This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Deception And The Investigating Officer Essay

1493 words - 6 pages

Deception by the Investigating Officer in the Investigative, Interrogative, and Testimonial Processes
Anita L. Levy
AJS/532 Ethics in Justice and Security

June 8, 2015
Professor Melba Pearson

Deception by the Investigating Officer in the Investigative, Interrogative, and Testimonial Processes
Deception involves “acting in such a way which leads another person to believe something that you, yourself, do not believe to be true” (Alonso-Quecuty, 1992). Deception can occur in any or all of the three stages of the detecting process which include, investigation, interrogation and court testimony. Each stage is subject to increasingly tough normative constraints (Skolnick, 1999).
...view middle of the document...

Skolnick suggests that judicial acceptance of deception in the investigative process has a positive effect on the moral acceptance of the same methods by detectives in the interrogation and testimony phases as well (p. 83).
When you look at the interrogation phase, the deception tactics vary, but they represent the hostile nature of this phase of a case. The goal of an interrogation or criminal interview is to obtain factual information about a crime and the confession of the person responsible for it. Although some methods seem clearly illegal especially those that deny or tend to distort the meanings of the Miranda rules that guarantee at least certain minimum conditions of conduct (Skolnick, 1999). Then you have others that may take on the form of twisting the seriousness of the crime, engaging in victim blame, or suggesting to a murder suspect, that the victim is still alive. Other opportunities for deception include threats or promises such as telling a suspect that confessing will result in less jail time or engaging in the good cop/bad cop method of questioning. Also fabricating claims of evidence, like appealing to a suspect’s conscience, are perfectly legal methods of deception (Skolnick, 1999).
There are a number of reasons that testimonial deception may be undertaken, including cases where the motivation is to hide criminal behavior on the part of the investigator or cover up investigative incompetence. There exists a large number is cases where the motivation is a desire to secure a conviction of those who are factually or morally guilty and avoid apparent deficiencies in the criminal justice system (Skolnick, 1999). The task of police officers is to deal with factual guilt, not legal culpability, and many officers are frustrated by the exclusion of evidence on the basis of a technicality or a lost case on the grounds of unreasonable doubt on the part of the jury. The police believe they have done their job and desire it concluded appropriately, when criminals get what is coming to them. Then they can say that society is protected from a predator and liar, and liberty is secured (Skolnick, 1999).
The law is definitely unclear on whether police deception is legal or not. There is also some very good case law on police deception which is laid out in the following cases (Brocklin, 2014):
In Miller v. Fenton, the court reversed the defendant’s conviction based on the interviewer presenting himself as a friend who wanted to help of the defendant would just unburden himself. Miller was also falsely told that the victim was still alive. The interviewer stated several times that Miller was not a criminal who should be punished but a sick individual who should receive help. One hour into the interview Miller confessed, then collapsed, and was taken to the hospital.
In People v. Adrian Thomas, the police interviewed the defendant for hours. Investigators told Thomas they would pick up his wife if he didn’t...

Other assignments on Deception And The Investigating Officer

Ethics In Business Communication Essay

459 words - 2 pages admitted to engaging in unethical behavior when it comes to investigating the safety of its vehicles” (Mack, 2010). This was the first admission from Toyota that they were wrong in the handling of the recall. During the hearing, Toyota’s US President and Chief Operating Officer stated to reporters that “safety was Toyota's top priority and we are committed to a great relationship with both Congress and our regulators." ("Toyota Executives Face

Multicultural Poliing Essay

265 words - 2 pages Michael Brown was an unarmed black teenager who was shot and killed by the police in Ferguson. I feel that the unarmed 18 year old has become a powerful symbol of the lack of trust between African Americans and the law enforcement, not only in Ferguson, but in the rest of the country. I doubt that the officer drew his weapon or fired it for no reason. When the officer shot he might have been defending himself. After research, reports say that

Managers Job In Context

2298 words - 10 pages Interactions Within the organization, Mr. Anasari has numerous interactions with employees in accomplishing his objectives for the bank. These may include; human resource manager, operations manager, marketing officer loan officer, credit manager, accountant, bank cashier, customer services manager, financial consultant/adviser and foreign remittance manager. In addition to the internal employees, Mr. Anasari may also have to interact with people outside

Sociology Essay Structure

3978 words - 16 pages , Race Relations Act, EAL, New Right. In answering this question, candidates may refer to some of the following sources and/or relevant alternative ones: Ball, Chubb and Moe, David, Gewirtz, Leech and Campos, Thompson, Trowler, Whitty. 2. Education (in the context of research methods) 20 mark questions * Using material from Item B and elsewhere, assess the strengths and limitations of one of the following methods for investigating the

Police Ridealong

5679 words - 23 pages MODULE 1: Note: My “Ride-A-Long” portion was completed in two sessions: Saturday September 6, 2014 From 9:00 AM to 2:00 PM and on Saturday September 20, 2014 from 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM. 1. Why did you become a Police Officer? (Answered by Officer V. Vasquez.) “Ever since I was a child, and as far as I can remember, I was attracted to Police work. When I turned 14 I enrolled in the Police Explorer program at my local Police Department

Business Law

757 words - 4 pages reply or intent of deception or fraud is not valid. For example, the agreement between A and B, where A will pay RM2000 to B if B promises to deceive the customs authorities at Port Klang that the imported goods tax-free. While for section 24 (d). Contract catastrophic disasters to the person or the property of others. If the reply or the purpose of an agreement involving or injurious to themselves or other people's property, the courts have

M3 A2

969 words - 4 pages there is good reason for the officer to suspect they have broken the law. In the case at hand, when Officer Marconi approached the area he saw a woman matching the description given by the store manager, and carrying what appeared to be clothing. He recognized the suspect as Mary Jones, someone he had previous dealings with. Because of the past history with the suspect, Officer Marconi was aware of the potential problems that could take place

Criminal Justice System

872 words - 4 pages functions in crimes. The police are the ones that are enforcing the laws and investigating the crimes as well as apprehending the offenders. Police work to maintain public order, reduce and prevent crime while trying to ensure public safety. Then there are the criminal courts which conduct fair and impartial trials. The court systems have to determine which cases are criminal

Public Administratuin

1171 words - 5 pages INVITATION: VALIDATION WORKSHOP ON THE PREPARATION OF NATIONAL HABITAT III REPORT Subsequent to Habitat II, the United Nations General Assembly will decide to convene the Third United Nations Conference on Housing and Sustainable Development (Habitat III) in 2016. Habitat III will be one of the first global Conferences after the Post 2015 Urban Development Agenda and is intended to provide the opportunity to discuss and chart new pathways in

Hawkins V. The State. Court Of Appeals Of Georgia

2133 words - 9 pages have the authority to send text messages to her, and receive and read text messages from her, using the phone of the other individual. The E evidence presented at the hearing on the motion to suppress shows that an officer with the Lowndes County Sheriff's Office was contacted by a mother, who said that numerous text messages about narcotics were being sent to her son's cell phone, the mother then delivered the cell phone to the officer. Sometime

Die Fliedermaus

685 words - 3 pages ever after”. The major theme in this play is lying and deception. The message that is conveyed through the play is that lying and deception is fun when it is done for fun. The deceit in the play is portrayed seemingly lighthearted. The plays major action is the lying and deception of the main characters toward one another. Rosalinda is seeing Alfred behind her husband’s back, Eisenstein lies to his wife about going to jail when he is actually

Similar Documents

Police Ethics Essay

1341 words - 6 pages ) provides the Enforcement Code of Ethics. Through focus by officer of law enforcement should be made in serving mankind through ensuring they saves lives, property and protects the innocent and weak from deception, violence, intimidation, ensuring justice and equity as well as safeguarding the rights of constitution of all men to liberty (Kleinig, 2008). Components of police corruption within criminal justice In criminal justice, the

What Attributes Are Required Of An Undercover Officer?

395 words - 2 pages What attributes are required of an undercover officer? Be a US citizen or a resident alien, have a high school diploma or GED. Pass the ASVAB test; you’re not a convicted felon. Have experience working as a law officer, and undercover training. Do you believe you would make a good undercover officer? Why or why not? I believe I would make a good undercover officer because; I always wanted to be a cop really a detective officer since I was ten

Investigative Report

546 words - 3 pages One December 9, 2011, Officer Larry and Officer Byron pulled up next to each other talking when they noticed a black window tinted Tahoe approaching them. The vehicle appeared as if it was going to head straight until it noticed the two officer’s cars on a side street, which it then slowed down, and turned around. This of course made Officer Larry and Officer Byron very suspicious. It was approximately 3:10 AM, which made it even more suspicious

Advertisment Essay

457 words - 2 pages In the world of advertisement the way the way words are used to describe products can be very misleading and it is the key to advertisement deception. For the past few days I have been watching commercials, and have seen these deceptive commercials in the advertisement industry.  These commercials mislead people into thinking that these products are “wonder products” and these products will do everything they claim it says it will do