Corporation Law Essay

2225 words - 9 pages

Word Count (including footnotes):1997

Due Date: 16/4/2012
Name of Tutor: Michael Duffy
Name of Unit: Corporation law

Question 1
Issue: can shareholders force the company comply with the replaceable rule and clause2.1?
Under s134, a company’s internal management may be governed by provisions of the Corporations Act that apply to the company as replaceable rules, by constitution, or by a combination of both. Orchard Downs Pty ltd’s internal management is governed almost exclusively by its own constitution. The only replaceable rules it uses are the replaceable rule in s201G and the replaceable ...view middle of the document...

Therefore, the shareholders can prove that the behavior of the board affect them in capacity as members, since the members have the voting right to appoint a director. (Pender v Lushington case) Section 1322(2) reinforces this right of members to enforce the constitution. It enables the court to invalidate a procedural irregularity that causes substantial injustice. (Chew investments Pty Ltd v General Corp of Australia Ltd case) The board of directors appoints a new director without holding a general meeting causes substantial injustice, since all shareholders are unsatisfied with the appointment.
Hence, the shareholders can sue the company breach the contract to obtain remedy. The main remedies are court injunction or declaration to enforce compliance with the constitution/ applicable replaceable rules.
Besides, one of the clauses in the constitution (Clause 2.1) states: ‘Orchard Downs Pty Ltd will only use suppliers of recyclable goods for the packaging of its products’. In fact, the board decided the company was no longer using recycled packing. Shareholders could argue that the company does not comply with Clause 2.1 under s140(1)(a). But members cannot enforce provisions in the constitution which purport to give them rights in some other capacity than that of a member.(Eley v Positive Govt Security case) Furthermore, under s198A directors can change the direction of the company and exercise all the powers except the Act or the company’s constitution (if any) requires the company to exercise in general meeting (John Shaw& Sons Ltd v Shaw case). Consequently, the company cannot be forced to comply with clause 2.1.
The shareholders can alter constitution to restrict director’s powers by special resolution (Shuttleworth v Cox case); or remove the board of directors under the replaceable rules s203(c), a proprietary company may remove a director by resolution.

Issue: Can Nick prevent the new clause inserted?
The process for inserting a new clause in the company’s constitution is
* Call a general meeting for inserting a new clause in the constitution of the company;
* Under s136(2), a company may modify or repeal its constitution or a provision of its constitution by special resolution, which is passed by at least 75% of votes cast by members entitled to vote on the resolution: s9.
* If any limits involved or a majority of 75% is not met, the motion of inserting a new clause will be failed.

In this case, s136(2) requires a special resolution to be passed for Teen Music Pty Ltd to insert a new clause in its constitution. However, as in this case the alteration of the constitution is related to expropriation of Nick’s shares, the other 3 shareholders must prove that the alteration of constitution is for a proper purpose and fair in all circumstance. Cite a case Gambotto v WCP Ltd. An expropriation of shares will be for a proper purpose, if the expropriation of shares prevents the company from suffering...

Other assignments on Corporation Law

Business Environment – Apple Inc Essay


Law Of Business Association Essay

1019 words - 5 pages . Relevant Rules of Law Under Corporation Act, law uses a number of techniques to deal with allowing companies to act and think. These technique are variously deployed as the policies of particular area of law emphasising differing qualities of responsible for action. There are four techniques to attribute actions and mental states to corporation, direct liability, vicarious liability, organic theory,and corporation culture. Direct

Role And Functions Of Law

608 words - 3 pages services in commerce; and powers of the executive, legislative, and judicial branches to regulate business activity (Melvin, 2011, ch 1). Statutory law is created by the legislative (Congress) branch and either approved or rejected by the executive (President) branch. At the state level the state legislature (i.e. General Assembly) passes statutes such as “motor vehicle laws, business corporation and partnership laws, and other traditional state

Film Analysis: The Corporation

1032 words - 5 pages starts with a potted record of the corporation’s legal structure in America, mentioning the major 19th-century legal innovation that resulted in treating corporations as persons under law. By granting them the protections and rights that persons enjoy, this legal innovation gave the corporation the freedom to thrive. The most effective level in addressing the problems mentioned is the corporate level. “The Corporation” shows that the trouble with

Lit1 Task 310.1.2-01-06

3037 words - 13 pages laws. • Longevity/Continuity- Corporations carry on regardless of the circumstances surrounding the owner’s deaths, and transfers of interests in the corporation have no impact, and unless the state law has put a limitation on the existence of a corporation, it can continue indefinitely. • Control- Day-to-day management of a corporation rests with the officers appointed by the board of directors, who are ultimately responsible for the

Types Of Business (3)

2086 words - 9 pages limited partnership has pass-through taxation. Each person reports their share of business profits or losses on an individual tax return. Corporations: A corporation is formed under the state’s law and provides limited liability for the investors. None of the shareholders in a corporation are accountable for the debts of the corporation. Creditors can look only to the corporation's assets for payment. The corporation files its own tax return and


590 words - 3 pages Res Judicata RES JUDICATA-         the Latin term for "a matter [already] judged", and may refer to two things: in both civil law and common law legal systems, a case in which there has been a final judgment and is no longer subject to appeal.[1]; and the term is also used to refer to the legal doctrine meant to bar (or preclude) continued litigation of such cases between the same parties, which is different between the two legal systems. In

The Scrushy Way

1617 words - 7 pages . In a similar fashion, SOX mandates that audit committees be independent from the corporation. Ethics cannot be legislated, if business desire to make a decision than a loophole in the law will be found. Financial disclosures The stated purpose of SOX was to improve the accuracy and reliability of corporate financial disclosures. If SOX were working, why then do there continue to be accounting and corporate scandals? Through the proper

The Paralegal Profession

657 words - 3 pages The Paralegal Profession Ruth Keith Everest University According to Paralegal Today (2011), a paralegal is “a person qualified by education, training, or work experience who is employed or retained by a lawyer, law office, corporation, governmental agency or other entity who performs specifically delegated substantive legal work, for which a lawyer is responsible” (p. 3). This paper will show the various duties of the paralegal. It

Business Organization

1415 words - 6 pages everyone. References Laurence, B. (2015). How to form a corporation. Retrieved from encyclopedia/form-corporation-how-to-incorporate-30030-2.html Rogers, S. (2012). Essentials of Business Law. Bridegpoint Education, Inc. Spadaccini, M. (2005). The legal ins and outs of forming a partnership. Retrieved from U.S. Small Business Administration. (2015). Sole proprietorship. Retrieved from

Criminal Law

2463 words - 10 pages The word corporation is derived from the Latin word Corpus which also means body. A corporation is therefore a legal person brought into existence by a process of law and not by natural birth. Owing to these artificial processes they are sometimes referred to as artificial persons, not fictitious persons. Company law can be described as the body of laws and rules that govern companies created under the United Kingdom Companies Act of 2006

Similar Documents

Coporate Veil Essay

552 words - 3 pages THEORY OF PIERCING THE CORPORATE VEIL Most people form corporations to insulate themselves from liability.  The insulation exists because corporations are generally considered by law to be separate and distinct from their shareholders.  This protection is often referred to as the corporate veil.  While most people who incorporate believe they have no personal liability for the debts of the corporation, this is not always true. For example, if

Legal Forms Of Business Organization Essay

1062 words - 5 pages better idea of the various options available to entrepreneurs after reading this essay. Legal Forms of Business Organization The three most popular structures of company organization are the sole proprietorship, the partnership, and the corporation. A sole proprietorship has one owner while a partnership has two or more owners, and a corporation is an entity created by law (Gitman & Zutter, 2014). The forms offer limited liability or unlimited

Net Operating Loss Rules Essay

388 words - 2 pages Unit 5 Assignment: Net Operating Loss Rules The Garvey Corporation, a C corporation, during its first 5 years of operation, reported the following taxable incomes (losses): Year | Taxable Income * | 1 | $60,000 | 2 | 20,000 | 3 | (90,000) | 4 | 30,000 | 5 | (40,000) | a. Explain the net operating loss provisions of the tax code as they would relate to the Garvey Corporation. Tax law allows that the amount can be immediately

Tort Essay

679 words - 3 pages , a corporation's board member has a fiduciary duty to the shareholders, a trustee has a fiduciary duty to the trust's beneficiaries, and an attorney has a fiduciary duty to a client" (Breach of Fiduciary Duty Law and Legal Definition). The directors in the scenario above are acting with the interests of themselves more than the corporation. The directors find themselves in Breach of Fiduciary Duty when they start diverting contracts from