This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Evaluate A Utilitarian Approach To Abortion

1333 words - 6 pages

Abortion, the deliberate termination of a pregnancy, has been the subject of discussion and controversy for many decades. Utilitarianism is the chief teleological ethical theory today which considers the consequences of an action; such as abortion. This ethical approach to abortion is useful because it determines that “an action is right if it produces the greatest good for the greatest number”. It considers the hedonic calculus, designed by Bentham, which weighs up the pleasure and pain generated by the available moral actions; the theory mainly focuses on both pleasure and pain and the ability to maximize pleasure over pain. It also emphasises the ends of abortion over its means; so it ...view middle of the document...

However, act utilitarianism, is considered a flawed theory because it can be seen as a tool to justify potentially evil actions purely because it fulfils the principle of bringing the greatest good to the greatest number. In relation to abortion, this could happen if a foetus is aborted simply because the family do not see a child as fitting with their current lifestyle, which some people would argue is an immoral choice, but it is justified by the theory; this illustrates that the theory doesn’t protect the interests of the minority.
In his utilitarian approach to abortion, Bentham would use the hedonic calculus which he designed to weigh up the pain and pleasure generated by the available moral actions to find the best option. It is potentially essential in relation to abortion because it determines whether it is intrinsically right or wrong, based on seven factors. Firstly the intensity of the pleasure, for example hearing your child’s first word. Secondly, the duration of the pleasure caused, might refer to the lifelong highs or lows from your child. An abortion demonstrates the certainty/uncertainty of the act because the mother may experience guilt and sorrow without the child or may experience freedom from not having the child. The remoteness/propinquity of the pleasure relates to whether the relief is immediate or a long way away. The richness of the pleasure may refer to the birth of a baby, which will bring happiness to many. The purity of the pleasure means whether the action will bring more or less harm, for example, by having a child at a young age could jeopardise an education or a career. Finally, the extent of the pleasure amounts to the number of people affected by it, such as the effect a newborn can have on a whole family. This method is effective in decision making because the calculations can be made over a longer period of time. However, having an abortion because of financial pressures, other family members' needs, education, work, may be justified by the calculus. Bentham concluded that the action that produces the best consequences is the morally correct option to follow. Although the hedonic calculus seems to have been purpose built for abortion, the negatives of the quantative method outweigh the positives by far.
Mill developed Bentham’s theory by emphasising that it is not the quantity of pleasure, but the quality of happiness that is central to utilitarianism and the issue of abortion. He argued that Bentham’s hedonic calculus is unreasonable because qualities cannot be quantified. Mill believed that there is a distinction between 'higher' and 'lower' pleasures. He accepted the idea of a woman giving birth because the outcome of that would be a child so it would be a higher pleasure for the parents and as a consequence the child would cause much pleasure for the parents, whose individual liberty to choose to have a child is maintained. As a rule utilitarian, Mill was concerned with which certain actions have...

Other assignments on Evaluate A Utilitarian Approach To Abortion

Pro Choice Or Pro Life Essay

2633 words - 11 pages whether or not abortion should be allowed or not. I believe in Pro Choice which believes that woman should have the right to decide if she wants to abort a baby or not. In this paper, I will look at abortions critically and express why abortion should be legal and be left us to a woman to decide. The goal is to point out reason why one might choose abortion. While one is Pro-Choice in the case of abortion, and feels that is should be legal and the

Preventing Aboriton Essay

1557 words - 7 pages There are many issues in America today such as violence, drugs, teenage pregnancy that is on a rise. There is also abortion which is what I chose to write about today due to the fact that it has been such a controversial and important issue of my generation although it has been an ongoing issue for centuries going back to 2600 B.C when the first recipe for an abortion producing drug. Since the 19th century English common law forbade abortion


1568 words - 7 pages destruction. The utilitarian approach deals with consequences, it tries both to increase the good done and to reduce the harm done. Strengths Secular. Utilitarianism does not rely on specific beliefs about God. In the modern, multicultural society with a range of religious beliefs and a growing number of atheists, a secular approach is most useful. The utilitarianism approach is universal, which means it is acceptable to all the different types


316 words - 2 pages behind having abortions A. Supporting detail- Confused decision making 1. “Opinions on abortion are very complex, with many Americans saying they are opposed to abortion but don't favor banning the procedure” (Murchison, 1999). 2. “Americans do not want to outlaw abortion, but neither do they think it should be completely unrestricted” (Murchison, 1999). B. Supporting detail- Birth control 1. Abortions should only be used in emergency

Army Of God

602 words - 3 pages informant has used against the Army of God to prevent any attacks from this group and what precautions will law enforcement need to take before apprehending a member from this group. This paper will also discuss how the local court systems handle domestic terrorism. Finally, should domestic terrorist be tried in local, state, or federal courts? The reason the people of Army of God choose to be terrorists is to stop and make all abortion illegal

Business Ecomics

897 words - 4 pages situation with my mother and I believe it was back in 2002 where she had so many high hopes and dreams for me until it all came crashing down (at that moment) when she found out I was pregnant. Keep in mind my father was raised up in a Christian home and raised and taught by his family the same values (Thou shall not kill). My mother wanted me to have an abortion and I had an abortion, now was it ethical was it right or wrong, she thought it was for

The Movie “Blood Work” Deontological And Utilitarian Analysis

2174 words - 9 pages promote the general good…” (Pg.369 Utilitarianism, John Stuart Mill) As a conclusion to McCaleb’s dilemma, I would say that the theory that suits his moral choice and the course of the events better is the Utilitarian approach versus a Deontological approach. The Utilitarian theory would also be a better guide to the moral life in this movie. Deontology teaches that a person shall act from a sense of duty out of good will and without any

A Competitor Firm Has Outsourced Its Production Abroad. You Could Do The Same. You Are The Major Employer In The Town Where You Are Located. You Have To Decide Whether Also To Outsource Your...

2065 words - 9 pages 1815). When looking at this approach we have to take in to account all of the organisations stakeholders. The utilitarian approach is simply a balance of good verses evil; pleasure versus pain. Utilitarianism has a few issues especially within this context where we are trying to remain competitive. Where utilitarianism is concerned, trying to maximize economic value can lead to three difficulties. Firstly increasing the inequalities between people


1580 words - 7 pages baby deserved the opportunity for the life it was given and if she had to, she would have rather taken care of the baby as its legal guardian. As a soon to be young mother, I was faced with a tough decision in life. Although I ultimately had the abortion I really didn’t want to give up my child; no mother wants to. At first I was going to give birth to my child especially since my mother kept reminding me of the time she didn’t have that


330 words - 2 pages Choose an organisation that has gone through a change process and critically evaluate the management of that change process by the consultant(s) or change agent(s) involved. The full assessment criteria is overleaf but please note the following information :- Context In order to evaluate the management of the process it is necessary to understand the situational context to assess how appropriate the consultant/change agent approach was


1541 words - 7 pages should come into the world wanted, loved, and cared for. Planned children often have better life prospects because caregivers are better prepared to support the child physically, emotionally, and financially. The fetus is not yet a human being because it cannot survive outside the uterus on its own. Abortion should not be considered murder if the fetus is not self-sustaining and requires the mother’s body and physical resources to survive. The body

Similar Documents

Abortion123 Essay

969 words - 4 pages negative strictly on their morals beliefs that abortion kills an unborn human. Prochoice individuals believe that a woman has the right to decide what to do with her own body. Many of their arguments begin with the idea that if a woman is raped she has the right to abort the pregnancy because it could traumatize her even more. Some women use abortion as a form of birth control and feel that it is their right to do so. No matter how one looks at abortion

Debate Paper

460 words - 2 pages , there are so many complications when it comes to abortion such as cancer and other problems with your ovaries and uterus not being able to function properly anymore. I strongly feel that abortion is wrong and it’s just a quick way to not accept ones responsibility for their own actions. References

Abortion Essay

571 words - 3 pages means. Abortion moved from a practice that occurred behind closed doors and only for a select portion of the population to a practice that virtually skyrocketed among the general populace, rich or poor. The pro-life side will contend that the term pro-choice is an altogether unfair designation. What their opponents really are, they will argue, is pro-abortion. On, the other hand, pro- choice proponents will likely argue the term pro

Why Can't We Be Good? Essay

391 words - 2 pages PHI 106 Assignment #1 Why Can’t We Be Good? “Our society simply has no generally acceptable solution to the ethical dilemma of abortion. So here is a test for us. This is ethnics. We are in front of a painful and Momentous question of right and wrong. How shall we try to think - to think, and not just wrangle - about it?”(“Why Can’t We Be Good?”, pg.63) I believe that everyone has an opinion about a certain situation whether it’d