This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Homeschool Vs. Public Schools Essay

1550 words - 7 pages

James Phillips
English 101-006, Ms. Medlin
Rogerian Argument
Nov. 13, 2015

Home schools vs. Publix schools
Making sure safety and educational support for all home schooling students should be a top priority as the state works to help parents who want to still have an opportunity to home school their children. Over twenty thousand Carolinians students attend school at home in 2013 and according to Martin-Chang, Gould, and Meuse (2011), the national number of home school kids was close to two million children in 2010. She noted that while home schooling has become a “fashionable choice” for young urban professionals who want the best education for their children. The subject is ...view middle of the document...

In many cases, parents do have total control over the home schooling environment. South Carolina, for example, monitors home school kids by requiring children to take standardized tests in “grades three, five, eight, and 10” (Hovde, 2013). This requirement is the only major assessment. According to Joyce (2013), many states require even less from families who choose to home school. Twenty-six states do not require any testing, and eleven states do not ask for any kind of notification from home schooling parents. In these locations, parents becomes the law in place of any formal guidelines. In most cases such parental freedom benefits the children, but in others, as opponents note, the children lose out.
In her article “The Home school Apostates,” Joyce (2013) tells the stories of several former home school kids whose home school experiences were dangerous and harmful because of their parent’s lazy stance. One woman explained, “I was basically raised by someone with a mental disorder and told you have to obey her or God’s going to send you to hell . . . . Her anxiety disorder meant that she had to control every little thing, and home schooling and her religious beliefs gave her the justification for it” (as cited in Joyce, 2013). In this same example, the parent failed to take an interest in teaching their child, choosing to simply hand out school books and require their pre-teen to self-teach. Joyce argued that this type of situation is not unusual and cited websites such as Homeschoolers Anonymous and No Longer Quivering where hundreds of others have shared similar accounts of their home schooling experiences. These students are in situations that are dangerous to their emotional, intellectual, social, and sometimes physical health, but little is done to protect them.
Outcomes are not just limited to abusive situations. Sometimes home school students struggle to reach the same level as their peers despite their parents’ best intentions. According to Martin-Chang, Gould, and Meuse (2011), children whose parents chose “unstructured” home schooling do not learn as much or make as good of grades as their peers, falling behind students who were in structured home schooling and traditional schooling (p. 200). In the unstructured form of home schooling the learning process is entirely determined by the child. Where in “structured” forms, “the parents view themselves as important contributors to their children’s education (p. 197-198). Structured home schooling may still focus on a child’s individual needs and benefits, but the parents create lesson plans or otherwise guide the child’s learning (Concordia University, 2012). In a interview for Concordia University, Martin-Chang acknowledged that the results of the study might have been different if student success had been measured using a different tool. The results here were gathered from a standardized test with no connection to either the public school program or home school groups. Or if the...

Other assignments on Homeschool Vs. Public Schools

Southern Black Women Essay

616 words - 3 pages . Jim Crow laws were intact, schools were segregated. Public accommodations and voter’s registrations In the first few paragraphs discuss the scholarship on the civil rights movement. Paragraph one we are introduced to Irene Morgan and Barbara Johns both women talked about their experiences and how they led up to the freedom rides. We also are introduced to the Brown vs. Board of education, sought to end segregation in an institutional setting

School Uniforms Essay

2666 words - 11 pages The School Uniform Debate: Measuring Effectiveness Pete Cade Jr. May 2015 Abstract With the rising numbers of violence in schools coupled with a decline in academic achievement, many stakeholders have begun to condemn the state of public school education. The situation has prompted schools across the country to look for unorthodox approaches to improve schools and the performance of their students. The result has led to a spreading

Foreign Studies

1317 words - 6 pages language study on the part of first-year 3rd grade foreign language students who continue their foreign language study through and including the 5th grade in Louisiana public schools contributes to their academic achievement in subject areas tested on the Iowa Tests of Basic Skills and the LEAP 21. The findings indicate that the FL students statistically significantly outperformed their non-foreign language counterparts on every subtest of the

Sociology Essay Structure

3978 words - 16 pages statistics OR participant observation. • The research characteristics of potential research subjects, eg truants, schools, truancy officers, parents (power relations and attitudes to authority/school; language skills; low academic ability; class, ethnicity and gender; home conditions; schools’ public image/funding). • The research contexts and settings, eg government policies, out of school settings, welfare/control agencies. • The

Ethnic Studies 001 Notes

1801 words - 8 pages greater social gains -They were given public deference and open admission to social functions and public facilities, they received lenient treatment by police and judges, and they enjoyed the privileges of voting, and of sending their children to the best, most well funded schools. 2.) Whiteness as Property -Cheryl Harris argues that the legacy of slavery, Indian land seizure established and protected an actual property interest in whiteness

Authorithy Figures Bullies Or Buddies: Brutalit From Authority Figures To Immigrants An Annotated Biblography

1551 words - 7 pages answer session with the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). It first addresses the blocking of public schools, universities, and colleges to all immigrants in the state of Alabama. They then proceed to talk about the police punishing individuals for routine interactions with undocumented immigrants. They also talk about the problem with having police in Alabama work on the "Immigration problem" and dealing with racially biased police officers

Administrative Law

3410 words - 14 pages that have been shaping the public policy on which these substances stand on. These substances have an immediate and perilous effect on the health of all human beings. Tobacco is the leading cause of preventable death in the United States, alcohol causes impaired judgment and in turn causes people to do things that affect their health physically and emotionally, and marijuana has almost the same effect as alcohol. (New England Law) Health is the

Sick Leave

2608 words - 11 pages ofthe JETprogram can be traced backto 1982. In that year. the Japanese Ministry of Education (Monbusho) initiated a project known as the Monbusho English Feilorvs (NIEF) Prograrn, rvhich hired Americans to rvork at the iocal boards of education in order to assist Japanese English teaching consultants who acted as advisors to the Japanese teachers of English in the public schools. The task of the MEFs was to oversee the junior and senior high school

Bringing Western Culture To South Korea Via Nursing Home, Plastic Surgery, Clothing And Makeup

9631 words - 39 pages also allocates some of the highest percentages of public funds to assist in the innovation of new technologies (“Globalization,” n.d.). Five percent of South Korea’s gross domestic product contributes to the knowledge of science and technologies (“Viewing South Korea-The Role of Science and Technology,” n.d.). Though South Korea may have the fastest speeds, there are still privacy concerns with these technologies (OSAC, 2014). There are issues with

Right To Food

3983 words - 16 pages ‘hunger amidst plenty”. In this respect, India has violated right to food in its worst form. Various micro studies have documented about the prevalence of hunger and starvation deaths in many parts of the country. A public hearing on hunger and the right to food held in Manatu block of Palamau district of Jharkhand following starvation deaths reveals gross irregularities in food related programmes and a disastrous level of public services (Bhatia

Vulnerable Populations In The Workplace

1540 words - 7 pages disparities. Mexican-Americans: A Population at Risk Mexican-Americans, especially aging Mexican-Americans are an extremely vulnerable population. Currently, Hispanics are the fastest growing ethnic population in the United States and as of the 2003 U.S. Census, their population, “grew at a rate almost fourfold that of the general population—13% vs. 3.3%--over a 39 month period” (Keating, et al. 2009). That being said, non-English-speaking

Similar Documents

Homeschooling Essay

1451 words - 6 pages homeschool students scored above grade level, and 93 percent of the homeschool students were at or above grade level in reading (HSLDA 6). Children that are homeschooled make better on standardized tests rather than children at public schools. Children that are homeschooled are known to go into college with a better GPA than with public school GPA. Children who are being homeschooled have more one-on-one interactions, and fewer distractions, which

Adequacy Of Homeschooling Essay

1881 words - 8 pages School from Home: Connections Academy. Web. 10 Feb. 2012. . Spooner, Rebecca. "Why Do People Homeschool Their Children? |" Homeschooling @, 23 Apr. 2010. Web. 10 Feb. 2012. . "The Condition of Education - Contexts of Elementary and Secondary Education - Learning Opportunities - Student Teacher Ratios in Public Schools - Indicator 31 (2010)." National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) Home Page, a Part of the U.S. Department of Education. Institute of Education Sciences, 2010. Web. 16 Feb. 2012. .

Private Sector Study On Education Essay

2557 words - 11 pages post-secondary options. An important finding in Parthenon’s analysis shows that private sector post-secondary providers actually enroll a higher proportion of these higher-risk students. In 004, roughly 1/ of private sector students were identified as being “high risk” vs. only 1/3 of students in public and independent schools.3 This relationship holds true across nearly every measure of underrepresentation, as private sector schools have

Strategic Management Essay

2100 words - 9 pages . Revenue mechanism How to generate revenues? Revenue model (mechanisms?) Describes the way in which a business model enables revenue generation. (Zott/Amit) Value chain 2. 10 schools of thought The 3 groups of thought Premisses of the 10 schools 3. Industry environment Role of industry in investments Venture capitalists invest in good industries, and it’s a myth that they invest in good people and good ideas. The industries that are more