This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Frederick Taylor’s ‘Scientific Management’ Was For A Different Time And A Different Place

2625 words - 11 pages

Frederick Taylor’s ‘Scientific Management’
Was for a Different Time and a different Place

“The principal object of management should be to secure the maximum prosperity for the employer, coupled with the maximum prosperity for each employee.”
-Frederick Winslow Taylor

Scientific Management was introduced by Frederick Taylor in the late 19th century. In this essay, I will address the question whether Scientific Management was for a different time and a different place. In this essay, I will analyze Taylor’s Scientific Management from different angles and base my argument on both sides. I will discuss that Scientific Management was introduced for manual labor industry, ...view middle of the document...

According to Drucker Taylor ideas made management bureaucratic. Taylor’s principles made managers to centralize power, separate planning from performing and specialize tasks. His study created a standardized method of how work should be completed and everyone had to work up to that standard; forgetting that workers are human beings making them to work as a functional, repetitive, effective and unquestioning machine. Own initiative, choice and decisions were eliminated; according to Ritzer Scientific Management is as a method used by managers to gain control over employees, a procedure that “produced nonhuman technology that exerted great control over workers” (Ritzer, 2010: 34). This does not apply today. In today’s business world employees are encouraged to use their best endeavors, their skills, their good will and initiative to earn the highest return possible for their employers. Taylor’s philosophy of "production first, people second" allowed measurable benefits to overshadow social benefits completely (Mintzberg, 1989: 333). Looking at it from this perspective Taylor’s Scientific Management was for a different time and has no place in today’s business world.

From the other side, some take the view that Taylor created a beginning, a start for something new, for something better. He was the first to lay down the principles of Scientific Management and view management as a discipline. He created a rigid system, but more a model which can be adapted to suit future business world. According to Drucker a new version of Scientific Management was needed to fit for “knowledge workers and technologists” of today’s business (Drucker, 1999). He sought to improve industrial efficiency and when he found out the answer to his question he explained how he did so. He tells us the method how he achieves efficiency and let us to decide whether we follow it or not. Efficiency is the principle of all the business objectives; where managers and workers perform their tasks in perfect harmony, output and profit is at maximum and costs are kept at minimum. This perfect equilibrium is what Taylor always wanted to achieve.

Taylor, eventually achieved what he wanted, he contributed to a revolution of the industrial workplace. The average industry in the early 1900 was inefficient with managers asking for a better way and a better system. Before Taylor, all economies were underdeveloped. An underdeveloped economy today is one that has not yet tried to make manual worker more productive. After studying and learning the science of work and how to make a more effective way of doing things, the productivity began to rise. Since then, it has been growing steadily at the rate of 3 % per annum compound. However, the opportunity of making the step to raise the productivity of the worker depends on the ability of the “developed countries-and of every industry in it, of every company in it, of every institution in it” (Drucker, 1999). The countries that emerged as...

Other assignments on Frederick Taylor’S ‘Scientific Management’ Was For A Different Time And A Different Place

P6 Compare The Challenges To Selected Business Activities Within A Selected Organisation, In Two Different Economic Environments

791 words - 4 pages , paying particular attention to any human resources management (HRM) issues that may arise under each heading. Overall, it is argued here that Nike has attempted to address various business and social challenges by harmonising its value proposition to ‘Consumers, shareholders, business partners, employees, and the community.’ There are many external environmental factors that can affect your business. It is common for managers to assess each of these

A Time In Paris Essay

997 words - 4 pages a result of BK’s variety of menu. Whoppers and Burgers both are of different sizes and hence the mating before assembly process. McDonald’s menu “Less product more often”offers standardized burgers. This cost of complexity is a huge cost driver for BK.The “dressing process” of McDonald’s is standardized with lever based dispensers and portion controlledcondiments. In BK, dressing is done by humans using plastic squeezed bottles without pre

A 25 Year Old Individual Is Working Full Time As A Volunteer In A Charity Organization. His Daily Job Is To Distribute Leaflets Door To Door And Take Part In Charity Events. He Is Now Preparing For A...

1915 words - 8 pages ). A 25 year old individual is working full time as a volunteer in a charity organization. His daily job is to distribute leaflets door to door and take part in charity events. He is now preparing for a marathon run organized by his charity foundation which will be held in 6 months’ time. (2.1) Explain how his body responds to his physical activities (particularly in relation to musculo-skeletal system, cardiovascular system and respiratory

Different Economic Integration And How Each Affect International Trade

2503 words - 11 pages ), it’s economic, social, and political importance has been on the rise in recent centuries. It is the presupposition of international trade that a sufficient level of geopolitical peace and stability are prevailing in order to allow for the peaceful exchange of trade and commerce to take place between nations. Economic integration is the unification of economic policies between different states through the partial or full abolition of tariff and

Review Of A Time To Kill

676 words - 3 pages Search Type in your essay topic: ex. Vietnam War JOIN LOGIN CUSTOM ESSAYS HELP CONTACT A time to kill Essay Below is a free essay on "A time to kill" from Anti Essays, your source for free research papers, essays, and term paper examples. “JUSTICE CAN BE COLOR BLIND” “A Time to Kill” takes place in a small Mississippi town, where two white Men kidnap, rape, and nearly beat to death a young black girl. The men are caught, but the

Meaning Of Alcohol In Five Different Societies: Native Americans, Maori, Chinese, French And Russian

3356 words - 14 pages conversation. (ibid). In the 2000s average daily consumption of alcohol was the same for Maori and non-Maori, however, still articles with discussion on high drunkenness among Maori were not found. As was investigated by studies of Brady (2000) Maori had a relative temperance to alcohol. It would be advisable now to compare meanings of alcohol among societies in countries with different level of development in contemporary time. In general, adults

A Rose For Emily

788 words - 4 pages in a yellow glove. (p.31) She planned to marry Homer Barron, who represented change. He represented the North as he was a commoner and a day laborer, but he disappears before a marriage takes place. He is well-named "Barron" because for they have no children. Emily dies barren of children. Again, love and family escape her. He returns and Emily does not let him leave again. She goes to a pharmacist to buy rat poison to kill the rat who

A Rose For Emily

940 words - 4 pages man-servant a combined gardener and cook--had seen in at least ten years.” From there, the house, her servant, and the bad smell are used to symbolize her secluded life. Miss Emily’s inherited her house, but nothing else according to the narrator, “When her father died, it got about that the house was all that was left to her; and in a way, people were glad.” She lived alone for many years, except for her servant. People moved out of the

A Rose For Emily

1758 words - 8 pages successfully able to keep his daughter by his side and nobody could disturb their close relationship. Even though a life was lost, the town was glad for Miss Emily when her father passed away. The reason they were glad was because they could finally pity her and “she had become humanized” like the rest of the town (Faulkner 439). She now has to deal with being alone and “would now know the thrill and the old despair of a penny more or less

A Rose For Emily - 407 words

407 words - 2 pages after that night and that was the last time he would be seen alive. Another event of foreshadowing is when a smell begins to come from Miss Emily’s house. The smell is so awful that people sneak into her yard at night to apply lime to try to get the smell to go away. The story states "a short time after her sweetheart--the one we believed would marry her--had deserted her".(Faulkner 28) This gives the impression that Miss Emily has become

Gifted For A Mission

557 words - 3 pages through tough times and help her family. I use my own skill and talents as a good student, sister and friend to strive to be successful in life and take care of those I care about. Executing my talents wisely has enabled me to achieve balance between academics, extracurricular activities and my part time job as a hostess. As I like to be the very best I can possibly be and receive recognition for my hard work, I was disappointed to learn that I did

Similar Documents

A Different Shot Essay

997 words - 4 pages lucky the photographer was to capture such a happy moment. This young girl now has the rest of her life to live, and the photographer was lucky enough to capture the moment she was saved. By simply changing two lines, an entirely different point of view can be unearthed. Photographers are said to be selfish and heartless for taking photos of tragic events. But if you take the time to look, you may find that they are actually just doing what they love. They don’t risk their lives such as firemen, but they capture moments that can produce such powerful emotions that I never knew existed. Such as the happiness from a miracle in Creve Coeur instead of a tragedy.

A Different History Essay

856 words - 4 pages fighting for. However, it could make herself seem like a victim of their colonization. It makes the reader feel more sympathy for her and could even make the reader agree with her argument on a higher level. It shows how powerful the colonization was that it even made someone who hated all the after-effects of their rule speak in English. It makes the reader see how much of their culture was indeed lost.

A Comparative Study Of The Elastic Limit Of Two Different Brands Of Rubber Bands

2712 words - 11 pages . Therefore, it is also a frequently used temporary stopper or to restrict the flow of fluids in plumbing. There are many different types of rubber bands; industrial rubber bands, dentist elastics, household rubber bands and many more. For this experiment the researcher will be using household rubber bands. The researcher aims to determine which of two brands of household rubber band has the longest elastic limit. This topic was chosen by the

Frank And Lillian Gilbreth Scientific Management Studies

496 words - 2 pages large amounts of time a surgeon would use wasting to switch and retrieve surgical instruments during surgery procedure. In response to the problem, the Gilbreths implemented the use of nurses to aid surgeons during surgery. The Gilbreths improved productivity tremendously. Today, this practice is still used in healthcare to its utmost efficiency. This study is surely a practice of scientific management, and time and motion. It provides efficient