Idealism And The Missing Explanation Argument

644 words - 3 pages

Idealists believe that we know objects through the way we perceive them, that they are mind-dependent. However, realists, who believe objects are mind-independent, proposed the missing explanation argument in order to disprove idealism. This theory supposes that everything is dependent on the mind; if this is true, then nothing in idealism can explain the regularities in our experiences. Although idealists and realists both provide good reasoning, neither argument by itself completely explains the perception of objects. We need to apply both views.
Internalists have made many attempts to answer the consistencies of experiences. One of their answers is that in order to believe that something exists, we must first know it. Therefore, it becomes an internal object which is conditioned by consciousness, and since anything conditioned by consciousness is mind-dependent, the object can only exist if there is a mind-dependent internal ...view middle of the document...

Ultimately, he goes on to say that external objects exist, since they are perceivable. This idea, however, seems to be essentially realist. It is because Kant used both idealist and realist point of views, that he was able to provide such profound arguments.
It is true that internalists have no way of directly answering the missing explanation argument, but their point of view is still valid in some cases. If objects were truly mind-independent, as a realist would argue, then how can one explain different perceptions? For example, three people look at the same object – a red car. However, one of them is colorblind. The colorblind person sees the object as a black car while the others see it as a red car. Now, the fact that the two non-colorblind people see the car as red supports the realist notion that objects are not dependent on the mind; they are both able to see the car as red because the color red is part of the nature of the object, in this case, the car. But what explains why the colorblind person sees a black car? If the color red is part of the intrinsic nature of that car, then shouldn’t everyone see a red car? Most people might respond to this by stating that the colorblind person is an anomaly, that he is not part of the majority. Even so, there is no way for us to know what the nature of the object truly is; just because the majority of the people believe something, does not make it the truth. For example, hundreds of years ago, everybody but a small handful of people thought that the earth was flat. Those who believed it was round were persecuted, even though they were right. The truth cannot be seen by realism on its own; in order to account for different perceptions, a mix of both idealism and realism is needed.
Taking the above into account, neither the idealists nor the realists alone are able to give a direct answer to the different views given from the issue between colorblind and non-colorblind people. This is easily answered, however, by a combination of idealism and realism, which is similar to Kant’s argument; the object exists and does in fact have intrinsic properties which allow the regularities in experience, but people can also perceive things differently in their own minds.

Other assignments on Idealism And The Missing Explanation Argument

How To Write A Critique Essay

737 words - 3 pages Steps for Writing Critiques (from Behrens and Rosen’s Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum, 12th Edition) 1. Introduce. Introduce both the passage under analysis and the author. State the author’s main argument and the point(s) you intend to make about it. Provide background information to help readers understand the relevance of the passage. This background information may include one or more of the following: * an

Ap Modes Assignment 2

850 words - 4 pages 1) In order for someone to understand the dynamics of cause and effect and also to evaluate the casual argument they need to understand two important concepts, which are the necessary condition and sufficient condition. Necessary condition is a condition that has to be occurred for an event to be happened, and failed to do so the event will not occur. Sufficient Condition is a condition for the occurrence of an event is one that guarantees the

American Romanticism

278 words - 2 pages events * Acknowledged the evil of man & the horror of evil. Decline of Romanticism: * Civil war in 1861 caused abrupt end to Romanticism. * A.R. gave way to tempering of idealism and desire to portray society more realistically. * Emphasis on thought and emotion seemed ineffectual in a world that was experiencing dramatic social change.


291 words - 2 pages If your coursework matches the examiners expectations and perhaps exceeds it, nothing can prevent you from excelling in your Management Essay. The examiner considers several viewpoints when s/he goes through your coursework paper. The more the sources you use to prove the facts, the better it is. The relevance of the information you have gathered. The explanation must be in your words and thought of by you. The comments, ideas and reasons

The Six Scientific Thinkin Principals

823 words - 4 pages , falsifiability, extra ordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, reliability, and Occam’s razor. Extra ordinary claims This is a scientific thinking principal, which argues that extra ordinary claims need extraordinary evidence. In other words, the more an argument contradicts what people know already, the more convincing the evidence has to be prior to people accepting the claim. For instance, a sight on the internet “where does big

Thomas Aquino

1291 words - 6 pages God. At the same time, this fool has in his mind the idea of God as “that than nothing better can be thought". Because he understands and has in mind this statement, he comes to a contradiction letting us know that God exists. In his discussion, Anselm also refers to the relationship between what we know (epistemology) and what something is (ontology). It would be Gaunilon who oppose Anselm’s point of view. Anselm’s ontological argument


543 words - 3 pages . Harris's office without his permission.   4. Choose the correct sentence. Correct Answer: B       The girl's vitality and humor were infectious. [one girl] Explanation: Place the apostrophe before the “s” to show singular possession. Your Answer: A            The girls vitality and humor were infectious. [one girl]   5. Choose the correct sentence. Correct Answer: A       The women's dresses are on the second floor. Explanation: To show


1019 words - 5 pages Table 1 Running Time of the Pawnshop N=20 | FREQUENCY | PERCENTAGE | 16 years and up | 7 | 35 | 1-4 years | 5 | 25 | 10-15 years | 4 | 20 | 5-9 years | 3 | 15 | Missing | 1 | 5 | TOTAL | 20 | 100% | Table 2 Choice of Running a Pawnshop Business N=20 | FREQUENCY | PERCENTAGE | Family Business | 7 | 35 | Own Choice | 5 | 25 | Challenging and Crucial | 1 | 5 | Only Employed | 7 | 35 | TOTAL | 20 | 100% | Table

Motor Learning Theory

918 words - 4 pages Jack A. Adams’ A Closed-Loop Theory Of Motor Learning attempts to explain the process of how motor learning is achieved in humans. He argues that a sufficient motor learning theory should cover how verbal and motor processes work together to produce learning and also how errors are detected and corrected. In this paper it will be shown that Adams fails to do this as there are numerous flaws incorporated into his argument. Adams tends to overlook

Essay Writing

2124 words - 9 pages explanation A might be more useful and valid than B in these circumstances. In the conclusion of your essay, on the other hand, you might want to point out that in other contexts (social, cultural, eras, etc.) there may be other factors that need to be considered. Do these limit or question the weight of claims you have made in the development of your current argument? Key questions before you embark on writing your essay • Have you identified

Analyzing Persuasive Arguments

1573 words - 7 pages against something and slanted writing is when the writer carefully chooses their facts, words and tone to achieve a particular response or attitude from the reader. This bias and slanted material can be reduced by considering the missing components of the argument. Consider whether there were any facts that the writer deliberately omitted and ask yourself whether your impression would be the same if some words were not used. One method is to view the

Similar Documents

Design Argument Essay

1021 words - 5 pages Anthropic Principle. From this argument, he argues that the universe functions by rules e.g. each day has 24 hours and this is not by chance it has been designed to have 24 hours, and the most likely explanation is God. He argues that although science can explain a reason behind these laws occurring, it cannot confirm the presence of these laws and so God is the most logical explanation for this as he is above human power. Frederick R. Tennant

Evaluation Rubrics Essay

298 words - 2 pages The author gave an explanation of the definition of elaborative learning techniques. He stated a possible reason for the mixed results as “elaborative learning techniques tend to be ineffective as students discontinue using the strategy when unsupervised” (Sample Paper, 2013, pg.1). He clearly illustrated his argument that the elaborative study technique is bi-directional. However, the argument is somewhat less thorough. He provided a lot of

Sociology Essay

2204 words - 9 pages years, after which I chose to comply with the social fact of eating. Question 2The emerge of capitalism can be seen from different perspectives; according to Karl Marx history must be understood from beneath in the sense that human actions based on material conditions are the reason for consciousness and historical changes, whereas Max Weber half a century later criticised Marx' explanation, claiming history to be based on the human mind in which

Mis535 Homework Week 1 Essay

513 words - 3 pages organization. Instructor Explanation: p. 15 3. The three activities in an information system that produce the information that organizations use to control operations are input, processing, and output. Instructor Explanation: p. 16 4. The fundamental set of assumptions, values, and ways of doing things that has been accepted by most of a company's members is called its culture. Instructor