This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

False Claims Acts: Should They Be Sealed?

2087 words - 9 pages

Running head: FALSE CLAIMS ACTS: 1

False Claims Acts: Should they be sealed?
Becky L. Garcia


Throughout history the United States Government has been responsible for massive expenditures for government operations involving taxpayer dollars. Unfortunately, with all the different organizations and transactions transpiring, there have become endless opportunities for fraud or deceptive practices. The government enacted the False Claims Act for help in controlling the deceptive practices and additionally giving them a viable tool to expose the fraudulent acts. The False Claims Act allows a whistleblower or “qui tam” to come forward and ...view middle of the document...

One action within the FCA that has been a large discussion topic and even challenged, is the sealing of the claims. The decision, reasoning, and rationale for the sealing of the claims are very important for the whistleblower and should not be considered unconstitutional but rather a constitutional right of protection and anonymity.
1) What is the False Claims Act?
The government was having many problems as far back as the Civil War with fraud and abuse by companies or government contractors selling supplies to the Union Army. Many millions of dollars were being swindled out of the government from supplies: like moth-eaten blankets, unhealthy horses, or boxes of sawdust that were supposed to be guns. The government needed help with all the fraud taken place with these government purchases. The help came by way of Congress enacting and passing into law in 1863, with President Abraham Lincoln being a strong supporter, the False Claims Act (FCA). FCA was also referred to or known as the “Lincoln Law,” since Lincoln was President at the time.
The FCA included the important provision of “qui tam,” which “allowed private citizens to sue, on the government’s behalf, companies and individuals that were defrauding the government” (“History of,” 2007). The Latin phrase of “qui tam” is the first two words in a long Latin phrase that is interpreted as “Who sues on behalf of the King as well as for himself” (Qui Tam, 2012). This act was very important and vital in allowing the private citizen to help with the federal officials in combating the fraud.
The penalties assessed when FCA was first enacted, entailed the individuals that committed the fraud to pay twice the damages and also a $2,000 fine was imposed for every false claim. The reward the citizens got for turning a case or claim in was fifty percent of the damages recovered by the government.
The FCA primarily continued through the years with minor changes until 1943, and the Congress made provisions. The provisions started with changing the fifty percent received by the private citizen or whistleblower, thus reducing the claims reported. Additionally, a change was made with the FCA stating that if the government already had information or evidence of the fraud, it would prohibit a qui tam lawsuit. With just these changes or amendments to the FCA, the claims almost ceased to exist.
The FCA was not looked at again until over forty years later, when in the 1980’s more rampant rumors or reports of fraud from contractors against the government. Much of the reports were during the Cold War and the defense spending. Numerous reports were made that the government was paying outrageous amounts for equipment or services, like over $400 for a hammer. These reports were cause for investigations, and leading the government to revise the FCA, again encouraging whistle blowers to come forward and help the government combat the fraud. The FCA was reformed in 1986 allowing the whistle blower to...

Other assignments on False Claims Acts: Should They Be Sealed?

Case 2 Essay

1552 words - 7 pages should not be, and are not, on trial on this case. While leaving the Winona Clinic on August 16, 1982 the plaintiff (who was on crutches at the time due to an earlier fall) was grabbed from behind by two or more security men, forced into a waiting van and driven to the Tau Center in Winona, MN. Forcibly resisting, he was varied by four men to a room on the top floor of the dormitory-style building. The windows of this room were boarded over with

Immanuel Kant Essay

872 words - 4 pages immorality. I feel that they could be perceived as selfish acts, but I also feel that people have the right to live their lives the way they want to. Resources

Lab #3: Case Study On Pci Dss Non-Compliance: Cardsystems Solutions

559 words - 3 pages 1. Did CardSystems Solutions break any federal or state laws? Yes they did because they did follw the compliance of the pci dss. 2. CardSystems Solutions claims to have hired an auditor to assess compliance with PCI DSS and other best practices for ensuring the C-I-A of privacy data for credit card transaction processing. Assuming the auditor did indeed perform a PCI DSS security compliance assessment, what is your assessment of the


1168 words - 5 pages auctions is due to the auction designs and the sequence in which they took place. Revenues depend on how well the auction design is able to attract entry and prevent collusion. Also, it has to be able to adapt to new environments. For example, a good auction design takes into account the information bidders have and the knowledge they have gained from previous auctions. A sensible reserve price is of high importance as well and should not be

Health Tips

260 words - 2 pages (or a toaster oven) for about 5 to 10 minutes (watch them closely to make sure they don't burn). Enjoy them whole as a scrumptious snack, or chop them up and sprinkle them into oatmeal or low-fat yogurt. Carrots Like sweet potatoes, carrots come equipped with a generous supply of beta-carotene. In addition to its pivotal role in skin-cell renewal, beta-carotene acts as a potent antioxidant, sopping up damaging free radicals that accelerate

Marketing Management

1579 words - 7 pages Ethical marketing standards for business are important, particularly in the age of the Internet where information is accessible to anyone and may remain online indefinitely. False advertising is a familiar issue, and most business people are aware of the risk of exaggerated product claims, but the main implication is that because of the advertising “watchdogs”, companies indulging in this practice may be caught and punished. Other issues with


1178 words - 5 pages matter (plant or animal). Cockroaches are attracted to warm, moist environments. They spend the daylight hours in dark, secluded sites under refrigerators, stoves, false bottoms in kitchen cabinets, in the backs of cabinets and in crevices between baseboards and floors or cabinets and walls. They may also be found behind pictures or within electronic equipment. A number of these openings will ultimately lead to voids in the stud walls. The

Supply Chain Management

3586 words - 15 pages . It can also arise due to the suspension by the supplier and delay caused by purchaser. When these claims are raised, it must be properly recorded and all supporting documents attached for assessment and evaluated for validity before the claims are honored. When disputes arise, the alternative dispute resolution procedures should be followed so that both parties will have a fair hearing. TOTAL WORD COUNT 2,046 MEMORANDUM To

Juvenile Crime

1123 words - 5 pages offender is treated different than an adult offender. The juvenile court system’s main concerns are for the safety, privacy and rehabilitation of the minor offender. The most signifying differences as stated by Attorney LaMance, Ken, “Juveniles are not prosecuted for committing crimes, but rather delinquent acts.  When the delinquent acts are very serious, they may be considered crimes and the juvenile may be tried in the adult system. Juveniles don't


626 words - 3 pages unconditionally Skepticism= doubting, suspending our judgment Reasoning based on acts not emotional claims Black and white terms- false dichotomy Taking apart things and looking at how they are constructed Ask the questions HOW- how does this argument work? How is the topic argued? How is the evidence used and interpreted? How does the author reach his/her conclusions? Reading critically Is the question at issue well stated? Is it clear

Davis V. The Board Of County Commissioners Of Doña Ana County

808 words - 4 pages and of exchanging favors for sex acts. Herrera’s supervisor, Frank Steele, investigated the charges and advised Herrera that he would be reprimanded. Herrera resigned to avoid disciplinary action. Six days later, Steele wrote a recommendation letter on Herrera’s behalf that portrayed him as an “excellent employee” and told prospective employers: “I am confident that you would find [Herrera] to be an excellent employee.” (Walsh, 2010, p.149

Similar Documents

Sealed Air Essay

592 words - 3 pages American market for this product. Europe and America are essentially two different market segments with significantly different priorities in what they look for in protective packaging. Since the European market is extremely price-sensitive, the uncoated product will likely be more effective in gaining market share than the higher quality, more expensive coated product. Sealed Air should utilize its already superior production and distribution

The Influence Of Law In Business

936 words - 4 pages interference in the business world. A big part of the FTC Act is monitoring false claims made by businesses, such as claiming “made in the U.S.A.” when that isn’t true. The Federal Trade Commission sets a standard for what would qualify a product to be marketed under the pretense that it is made in the U.S.A., which would make purchasing the product more likely based on such a claim. The Federal Trade Commission is also responsible for

The Importance Of Deductive Reasoning Essay

654 words - 3 pages of the important information needed in making the decision in which schooling is right for their children, however they do leave out one way of schooling and that is home schooling. This is very much an option for schooling children and more information on this option should be presented or made aware to the one deciding. The final argument addresses that Jenna is struggling in her class, but does not state how badly. Struggling could be to some

Special Attraction Of International Trade As A Market Entry Mode

826 words - 4 pages 13. When people in the world see your good work, who do they give glory to? ANS. God 14. The widow of Zarephath `s story can be found where in the Bible? ANS. 1Kings 17:7-16 15. Quote 2 Corinthians 9:7. ANS. “each man should give what he has decided in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver” 16. Who said this and to whom “ Go at once to Zarephath of Sidon and stay there” ANS. God to