Eye Witness Testimony Can It Be Trusted?

625 words - 3 pages

“The testimony of an eyewitness is so flawed that it can never be trusted”
To what extent is eyewitness testimony as flawed as the quote suggests?
The eyewitness testimony can be inaccurate and distorted:
Eyewitness testimony (EWT) is the evidence provided by people who witnesses a particular event or crime. It relies on recall from memory.
EWT includes, for example, descriptions or criminals (e.g. hair colour, height) and crime scenes (e.g. time, date, location).
Witnesses are often inaccurate in their recollection of events and the people involved. As you can probably imagine, this has important implications when it comes to police interviews.
Many cognitive psychologists focus on working out what factors affect the accuracy of eyewitness testimony, and how accuracy can be improved in interviews.
Loftus and palmer (1974) studied eyewitness testimony and investigated how EWT can be distorted. Loftus and Zanni (1975) also looked at ...view middle of the document...

Anxiety can also affect focus. Psychologists tend to believe that small increases in anxiety and arousal may increase the accuracy of memory, but high levels have a negative effect on accuracy. In violent crimes (where anxiety and arousal are likely to be high), the witness may focus on central details (e.g. a weapon) and neglect other peripheral details.
Loftus (1979) studied weapon focus in EWT. This is when the witness gets anxious and aroused, witnesses focus on a weapon at the expense of the other details, i.e. the criminals face.
The cognitive interview.
The cognitive interview was developed to increase accuracy. Cognitive psychologists have played a big part in helping to increase the accuracy of eyewitness testimony. As you’ve seen, research shows that the accuracy of eyewitness testimony is affected by many factors. The cognitive interview technique was developed by Geiselman et al (1984) to try to increase the accuracy of witnesses’ recall of events during police questioning.
Here’s basically what happens in cognitive interviews:
The interviewer tries to make the witness relaxed and tailors his/her language to suit the witness.
The witness recreates the environmental and internal (e.g. mood) context of the crime scene.
The witness reports absolutely everything that they can remember about the crime.
The witness is asked to recall details of the crime in different orders.
The witness is asked to recall the event from various different perspectives, e.g. from the eyes of other witnesses.
The interviewer avoids any judgemental and personal comments.
Conclusion: So yes the eyewitness testimony does have its flaws as I have explained and shown but I believe it is a good way of getting information from witnesses about crimes. Without the eyewitness testimony it would be based on the police’s judgement which is risky because they could look down on how the suspect looks and so on. So I disagree with the quote shown at the top, the eyewitness testimony definitely has its flaws but until something better comes along its all we have to identify crimes and to find out what happened.

Other assignments on Eye Witness Testimony Can It Be Trusted?


3222 words - 13 pages descending order of probability and acceptance.” Markan Priority “Surveys of the Gospels or of the life of Christ and the major commentaries on each of the Synoptics along with studies more focused on individual themes or passages within those Gospels, all presuppose that Matthew and Luke each used Mark.” There are at least nine reasons for this statement. “(1) Mark had some evidence that was the product of “eye witness testimony, that

Media Violence Essay

379 words - 2 pages influenced by the media. The American Academy of Pediatrics, Testimony before the U.S. Commerce Committee: “Before age 8, children cannot discriminate between real life and fantasy. Onscreen violence is as real to them as violence that they witness at home or in their community. From childhood’s magical thinking and impulsive behavior, adolescents must develop abstract thought and social controls to prepare them to deal with adult realities. If this

Courtroom Participants

3832 words - 16 pages witnesses are persons who know the defendant or victim and testify about his or hers good character. Defendants, who have rights to not incriminate themselves, may choose to testify as a witness during their trial. Witness testimony is very crucial during criminal proceedings and can backfire for either counsel. For example, if the defense’s character witness is found not to be credible during cross examination, the credibility of the entire

Fraud Paper

1711 words - 7 pages becoming a witness for the prosecution. If you suspect or become aware that a criminal referral is pending you should know the course of a criminal case is much different than a civil matter. If during your investigation you uncover what you suspect to be criminal activity, such as a fraud or embezzlement scheme, inform your client/counsel immediately. It is engaging counsel or your client’s council’s decision as to whether or not to refer your

The States Siide

576 words - 3 pages development and marketing for Internet Explorer; so in the end it may not have been free at all. (Wikipedia.org) During questioning, guilty was the only characteristic of Microsoft. When Chairman Bill Gates was giving his testimony he was vague and nonresponsive claiming he did not recall any of the answers to what he was asked. A witness whom worked for Intel recalled Senior Vice President of Microsoft as having stated the intention to

Narcotics And Criminal Justice

1556 words - 7 pages molecular weight (N. Coffey). The compounds are then compared to statically data base to determine what compound it is most likely to be. The evidence from the preliminary testing and then the lab testing can be presented in court when officers and then specialist from the labs are called to testify before a judge or jury during a proceeding. Arthur McBay, Ph.D. states the following, “The Federal Rules of Evidence (Moore 1994a) that apply to


918 words - 4 pages of Ariel. PLACE: P&G already have many distributors in urban areas so that Ariel need tobe available both in urban and rural areas. * IN-STORE PLACEMENT STRATEGY: Putting products at the proper eye level will help to improve sales. But it is important to remember whose eye level you are trying to reach. In case of Ariel& G makes a strategy that their product in big stores is placed in female’s eye level so that they can easily see the

Evaluate And Explain The Limitations Of A Range Of Sources Of Information Both Primary And Secondary, For Small Scale Public Services Projects

1491 words - 6 pages Evaluate and explain the limitations of a range of sources of information both primary and secondary, for small scale public services projects. The source's used in the collection of data for a research project or investigation are of vital importance. Characterised as primary and secondary, a good range will provide more information needed to aid decision making. However it is important to note that it can some time's be difficult to

Caera Red Yeye Effect: Why?

263 words - 2 pages Although it looks magical and somewhat sinister, there’s a reasonable scientific explanation for it. So what causes your blue (or brown or hazel) eyes to turn red in certain photographs? The red-eye effect happens when flash pictures are taken in low-light situations. When the flash is located close to the camera lens (as it is in most cameras), you may be looking almost directly at the flash when you look at the camera lens. The red-eye


315 words - 2 pages Notes for Lab Report: Cow Eye -This is a full lab report and it must be typed -You must come up with an Aim (there is no hypothesis for this lab) -You must list the materials using the lab handout as a guide but remembering to accurately list any substitutes that have been made by the teacher -You must write your own procedure based on the informal one provided in the hand-out -REMEMBER: do not use “I” or “you” in a formal lab

Human Tears

1002 words - 5 pages has been documented in apes, elephants and even camels, it seems that only humans produce emotional tears, and it is only in humans that crying behaviours persist into adulthood. The challenge is to explain why this should be so, given that tears also run the risk of signalling our presence to predators. Vingerhoets's explanation is novel: although in certain situations weeping can be risky, he suggests it is far less risky than screaming or

Similar Documents

Multi Store Model Of Memory Essay

1700 words - 7 pages ) found that patients with damage to their frontal lobe had problems concentrating suggesting damage to the central executive (researcher biased) | Outline and evaluate the cognitive interview (12)Outline and evaluate how a cognitive interview can be used to improve the accuracy of eyewitness testimony (EWT). (12) | Findings concerning the unreliability of eye-witness accounts have led researchers to attempt to devise methods for improving retrieval

Psychology Essay

645 words - 3 pages caused him more distress as he watched himself after the study was taken. Eye witness testimony Leading questions Is a question phrased in a way that will biased your response. Loftus She had 45 student watch a video of a car crash. She then asked them questions of their eye witness testimony. And then asked them questions like How far was the cars going when they --------- into eachother. Answers: Hit Collided Smashed- fastest

If Gardner’s And Sternberg’s Theories Of Multiple Intelligences Are Correct, What Are The Implications For Intelligence Testing And For Education?

784 words - 4 pages and retrieval of the information. As a juror I may say to other jurors that eye witness testimony may be unreliable because there may be memory errors which may lead to wrongful judgments of guilt or innocence and even life-or-death decisions. So the testimony of the eye witness must be examined and weighed carefully. I would explain that researchers have demonstrated that it is relatively easy to create false memories. During problem

Lab 1 Week1 Essay

898 words - 4 pages people behind bars. 3. What is hearsay and provide an example when Computer evidence can be considered hearsay? “Hearsay” refers to statements made outside of court of law an example of Computer evidence that is considered hearsay is 4. What is system integrity? System integrity is the state of a system where it is performing its intended functions without being degraded or impaired by changes or disruptions in its internal or external