Commercialization Of Organ Transplants Essay

1361 words - 6 pages

Assignment 1: Commercialization of Organ Transplants
Nicholas Owens
Professor Kenneth Pino
Business Ethics
05-04-14

I’ve recently done research regarding the commercialization of Organ Transplants. I’ve found many arguments for and against this subject. Some individuals find the act to be unethical, and other’s think it will save lives. The problem is that a new policy was proposed to allow sale of organs by consenting individuals to patients in need and to medical institutions. When it comes to the subject of human organs, there are a few ethical standards to consider. There are religious standards, social norms, ethical code, morals, and policies in which we should follow. Critics ...view middle of the document...

Anything that can be sold on the black market would be more beneficial if made legal and taxed. Despite all of the pros there are some cons that have dire consequences. By commercializing organ transplants some ethical codes are violated. Apart from the fact that selling these organs would be against federal law because it was banned by congress. Also, despite the fact that this goes against public policy we have to evaluate the ethical wrongs. Many religions have certain beliefs about the body being the “temple of the lord” and not defiling that temple. So, to commit such an act would violate their traditions. For example, the Jews believe in being buried with all of their body parts. Also, critics argue that to allow commercialization of these organs will encourage criminal behavior. In our society there are criminal acts made because of financial struggles i.e.; prostitution, and human trafficking. I think we all can agree that selling human organs and thinking of them as a commodity violates the social norm. There may seem to be more pros than cons when it comes to commercializing organ transplants but I’m against it. It doesn’t matter if an action only hurt’s a few people the fact remains that it’s unethical. Society needs to evaluate the moral principle in this situation. We can’t allow human organs to be sold as commodities for money, personal gain, or just because we can do what we want with our bodies. For example, suicide is illegal because it’s immoral even if it is your body. Also, you can be locked up or discharged from the military for causing yourself bodily harm and this isn’t much different. By donating your organs you can risk sickness, and even death. Also, if one person donates an organ and the other organ gives out this will pose another health problem. We shouldn’t agree with anything that violates any moral standards, or that would promote unethical behavior. For example, it’s not ethical to commit murder in order to save a friends life. Well, then it’s not okay to put other people at a health risk to save another patients life on a waiting list. Also, this policy would make the commercialization of organ transplants worldwide which can cause health issues. These transplants can bring diseases to people who are in need of an organ transplant which will make them sicker. “According to the World Health Organization (WHO), in 2005 93,000 kidney, liver, and heart transplants were performed globally. There is evidence that the medical practices surrounding commercial organ transplantation are sub-standard. Medical complications are common, as is the transmission of infectious diseases, including HIV and hepatitis B and C.” (R.W., Evans) Some argue that this won’t happen if we regulate transplantation. For example, policies should be made to run tests on donors and make sure their organs are healthy before accepting. However, this will not fully eradicate the disease problem because a criminal market will be produced after...

Other assignments on Commercialization Of Organ Transplants

Shingles Essay

322 words - 2 pages weaken immune system, which and can be caused by and HIV/AIDS, Cancer - undergoing chemotherapy or radiation treatments (lowering the your resistance) Medications- drugs that prevent organ transplants and can prolong the use of steroids, such as prednisone. Complications Treatments and Drugs There are no cure for shingles but medications and treatments are given to reduce the infection and complications and/or the virus and accelerate up

Human Essay

1118 words - 5 pages babies to be raised to maturity”(Hume, 1997). Moreover, it could be argued that being “evil” is probably a learned behavior. Each of the ten thousand clones would be a product of their environment, which would not be the same environment in which Hitler (or whoever) was raised. Other arguments against human cloning involve organ transplants and slavery. Sometimes people who oppose this scientific miracle think that millionaires might clone

Stem Cell Research

2085 words - 9 pages . Organs produces through cell culturing have several advantages over a donor’s transplanted organ. First obviously being availability, near perfect conditions are necessary to accomplish transplants of any organ and cell culturing would result in a much more controlled method of transplantation. Third advantage is that organs developed using this method will subject to immune reaction occurring when a replaced organ is rejected by a recipient’s body

Reflection

1017 words - 5 pages state? Does terminating a pregnancy due to birth defects make it right? Ethical termination of adult life is yet another issue. Do we really have the right to end another person’s life? Whether the person is dying of a disease or committed sometime of crime is it really up to us to play God and decide when they die? Another issue is organ transplantation. Do we have the right to sell our organs before or after death? Are we obligated to donate our

Altruism

1987 words - 8 pages behaviour makes in society (an altruist believes in selfless behaviour and incorporates the welfare of others positively as a function of their own utility). This is as preventing the exclusivity of having only altruistic donors for a certain organ, would cause society to perceive a downward bias on the true positive effect created by altruistic behaviour. This occurs due to the distortion created by the large benefits of having a market for kidneys

Ch 16

2519 words - 11 pages based on a description of the extent of the disease rather than on cell appearance. Assignment is completed after the diagnostic workup and determines treatment options. o The clinical staging classification system uses five stages, from in situ to metastasis. o The TNM classification system uses three parameters: tumor size and invasiveness (T), presence or absence of regional spread to the lymph nodes (N), and metastasis to distant organ

Ahel Results

3011 words - 13 pages Our commitment to advanced patient care has helped us put in place the world’s busiest solid organ transplant program. Completed 500 Bone marrow transplants with outstanding outcomes India, May 20, 2013: Apollo Hospitals Enterprise Ltd (AHEL), (BSE: 508869, NSE: INE437A01024), the Healthcare Pioneer and leading provider of quality clinical care today reported its consolidated financial results according to Indian GAAP for the quarter and

Bacteria In Mcrobiology

3359 words - 14 pages these trillions of microbes, as well as others living elsewhere in and on the body, is collectively known as the microbiome. Taken together, these bacteria can weigh as much as six pounds, and they make up a sort of organ whose functions have only begun to reveal themselves to science. Lyte has spent his career trying to prove that gut microbes communicate with the nervous system using some of the same neurochemicals that relay messages in the brain

Terri Shiavo Case

2300 words - 10 pages with dignity and privacy was violated (Erban, Sullivan, Ney, & Weijer, 2006). Medicine has seen immense changes such as organ transplants, implantable defibulators, and permanent gastric tubes. The technology lengthens life but the payoff is seen in numerous social and moral issues. This has resulted in modern medicine merging with legislation, ethics, and politics (Cline, 2010). Quality of life must be considered as the life expectancy

Plans

8374 words - 34 pages join the new Registry, ensuring their wishes are documented. Today, more than 100,000 children and adults await lifesaving organ transplants while hundreds of thousands more are in need of tissue transplants. Together, we can make a difference. How Can You Help? 1. Learn the facts about organ, eye and tissue donation. 2. Designate your wishes by joining the Joshua Abbott Organ & Tissue Donor Registry at www.DonateLifeFlorida.org 10

Ethics Terms And Principles

2792 words - 12 pages to terminate the life of a terminally ill patient who only has a few days to live in order to donate her organs to several other patients needing transplants is an example of consequentialism. In the United States, the best interests of the individual patient are still most important. Health care professionals still practice nonutilitarian medicine. Kantian Deontology Deontology is an ethical system that relies heavily on the work of

Similar Documents

Concept Essay

1291 words - 6 pages kidney to keep his son alive. While Matthew’s father sees this as a potential option, this system is illegal in the United States and many other countries around the world. Five to ten percent of all organ transplants are obtained through an organ trade (“Is It Ever Right” 36). Organ trade is also known as organ trafficking. To better understand organ trafficking, it’s best to know what it is, to what extent it occurs, and what

Organs Transplant Essay

5407 words - 22 pages , the kidneys are the most commonly transplanted organs, followed by the liver and then the heart. Cornea and musculoskeletal grafts are the most commonly transplanted tissues; these outnumber organ transplants by more than tenfold. Organ donors may be living, brain dead, or dead via circulatory death. Tissue may be recovered from donors who die of circulatory death, as well as of brain death – up to 24 hours past the cessation of heartbeat

Organ Donation Essay

3369 words - 14 pages Health and Human Services, every day 19 people die who are waiting for organ transplants due to a shortage. (Holmes) The benefits of organ donation are important because they have a higher need for organ transplants due to certain diseases that affect individual races on a more frequent basis. Many parts of the human body can be donated, including organs, such as kidneys, heart, lungs and liver. The pancreas and intestines are also viable

Why Not Me Essay

1976 words - 8 pages a number of African-Americans in need of heart, pancreas, lung, and liver transplants (Carolina Donor Services, 2003). The Root of African-American Disproportion of Organ Need African-Americans are disproportionately afflicted by certain conditions such as hypertension and diabetes, which can lead to kidney failure. Native Americans have the highest rates of diabetes in the world but, 2.3 million African Americans have diabetes and one-third