This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Gsis Vs. Court Of Appeal G.R. No. 101439

811 words - 4 pages

Graduate School of Business
Master of Business Administration

Business Law
Case 3
GSIS vs. Court of Appeals

Submitted by:
Liao, Weiqin
Facts of the case
• National Food Authority (NFA, formerly National Grains Authority) was the owner of a Chevrolet truck which was insured against liabilities for death of and injuries to third persons with the GSIS.

• On May 9, 1979, at about 7:00 in the evening at Tabon-Tabon, Butuan City, the said truck driven by Guillermo Corbeta collided with a public utility vehicle, a Toyota Tamaraw. The Toyota Tamaraw was owned and operated by Victor Uy, under the name and style of “Victory Line”. The Tamaraw was a total ...view middle of the document...

o GSIS Also elevated the decision in this civil case to the same appellate court.

Resolved by court
• First Case (Civil – Case No. 2196) June 5, 1979
o The RTC awarded Uy the total amount of P109,100.00 for damages
• Second Case (Civil – Case No. 2225) August 27, 1979
o RTC dismissed the case against UY and orered MIGC
o Corbeta and NFA to pay plaintiff Tear (Private Passenger), jointly and severally, the amount of P40,559.94 for actual, compensatory, and moral damages plus attorney’s fees.
• Third case (Civil – Case no. 2256) November 26, 1979
o Damages likewise award to the herein private respondents.
o Corbeta, NFA and MIGC are solidarity liable for damages.
Injured Victims
Victoria Jainme Vda. De Kho
Transportation and and Telegraph Expense P 2,372.30
Other Compensatory/Moral Damages P10,000.00
Loss of Income P12,000.00
Total P33,307.36
Gloria Kho Vda. De Calabia
Other Compensatory/Moral Damages P10,000.00
Total P10,000.00
Heirs of Deceased Victims
Funeral Death Mora Total
Expenses Indemnity Damages

Heirs of Willie P 2,500.00 P18,000.00 P10,000.00 P30,500.00
Calabia , Sr.

Heirs of P 2,500.00 P18,000.00 P10,000.00 P30,500.00
Roland Kho

Heirs of Maxima P 2,500.00 P18,000.00 P10,000.00 P30,500.00
Ugmad Vda.
De Kho

o GSIS direct liable to the private respondents base con...

Other assignments on Gsis Vs. Court Of Appeal G.R. No. 101439

Court Visit Report

828 words - 4 pages Privy Council are requisite; those of the United Kindgom and Commonwealth are highly persuasive. The structure of the legal system in Trinidad and Tobago is as follows; Magistrate Court, High Court, Court of Appeal, House of Lords/ Privy Council. The Magistrates’ court is a lower court handling both civil and criminal matters. Some civil matters are decided here but all criminal proceedings begin in a Magistrates’ court and most will end

Management Essay

374 words - 2 pages Week 1: Assignment 1. This story is about the Supreme Court’s decision. What process did this case have to go through to get to the Supreme Court? a. The Supreme Court concluded that there was no fixed policy that described some kind of discrimination against woman. The judge also pointed out that the plaintiff did not have a strong proof or standing of what they proposed to be employee discrimination. 2. In the story, two

Thinking And Decision Making

1623 words - 7 pages Thinking and Decision Making Adults face opportunities to make decisions constantly. Each day, people decide how best to solve issues, plan for the future, make ethical decisions, and more. Some decisions require little to no extra thinking, with minimal consequences or benefits; whereas other decisions require much more time due to the magnitude of the decision, and its potential impact on the wellbeing of self or others. Important decisions

Gujarat Bottling Company Vs Coca Cola Company

1271 words - 6 pages , restrained GBCL from the manufacture and sale of any other products during the period of its agreement with Coca Cola. Because of this order and the action taken by Coca Cola to stop the supply of material to GBCL, the franchisee’s plant was rendered idle. GBCL went on, to appeal to the Supreme Court. No separate Act for franchising exists in India, and as in many other countries, the Contract Act is normally applicable to all disputes arising between


9859 words - 40 pages finding of the trial court, there was no occasion at all for appellant Gaddao to flee from the policemen to justify her arrest in “hot pursuit.” In fact, she was going about her daily chores when the policemen pounced on her. Neither could the arrest of appellant Gaddao be justified under the second instance of Rule 113. “Personal knowledge” of facts in arrests without warrant under Section 5 (b) of Rule 113 must be based upon “probable cause

Business Law

931 words - 4 pages passing to statutory status. 6.3 European Commission: A: They have no power in making laws, only propose ideas in law creation. But council and Parliament may proceed with other ideas. The European Commission have the power to take parties to court, where EU laws have been broken. So they make sure parties, Businesses and individuals follow the EU Laws that are put in place. 6.4 Court of Justice: A: This is the court of justice, consisting of

Administrative Law

3410 words - 14 pages tobacco and cigars to adult customers.” (Tobacco Free Kids, Lorillard v. Reilly, 533 U.S. 525 (2001) The court believed, among many other things, the state Did not target the advertising ban to those types of ads or characteristics of ads that studies have found to appeal to youth most, which is why it was to broad. (Tobacco Free Kids) . The U.S. Supreme Court applied the Central Hudson Test to the case in order to determine whether

Lok Adalat

2345 words - 10 pages was observed that the award is enforceable as a decree and it is final. The endeavor is only to see that the disputes are narrowed down and make the final settlement so that the parties are not again driven to further litigation or any dispute. The scheme also helps the overburdened Courts to alleviate the burden of arrears of cases and as the award becomes final and binding on both the parties, no appeal is filed in the Appellate Court and

Business Law Assignment

407 words - 2 pages Even though the Central London Property Trust v High Trees Pty case suggests that past consideration can be valid given the circumstances, there are many other cases after the High Tree case shows the concept of past consideration is not good consideration still an indicator of judgment in court. In the Re McArdle court of appeal case in 1951, Majorie McArdle carried out some repairs and improvements on a bungalow, such property was part of the

Juvenile Crime

1123 words - 5 pages changing crimes, the juvenile system is always hard at work, facing the new challenges and seeking improvements. Juveniles that commit crimes are no longer considered criminals, but instead juvenile delinquents. If the child is of a certain age in some states, or the crime is a violent felony, such as rape, or murder, the child can be treated as an adult, making him or her criminal and trialed as an adult in a criminal court of law. The juvenile

Business Law

292 words - 2 pages will receive a higher salary and profit-sharing bonus after the departure of Dr. Qaas. This kind of contract would be classified as an implied-in-law contract (quasi-contract). Dr. Winkel performed his services and duties to Dr. Vranish for a year even though no contract existed. Therefore, the court would entitle Dr. Winkel the profit-sharing bonus. Pertaining to the second question, Dr. Vranich protest of the altered oral modification of

Similar Documents

Busi Law Day 1 Essay

767 words - 4 pages – specific matter such as divorce * General any kind of case * Original – first hearing of case** - is possible for it to be supreme court (bush vs Gore) * Appellate jurisdiction – does not have original jurisdiction * Concurrent - both federal and state have ability to hear court – when more than one can * Standing to sue – must have a stake in the game basically to be able to sue, cant sue if friend get in a wreck for

Do Police Need A Warrant To Search Property

1648 words - 7 pages leave the premises voluntarily. A warrant was entirely feasible in this case, and no reason to contract the Fourth Amendment’s dominion. Therefore the Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the California Court of Appeal. I do not agree with the Supreme Court’s decision to reverse the judgement of the California Court of Appeal, as there was obvious domestic altercations in the home when Rojas’s had a large bump on her nose and blood on her

Biography Of Marshall Rothstein Essay

326 words - 2 pages . Also, he lectured in transportation and contract law at the University of Manitoba Faculty of Law for over 20 years. He was soon appointed to the Federal Court of Canada. He was elevated to the Federal Court of Appeal on January 21, 1999, and, finally, to the Supreme Court of Canada on March 1, 2006. Three qualities I believe are necessary in a Supreme Court Justice: 1. Must be fair- A Supreme Court Justice must be fair and have no

Crime Essay

2538 words - 11 pages court made, and the first decision is left unchanged. There are eleven judicial circuits in the United States, with one court of appeal in each circuit. There is also a court of appeal for Washington, D.C. and for the Federal Circuit, which means there’s thirteen United States Courts of Appeal in all. The highest court in the country is the United States Supreme Court. Appeals from the circuit courts are taken to the Supreme Court, and