Counseling Clinical Depression: Nouthetic Versus Contemporary Christian Counseling

3851 words - 16 pages

Depression is a state of mind in which a person has feelings of sadness, helplessness, negative thoughts, guilt, and other feelings that usually last longer than the average mood that results from experiencing the ups and downs that life brings. Bouts with depression can last for weeks, months, and even years. People exhibit depression through a lack of interest in things that would normally motivate them to action, a lack of attention and/or production on and off of the job and at home, as well as in other areas of life where the same people would normally thrive. Sometimes physical affects are the results of depression. Things such as weight loss, achiness, and other symptoms that are ...view middle of the document...

Clinical depression is depression that is not caused by a mental disorder, but instead can be caused by circumstances that we do or do not control. The causes can be biological or from things other than sickness. This type of depression can be cured and is not necessarily the result of some sin. Contrasted with manic depression, clinical depression is not caused by a mental illness, like bipolar disorder, but it can come as the result of physical illness because it is found to be caused by a lack of serotonin in the brain.
Treatment of clinical depression in the Christian community is as debated as the issue of counseling itself. In 1970, in response to what was believed to be a secular and anti-Christian view of how to deal with counseling issues for believers, Jay E. Adams popularized nouthetic counseling for believers. Adams believed that using secular methods for Christian counseling, because it relied heavily on the beliefs and studies of Freud and Jung was inept to solve the problems that people faced psychologically. Because Freud believed that many of the problems that people faced were not problems that they caused, but were the results of unconscious processes, and his ideas about psychology seemed to avoid personal responsibility, the use of this style of counseling by Pastors and lay people was not adequate. Freud, and other modern psychologists also rejected Christianity altogether.
At this time Christian psychologists sought to blend what psychologists believed with Christian counseling. In effect, to take from modern psychology what could be valuable to Christian counseling and blend it with the Bible and Christian principles for effective counseling techniques.
Adams believed that the bible offered all of the answers to man’s clinical psychology problems, and that it should be relied upon, apart from the Freudian methods taught by modern psychology, to heal patients. Adams said that modern psychology was not the answer to man’s needs because it did not address the whole person. He also believes that because psychology tended to blame problems on some biological defect, the problem of sin in the life a believer was often avoided. He said that psychologists were not even sure of what to gather from these two individuals, and so how could they use their methods to help people to solve their problems. Adams was very sharp in his criticism of modern psychology saying that “The church, throughout the years, like Adam and Eve, either has been deceived by Satan’s counsel or has found itself in conflict with it. There is no neutral ground.”[2] Not everyone however, believed that there was no neutral ground.
In response to Adams, and in an attempt to be more progressive another movement has emerged which uses the bible and modern psychology to address the problems with the human condition. From this movement, Adams is criticized for being too focused on the sin problem, and not giving enough attention to the grace of God in the...

Other assignments on Counseling Clinical Depression: Nouthetic Versus Contemporary Christian Counseling

Psychology Essay

961 words - 4 pages covers a broad range of disorders, from depression to obsession-compulsion to sexual deviation and many more. Counselors, clinical psychologists and psychotherapists often work directly in this field. * Biopsychology: Biopsychology is a field of psychology that analyzes how the brain and neurotransmitters influence our behaviors, thoughts and feelings. This field can be thought of as a combination of basic psychology and neuroscience

Single Parenting Essay

892 words - 4 pages single parenting because it can help people cope well with difficult problems. For instance, a single parent may run into technical difficulties and may need help. This prevention can provide help like counseling or something to help prevent any psychological orders like depression. I know from experience that depression can take a toll on someone’s body. A single parent can have so many emotions. Primary prevention can help them cope with

Depression In College Students

2357 words - 10 pages pression Affects College Students How Depression Affects College Students Nikki M. Broadnax Elementary Education Major Abstract The age group of depressed college students is 18 – 32 many students find the adjustment from high school to college difficult. Even the student that seems most at ease with their new lifestyle will often confess to moments of missing their familiar high school friends, family and other

Behavior Therapy Outline

4080 words - 17 pages context of a behavioral orientation, can contribute significantly to the process of behavior change. Most behavioral practitioners stress the value of establishing a collaborative working relationship. Application: Therapeutic Techniques and Procedures Arnold Lazarus - Pioneer in contemporary clinical behavioral therapy. - “practical practitioners can incorporate into their treatment plans any technique that can be demonstrated to

Abnormal Psychology

5375 words - 22 pages environment and experiences. Contemporary research suggests that most personality traits are based on the joint influence of genetics and environment. One of the forerunners in this arena is C. Robert Cloninger, who pioneered the Temperament and Character model. * Uniqueness versus universality This question discusses the extent of each human's individuality (uniqueness) or similarity in nature (universality). Gordon Allport, Abraham

Hypnosis

3514 words - 15 pages & contemporary perspectives. The American Journal Of Clinical Hypnosis, 51(2), 101-121. Kellis, E. (2011). Clinical hypnosis and cognitive-behaviour therapy in the treatment of a young woman with anxiety, depression, and self-esteem issues. Australian Journal Of Clinical & Experimental Hypnosis, 38(2), 155-165. P.G.O'C. (1998). In support of hypnotherapy. Cortlandt Forum, 11(1), 92. Singer, W. B. (1952). Post-hypnotic suggestion in group

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Social Media

626 words - 3 pages depression shows its impact on university students. The first article is about the relationship between depression, treatment and the academic performances on the undergraduate students. In this 121 students were examined with depression. As form of treatment some students were prescribed drugs, some counseling, and others none. Later it was found that some faced family problems, some relationship problems and so on. However all these significantly

4-Mat Review-Mcminn

1534 words - 7 pages Psychology, Theology, and Spirituality in Christian Counseling 4-MAT Review 4-MAT Review: McMinn Summary Psychology, theology, and spirituality in Christian Counseling written by Mark McMinn (2011) discuss the integration of psychology and spirituality including impacts of such in our daily lives both personally and professionally. According to McMinn (2011) there are three essential categories that must be

Human Services Scenario

1164 words - 5 pages could negatively affect their client in the greatest way. A scenario of a 45 year-old Hispanic female diagnosed with clinical depression will be used as a hypothetical case and the approach in helping her will be explored. The attempt to analyze, diagnose and treat her effectively given her unique situation is the goal. With each case and clinician being different it is apparent that unique interviewing skills and techniques must be applied

4-Mat Review

2101 words - 9 pages 4-MAT Book Review Jayne Kelley Liberty University   In his book Dr. Wright begins by reciting a personal dilemma from the time when he was a youth pastor at his church. Throughout the book, he uses a Christian perspective on counseling reciting scenarios from his life to demonstrate the different concepts of counseling. Dr. Wright uses these situations. To teach the proper responses, to different crisis situations. When reading these

Entwistle Review

1109 words - 5 pages further research on it I cannot get a definite grasp on the information given in the book. Action When I become a Christian counseling, I plan to incorporate the powers of prayer and scripture into my clients’ situations. I will make sure that I pray to God to give me the strength and guidance that is needed to listen and help others as they go through their struggles. If I have a client that is going through a similar situation that I went

Similar Documents

Ethic In Counseling Essay

4546 words - 19 pages Abstract It is the purpose of this paper to address the topic of ethics in group counseling. This author will define what group ethics is according to the psychological organizations such as the American Counseling Association (ACA), and the Association of Specialist in Group Work (ASGW). This author will also address what the American Association of Christian Counselor (AACC) has to say about the ethical standards for Christian Counseling. To

Multiculturalism In Counseling Essay

2088 words - 9 pages describe various therapies that are used with different age groups and explain why it is important to use certain therapeutic methods with young children versus adults who are neurologically developed. Literature does not explain that multiculturalism is inevitable, especially in America – the capital of diversity. Limitations of this research are further explained. Race/Ethnicity Differences with Therapy Contemporary psychotherapy and

Group Therapy Essay

268 words - 2 pages me to long hours of counseling, to help me understand and deal with my situation. Although I have had some marriage counseling in the past, the majority has been subsequent to being diagnosed with depression. I have done individual counseling, marriage and family counseling too. And most recently, I am currently taking a course titled Working with Groups, at Columbia College. It discusses the different types of therapy. Needless to say, it is very

Examination Of Clinical Psychology Essay

1079 words - 5 pages overall improve their life (Plante, 2011). Although each research method and design each have their advantages and disadvantages, they each serve a purpose to provide unbiased results. Clinical Psychology and Other Mental Health Professions Clinical psychology differs from other mental health professions due to the emphasis in research. “Psychiatry, social work, and marriage and family counseling, for example, all have their roots in practice