This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Julius Caesar A Tyrant? Essay

1848 words - 8 pages

Does Shakespeare depict Julius Caesar as a tyrant who deserved to be deposed because of his unconstitutional usurpation of power? 

William Shakespeare’s well-renowned play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, has led to centuries of controversial debate on the validity of tyrannicide based on his depiction of Julius Caesar. Some scholars have argued that Shakespeare intended to portray Caesar as a tyrant, while others believe he is acting as a just King. On one hand, it is difficult to assume that Shakespeare plainly viewed Caesar as a tyrant, especially since Shakespeare deliberately left Caesar’s actions and intentions ambiguous, making him into a less obvious tyrannical figure compared to ...view middle of the document...

Furthermore, I will briefly compare Shakespeare’s Caesar to Plutarch’s Caesar and argue that Shakespeare’s ambiguity of Caesar’s character and reputation actually portrays Caesar as far more tyrannical than Plutarch’s character. Finally, I will argue that the deposition of Caesar was justified.
Shakespeare often wrote works that were politically charged and representative of the political atmosphere at the time. His representation of rebellion in classical Rome also resonated with the political turmoil in England during the 1500s. From 1558 to 1603, Queen Elizabeth I, was seen as a grossly unjust and tyrannical ruler. By Shakespeare’s day, “tyrant” was applicable to “any usurper of power by force as well as to any lawful ruler who governed viciously.” Elizabeth was an unlawful ruler who governed viciously, while Caesar was a usurper of power by force. Elizabeth thwarted numerous attempts to depose her and install Mary, Queen of Scots, as the ruler of England and she oversaw the “execution of scores of Catholic—the banishment of hundreds of others for religion, and the expropriation, imprisonment and ruin of Catholic men, women, and children, in thousands, for the evident purpose of utterly extirpating their religion in England.” Caesar was not yet fully launched as a tyrannical King, like Elizabeth was as Queen. However, the two certainly shared similarities that further position Caesar as a tyrant. For example, when it came time to discuss Elizabeth’s succession, she forbade any deliberation of it. When Peter Wentworth tried to bring up the question of succession in 1593, he was jailed and left to die by the will of the Queen. Similarly, Caesar “imperiously refuses to repeal the decree banishing Cimber’s brother” referring back to his will as ruler. Moreover, Elizabeth “craved the flattery that Caesar was said to love. She was said to have spoken of as a living goddess, as if immortal—flattery of a kind derided by Cassius: “this man [Caesar] is not become a god”, “immortal Caesar.” Continuing with the argument that Caesar clearly displays traits that are tyrannical, Miola points out that:

Shakespeare's Caesar has some of the salient characteristics of the tyrant in practice. He fears plots and conspiracies, twice observing early in the play that such men as Cassius are "dangerous" (I. ii. 195- 210). Despite stirring denunciations of fear, Caesar orders a sacrifice in response to the unnatural portents of the storm. Calphurnia persuades him of the threat to himself and he fashions an excuse for staying home, "Mark Antony shall say I am not well" (II. ii. 55). He shows superbia, arrogant pride, another distinguishing characteristic of the tyrant. Shakespeare's Caesar considers himself a special creation, far superior to ordinary mortals.

This shows an excellent display of archetypal tyrannical traits possessed by Caesar as portrayed by Shakespeare. From a classical perspective, his fear of plots and conspiracies can be interpreted to...

Other assignments on Is Julius Caesar A Tyrant?

Shakespeare Essay

2285 words - 10 pages Shakespeare’s current fashions, adapting issues to public taste In the second Shakespearean stage, which runs from 1598-1604, are located the pieces often called "middle works", characterized by a higher stage virtuosity Dramas Julius Caesar, Hamlet and Othello announce the next period, known as the great tragedies (1604-1608), in which Shakespeare delves into the deepest feelings of the human being The final phase (1608-1611

The Three Little Pigs Paraphrased Essay

1433 words - 6 pages story confronts the idea of the tyrant who is unable to reconcile his position with his perceived importance in world events. The third story is by Fazio and Ek and written in the year 2000. The story presented here is one observing the idea of good versus evil and brings into question the roles of fear, confrontation, and evil as major parts of life. The final story is by A. Hokum, B. Goniff, and C. Crook and was written in 1997. They used

Freud: Psychoanalysis

443 words - 2 pages Freud (1875-1896) * Amile Nathansohn Freud (1835-1930) * (Julius, Anna, Rosa, Marie, Adolfine, Paula and Alexander) * In 1885 he received a traveling great from the UV an decided to study in Paris. * Hysteria * Catharsis * During the late 1890’s, Freud suffered both professional isolation and personal crises. * In 1902, Freud invited a small group of somewhat younger Viennese physicians. * In 1908, this

Gs202

626 words - 3 pages Helps keep you and the reader on track It may or may not include a plan of development Narrows the scope of your paper Makes for a stronger paper Shows that you acknowledge the different positions on the topic Answers questions like who, what, where, why and how Testing your thesis statement Does the thesis statement show analysis and depth of thought, or is it mainly descriptive? Does the thesis statement present an argument about the

A New Vision For Public Administration

1603 words - 7 pages of branded control under state’s view. This is controlled from the top and if the top person in charge is a tyrant, then the control is made unconditional by intimidations and eliminations. “In a democracy, the situation is more complicated: Laws and elections must be honored, a free press tolerated, and, in America, the separation of powers and divisions of federalism dealt with” (p. 624). Public administration centers on matters of

The Inferno (Rough Draft)

966 words - 4 pages their master-i.e. Caesar. Dante finds both Brutus and Cassius being eaten by Satan, a three-headed beast who devours souls of the ninth level. Brutus and Cassius are two of the unlucky ones. It is this level that I think is equal to the death penalty in our society. Religion is a major part of Inferno. The religion in the book is similar to what I conceive religion to be today. Dante, who was a firm believer of God, is on his was to heaven. However

Macbeth Synopsis

753 words - 4 pages Scene 1 begins in a deserted place between Scotland and England, with Birnam wood in the distance. There are Scottish refugees containing men, women, and children. Macduff stands at distance from the others, mournfully. A chorus starts singing about Scotland and how it has become an oppressed land, full of mourning people and the tomb for its own sons. They show a great love for their homeland and a great sadness for losing it to the tyrant

Comparison And Contrast Of Two Major Fast Food Restaurants

890 words - 4 pages iceberg lettuce and sometimes dilutes the salad dressing. This, however, is a small inconvenience compared to the faults against McDonald’s salads. McDonald’s salads lack in appearance and freshness, causing them to fail at establishing a superior presentation of healthy food choices. These salads appear thrown together and often look wilted. The chicken pieces in the Garden and Caesar Selections are sliced but not separated and, therefore, need to

Irregular Warfare Strategy For Somalia

681 words - 3 pages Introduction The use of Irregular Warfare has been ongoing for years around the world. Irregular warfare is described as a violent struggle among state and non-state actors for legitimacy and influence over the relevant populations. I will discuss where the U.S. may apply military force in conjunction with other means of national power to stabilize the nation of Somalia. I will also discuss why it would be considered as an Irregular Warfare

Healthsouth Scandal

2596 words - 11 pages into the concept. Dr. Phillips testified he felt that this concept was and still is very comprehensive. He did not know of the fraudulent accounting and believes under the new directors the company can continue to succeed. Executives at HealthSouth According to Jennings (2012), the workers consider Scrushy as a tyrant and micromanager. He had Monday morning numbers meetings which were referred to as the “Monday morning beatings,” (p. 184

Essentials Of A True Hero

1162 words - 5 pages of leadership. Despite the difference in styles, William Wallace’s courageous and active leadership proves the most essential. Ultimately, Wallace’s undying passion and determination for freedom helps his army prevail as an underdog. In the film Braveheart, the opening scene is set during late 13th century England, which is controlled by a tyrant known as King Edward the Longshanks. His claim over the Scottish throne cause great suffering for

Similar Documents

Jealousy Essay

385 words - 2 pages * For a long time and to this day it's been questioned whether jealousy can ever be a good thing.Those who claim that jealousy can be beneficial argue that it evokes the determination and will to be better and to work harder to reach goals. However, examples from literature and American history prove that this notion is not necessarily valid. The play of Julius Caesar and the assassination of Martin Luther King illustrate that jealousy can

In What Ways Does The Language And Imagery Of Antony’s Speech Demonstrate His Manipulation Of The Crowd?

677 words - 3 pages In what ways does the language and imagery of Antony’s speech demonstrate his manipulation of the crowd? In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Mark Antony’s speech at Caesar’s funeral, despite all his protestations to the contrary, is fuelled by one purpose: vengeance to those who murdered his beloved Caesar. He uses combinations of verbal irony, repetitive diction, and heavy emphasis on emotions to sway his audience. He does so without guilt or

Ambition Essay

1246 words - 5 pages you arrive in.” 1.1 Introduction: Many people have different ambitions in life so the word ambition would have different definitions, depending on whom you ask. To me ambition is an urge desire to achieve your goals or succeed. Ambition leads you to dedication, motivation and determination. Ambition is a feeling that is driven from within. In other words it is the sum of two factors; force and goal. In this essay, I will define "ambition", the

History 454 Effects Of Castration On Men And Women

553 words - 3 pages , not cure, as a goal for transvestites and transsexuals. 16 Much of Cauldwell's published work was based on his correspondence with letter writers asking for his advice through Sexology magazine. During his time at Sexology, Cauldwell published over 3,000 answers to questions, and he answered thousands of other letters personally. His contribution as a sexologist, and especially to transgenderism, therefore, is as a popular writer dispensing