Laws And Ethics Essay

979 words - 4 pages

Laws and Ethics

The Dilemma: A married couple, both addicted to drugs, is unable to care for their infant daughter. She is taken from them by court order and placed in a foster home. The years pass. She comes to regard her foster parents as her real parents. They love her as they would their own daughter. When the child is 9 years old, the natural parents, rehabilitated from drugs, begin court action to regain custody. The case is decided in their favor. The child is returned to them, against her will. Do ethics support the law in this case?
The question of whether any school of ethics supports this ruling is not as black and white as it may seem. The Care-based theory of thinking ...view middle of the document...

Marshall William Waller a California child custody attorney states that “most judges recognize that it is their job to decide where the child will live, and Not the child’s” (Waller, 2009). Both attorneys’ statements back the court’s decision to return the child to her biological parents. Ethics pertaining to this situation are not black and white especially when using the Care-based approach. There are many peoples’ feelings to consider especially the child’s. Based on the limited information provided and if the biological parent’s parental rights were not terminated, I would say reach a solution using this theory is hard because of the empathy logic used to come to a conclusion. You came be empathetic to all parties involved. I do feel the ruling is just because if the parents have truly rehabilitated themselves they do deserve a second chance. This is my opinion in this matter.
The Rules-based theory would say that this is an ethical decision because the law (rule) was followed. The decision of the court is ethical regardless of the effect it has on the child or the foster parents. Rules-thinking does not factor in how attached to the foster parents this child has become, it is black and white because the court ruling would be the rules followed in this case.
There are huge differences in the 2 solutions; Care-based has me place myself in the shoes of the affected parties and by doing so make a just and ethical decision. Using the Care-based theory of thinking makes this decision is a difficult one because as I stated earlier there are many things and people to consider, mainly the child. Following your heart is not always the correct answer but this is what the Care-based theory would have you do. Rules-based is cut and dry because of what the law states and...

Other assignments on Laws And Ethics

Managing Ethics In The Workplace Essay

4295 words - 18 pages reacted and demanded that businesses place high value on fairness and equal rights. Anti-trust laws were instituted. Government agencies were established. Unions were organized. Laws and regulations were established. 2. Ethics programs help maintain a moral course in turbulent times. As noted earlier in this document, Wallace and Pekel explain that attention to business ethics is critical during times of fundamental change -- times much like those

Business Ethics Essay

491 words - 2 pages , across countries and sectors. | | View Feedback | Question 2 | | 1 / 1 point | The law can be said to be a definition of the minimum acceptable standards of behaviour, with many morally contestable issues not covered by the law. What does this imply for business ethics? Question options: | 1)  | In a sense, business ethics can be said to begin where the law ends. | | | 2)  | Businesses should prevent laws from being enacted

Ethics Essay

878 words - 4 pages Ethics Essay LeeAnn Tedford ETH/316 3/21/2016 Linda Emmele Ethics Everybody has a different upraising making them each have different views on ethics. There are three different types of ethical theories. These types include the virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological. Ethical theory deals with how one should behave in relation to someone else. Virtue According to IEP, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Virtue

Business Ethics

497 words - 2 pages is the expected behavior of individuals, and the laws Reflect with the required actions do there may be legal but immoral, or unethical, but illegal. The work ethic of the basics of success because it reflects the organization the confidence of its employees and its organs, as well as the society in which they operate in his confidence, commitment to ethics will lead to the development of employees and reflects the attention paid by these

Business Ethics

1977 words - 8 pages foundation for our duty to follow the human rights and respect one another. Human rights have become the foundation of the development of political systems, including our own democratic rule. There have been wars around the world to gain them, instill them, and protect them. The Kantian theory can be found at the foundation of many policies, laws, regulations, and in the actions of individual’s every day behavior. Rawls theory of ethics places

Analysis

278 words - 2 pages , Martin Luther, Abraham Lincoln and a few more. What King was really saying is that they only called him extremist because what he wanted was something they were against, not because his means were extreme. His appeal to ethics was critical when he wrote about how we should only be obligated to follow the just laws and that the unjust laws can be disobeyed in an attempt to make a change. This act or lack of action is called Civil Disobedience. Civil

Sales Ethics

642 words - 3 pages , civil, regulatory laws or industry codes. Moral decisions are rational as opposed to emotional and are balanced so there are no big winners and big losers. A simple question to ask in deciding if the decision is ethical or not is: “how would I feel if what I am doing appeared in tomorrow’s news headlines?” After all is said and done there are really only two important points when it comes to ethics in sales: The first is a standard to follow and the second is the collective will to follow the standard. It is time sales professionals addressed both.

Cross Cultural Perspectives

1225 words - 5 pages Cross Cultural Perspectives Most companies and other organizations that have operated primarily in the U.S. have an established code of ethics which they follow in order to ensure that they are conducting business in an ethical and socially responsible manner. American companies that exhibit unethical behavior, such as fraud and labor law violations can be subjected to an outside investigation and subsequent prosecution. In the United

The Evolution Of Business

1390 words - 6 pages by individuals (Macauley, 2004). In addition to laws intended to mandate more ethical business behavior, the 20th century also saw the creation of the first codes of conduct for businesses. For example, department store founder and pioneer of social responsibility Edward Filene’s personal code of ethics came from two standards: “A business, in order to have the right to succeed, must be of real service to the community” and “real service in

Ethical Self

873 words - 4 pages management excellence through education and research. ACHE is known for its education programs. ACHE established network of more than 80 chapters provides access to networking, education, and career development at the local level. The goal of the organization is to be the premier professional society for healthcare executives dedicated to improving health care delivery (American College of Health Care Executives, 2012). The ethics self

Business Ethics Across Cultures

1494 words - 6 pages Business Ethics across Cultures Jeff Christison XMGT 216 / Organizational Ethics and social Responsibility (AXIA) Carolyn A. Fuentes December 5th, 2010 The first country I chose to research was Germany. I chose them because the world already knows about their personal morals and ethics in history, and how they could be swayed by one individual. They systematically set their morals aside and allowed one man to dictate the country’s

Similar Documents

Computers And Ethics In The Workplace

311 words - 2 pages on people in today’s society. For that reason, computer ethics supports the how some debate on just how much influence computers need to have in human communication. With computers evolving constantly, ethical standards will continue to be constructed by computer ethics and will always have newer concerns that come from recent technology. With the new changes in technology like computers, more supervisors are coping with having to manager employees for proper use of company computers; they have to stay informed of all new ethical problems and the laws that were created to enforce ethics with workers.

Code Of Ethics Essay

1066 words - 5 pages and policies (Macy’s Inc. Code of conduct and ethics, 2012). • There will be no sliding of accounting information (cooking the books). • Publicly traded stocks will be processed in accordance with Security Exchange Commission rules. • Stockholder information will be updated annually and in accordance with the Security Exchange Commission guidelines. Privacy: Employees will adhere to privacy laws and regulations that adhere to federal

The Differences Between Ethics And Law

552 words - 3 pages , therefore, an act of tampering and changing electronic information is considered as vandalism and disrespect for other people’s property. SIMILARITIES BETWEEN ETHICS & LAW Both ethics and law are complimentary to each other and are made: • • • to guide user from misusing computers to create a healthy computer society, so that computers are used to contribute to a better life to prevent any crime DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ETHICS AND LAWS ETHICS

Management Essay

9111 words - 37 pages . Learning Outcome: Discuss the roles of ethics and social responsibility in strategic management 28) European firms are increasingly adopting explicit, American-style sexual harassment laws. Answer: TRUE Diff: 2 Page Ref: 316 AACSB: Ethical Understanding and Reasoning Abilities Objective: 10.01 Explain why good ethics is good business in strategic management. Learning Outcome: Discuss the roles of ethics and social responsibility