David Hume Non Human Reasoning Essay

543 words - 3 pages

Nick Hittner
Phil 3120
4/16/2015
Reaction Paper Cycle 3 Topic B
Thesis
The topic of this paper is David Hume’s belief whether or not nonhuman animals are rational. David Hume has a belief that is in contrast to that of the Cartesian view of humans possessing a unique ability to reason. He believes that nonhuman animals do have this ability to reason but not one in the same as humans. In this paper I am going to defend Hume’s beliefs but also point out some of the downfalls to his arguments.
Exposition
Hume believes that nonhumans do have the ability to reason because to suggest that they couldn’t would be implying that humans are radically different from animals. This is not good reasoning because humans and animals behave and have a great amount of similarities to each other. ...view middle of the document...

Hume is not suggesting that there is not difference only that it would be incorrect to say that animals do possess the ability to reason. His first reason to suggest that animals have the ability to reason is that they can learn from experience and can make links between events. Another reason is that animals do not make these connections using argument or reason but neither do children or anyone for that matter. He believes that humans just like animals make connections on experience and not through reason alone, humans use analogy but animals do not. Hume believes that the instincts that animals possess are no different from the ones shared by humans to reason on the basis of experience.
Analysis
One of the problems I find with Hume’s conclusions is that he does not believe that human reasoning is not a special faculty of our mind. There are robots, computers, and other mechanical devices that behave in ways that are similar to humans but this does constitute proof that these devices act as a result of ideas or experiences to their consciousness. But I believe that computers don’t have the ability to act on causes that they aren’t programmed to handle. Humans and even animals to some extent can use reason, which we draw from previous experiences, to handle situations that have been thrown at us such as a fire or some other natural disaster. There are cases of animals doing extraordinary things in situations that they have never been in and have used reason to save their lives. Reason cannot obtain an a priori knowledge about the mysteries of the world. Reasoning is based on perceiving the right connections in nature and even with these connections we can never perceive any of these that go beyond constant conjunction. This causes our higher reasoning to be no more than that of the instincts and rational justification of animals.

Other assignments on David Hume Non-Human Reasoning

Literature And Poetry Essay

623 words - 3 pages pessimistic,humanists psychology are that human beings are intrinsically good and that their human natures possess constructive and trustworthy attributes.This view of many humanists in the West. Cognitive: Cognitive psychology investigates processes related to thinking, including memory, reasoning, and decision making. Cognitive psychologists also research perceptual and learning processes. Their are two student in

Management Essay

9111 words - 37 pages Strategic Management: A Competitive Advantage Approach, 14e (David) Chapter 10 Business Ethics/Social Responsibility/Environmental Sustainability 1) Many people consider it unethical for a firm to be socially irresponsible. Answer: TRUE Diff: 1 Page Ref: 310 AACSB: Ethical Understanding and Reasoning Abilities Objective: 10.01 Explain why good ethics is good business in strategic management. Learning Outcome: Discuss the roles

Scientific Investigation And Non-Scientific Investigation

1386 words - 6 pages have any criteria in defining the reality. It regularly falls into these forms: (1) common human inquiry (basic phenomenon that any human beings may find out from daily life), or in the form of agreement reality (those things people “know” as part of the culture that they share); (2) Tradition (inheritance of a culture); (3) Authority (dependence on the status of the discoverer). What are the differences between scientific and non-scientific

Gre Verbal

4064 words - 17 pages GRADUATE RECORD EXAMINATIONS® Introduction to the Verbal Reasoning Measure Copyright © 2009 by Educational Testing Service. All rights reserved. ETS, the ETS logo, GRADUATE RECORD EXAMINATIONS, and GRE are registered trademarks of Educational Testing Service (ETS) in the United States and other countries. Introduction to the Verbal Reasoning Measure This document describes the types of questions contained in the Verbal Reasoning

Social Responsibility

5313 words - 22 pages , pricing, resource conservation, product quality and safety, and doing business in countries that violate human rights. There are two opposing views of social responsibility. The classical view is the view that management’s only social responsibility is to maximize profits. Economist and Nobel laureate Milton Friedman is the most outspoken advocate of this view. Friedman argues that managers’ primary responsibility is to operate the business in

Capital Punishment

1497 words - 6 pages death penalty should be enforced. In this paper I will discuss my reasoning as to why I feel the death penalty should be eliminated. Some have argued that capital punishment is a form of cruel and unusual treatment which makes it unacceptable due to the pain and suffering that it causes the condemned individual. An execution is a violent spectacle of official homicide which endorses killing to solve social problems. Governments worldwide have

The Human Condition

1180 words - 5 pages : Eisenberg, Leon. "The "Human" Nature of Human Nature." Science, JSTOR. 14 Apr. 1972. 16 Jun. 2012 http://www.jstor.org/stable/1732969. Gutierrez, David “Supporting World Population at U.S. Consumption Rates Would Require Five Earths.” Natural News 26 Mar. 2008. N. Pag. Web. 16 Jun. 2012 Walsh, Dylan “A War Against Food Waste” New York Times 15 Sept. 2011. n. pag. Web. 18 Jun. 2012

Hello World

3546 words - 15 pages the silence of mental solitude. But we no longer believe in the solitary mind. If the Romantics had Hume and the modernists had Freud, the current psychological model — and this should come as no surprise — is that of the networked or social mind. Evolutionary psychology tells us that our brains developed to interpret complex social signals. According to David Brooks, that reliable index of the social-scientific zeitgeist, cognitive scientists

Panic Attacks In Young Adults (18-29)

2442 words - 10 pages , Norman S.; Swinson, Richard P., Anxiety Sensitivity and Panic Attack Symptomatology, Behavior Research and Therapy, Sep95, Vol. 33, Issue 7, p. 833-836 Deacon, Brett J.; Valentiner, David P., Substance use and Non-Clinical Panic Attacks in a Young Adult Sample, Journal of Substance Abuse, Jan00, Vol. 11, Issue 1, p. 7-15 Den Boer, J.A., Defining Panic- A Diagnostic Dilemma, Human Psychopharmacology: Clinical & Experimental, Jun97

Cognitive Views On Learning

3462 words - 14 pages “Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space lies our freedom and power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and freedom.” Viktor Emil Frankl, M.D., Ph.D (Man's Search for Meaning; 1946 ) Everyone of us, Human or animal alike, have been living in this world since the primordial time. Coping with every change that had happened and developing new routine in everyday life. Routines that may soon be etch with

Is Morality A Biological Or Social Construct?

2036 words - 9 pages , propose such different values and beliefs? It is apparent that morality is a world known entity but morality cross culturally and within the same society or even households are not absolute. After careful consideration, it would prevail that through the process of evolution, humans do share a number of characteristic traits with non-human animals. It seems that humans have learned the capacity for moral reasoning over time and through

Similar Documents

Explain Paley's Teleological Argument Essay

1739 words - 7 pages planets. He argues that this regularity did not come about by chance but that it has been directed to be the case by some higher power. This being, for Paley, is God. Hume’s comments about design in the universe destroyed Paley’s argument. Discuss (10) David Hume criticised Paley’s argument and analogy by means of ‘redectio ad absurdum’ He clearly showed that if one takes the analogy of a machine being like the world then the argument simply

Why Was Socrates Regarded As A Man Of Virtue?

7161 words - 29 pages . * The Age of Enlightenment ended with the French Revolution. It was followed by the period of Postmodernism which associates with the critique of Enlightenment values and truth claims. Prominent Philosophers of the Modern Period * Rene Descartes * Thomas Hobbes * John Locke * David Hume * Immanuel Kant * Jeremy Bentham * Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel * Arthur Schopenhauer * John Stuart Mill * Soren

My Philosophy On Life Essay

3200 words - 13 pages it has mass, than it must be physical. Idealists would greatly disagree, saying everything that appears physical is really an immaterial manifestation of the mind, but the mind itself must be physical because it is made of matter (Moore 99). Even my thoughts exist on a physical level; they are a combination of neurotransmitters and electricity. In this way, I am very inclined to believe the epistemological theories of David Hume, a modified

Organs Transplant Essay

5407 words - 22 pages . Medawar received the Nobel Prize in Medicine in 1958. In the early 1950s, Dr. Rene Küss in Paris and Dr. David Hume in Boston began earnest attempts at transplantation. The first recorded event in which a transplanted kidney functioned was in 1951. Dr. Küss transplanted the kidney to the iliac fossa, as is done today. One of the 5 transplanted kidneys worked for 2 months without immunosuppressant, when it rejected and thrombosed. In contrast, Dr