 words - 2 pages Set 105 Environmental Scanning/Industry Analysis – 1 1. What external environmental variables should be scanned? In conducting an external environmental scan, focus should be drawn to two environmental variables: • Societal environment (macro-environment) – This is the general environment in which the business organization operates. It is characterized by those variables on which the business has no control. It does not directly

Similar Documents

Economic Essay

1484 words - 6 pages NATURAL SCIENCES DEPARTMENT COURSE SYLLABUS S.Y. 2012 - 2013 I. II. III. COURSE NUMBER: SCTESO1 COURSE TITLE: Science , Technology and Society (Lecture 3 units, 54 HOURS/SEM) COURSE DESCRIPTION: Science, Technology and Society (STS) focus on the interrelationship of the three components, not only in the present time but for the future as well. It tackles important issues in the society as a result of development of science and technology

Economics Essay

2233 words - 9 pages keep this firm in business (or the firm will not produce at all). (g) Suppose the government instead chooses to force the monopolist to charge a price equal to their average total cost. How much will the firm produce, assuming it produces more than its unregulated equilibrium? What will be their profits? 2 Econ 101: Intro to Microeconomics Spring 2012, Handout 8 Solutions (Note: This problem involves a quadratic equation. The numbers are

Online Shopping Market Essay

540 words - 3 pages form from 2004-2009. [pic] E-stats. (2011, May 26). Retrieved November 23, 2010. Retrieved from Feuer, S. (2010, May 1). Social shopping science. Retrieved November 25, 2011. Retrieved from: Market Wire, (2010, August). Eight out of ten consumers shop online at least once a week. Retrieved November 25, 2011. Retrieved from;col1

Macroenvironmental Effects On The Marketing Mix And Qantas

2557 words - 11 pages , Environmental, Legal). To utilize this tool even further, one can apply PESTEL and the effects of the macro-environment to their business and evaluate the apparent or implicit effects on the marketing mix. Companies such as Qantas, an Australian airline company could greatly benefit from the application of PESTEL analysis. After a huge financial loss in 2011 and a huge decline in market share forcing a major structural change and the cut of 1000