Classism And Criminal Justice Essay

4368 words - 18 pages

Kristopher S. Bolds

Classism and Criminal Justice

Justice is a term that we hear every day and accept although many of us have skepticism as to what it truly means. In general, justice is the idea of righteousness and equality. In regards to society’s views on how “just” the criminal justice system is, we always incorporate the “ism’s”: Racism, sexism and classism, to demonstrate some of the pitfalls that the system has. Though it is obvious that all of these societal differences play a large role in the criminal justice process, I will focus on classism. Classism is the discrimination against a group or individual based on social and economic status. Classism is one of those “ism’s” ...view middle of the document...

Obviously, the people that are labeling these so-called deviant acts are not going to mandate them in opposition of their interests, so they are made in a way that gives the people with high class and power some leeway, whereas the people whose interests are not taken into account are put at an unfair disadvantage. Authors of Class, Race & Gender Crime, Barak, Leighton and Flavin stated “The rich and powerful use their influence to keep acts from becoming crimes, even though these acts may be more socially injurious than those labeled criminal” (Barak, Leighton and Flavin 2007, 124) These deviant acts are controlled by laws which are implemented to promote the interest of the state, which is run by the upper-class. Time and time again we see examples of this disadvantage in play. This can be represented through favoritism shown towards members of the upper class by giving them a slap on the wrist for crimes that would be looked at as serious if committed by a member of the lower class. Another form of this favoritism is profiling the lower class for specific crimes that they elite may be committing because when the lower class commits these crimes, they are “more dangerous”. Barak, Leighton and Flavin give a number of demonstrations of the way that laws are only enforced onto certain groups. One demonstration that they provided was the lack of attention paid to white collar crime in an effort to crack down on street crime. The authors stated
“… the Reagan, Bush I, Clinton, and Bush II administrations have all consistently worked to get government ‘off the backs’ of corporations as they ratcheted up their war on the crimes of the poor. For example, while President Reagan’s ‘tough on crime’ legislation expanded the use of mandatory and minimum sentences along with federal use of the death penalty, his administration eliminated many federal regulators and inspectors who acted as police in the corporate neighborhood.” (Barak, Leighton, Flavin 2007, 183)
This is a perfect representation of what Bernard Harcourt calls the “ratchet effect”. The ratchet effect is the effect that targeting a specific population to reduce crime has on crime itself. When a group is targeted, their propensity to commit crime goes down, while the crime rate in the non-targeted group goes up. While this persists, special attention is not paid to the group with the higher crime rate because the officials are too focused on keeping the crime rate down in the targeted group. In the case of white collar crime, it is not farfetched to believe that, in addition to the aforementioned statement, the elite just simply “chose” to not focus on the crimes of the upper class as long as they are capitalizing on the crimes of the lower class.
Under Marxist criminology, in response to the oppression and disadvantages unfairly bestowed upon them, the lower-class participates in what Marxists call “working class crime”. This type of crime is caused by a sense of anomie, which is a...

Other assignments on Classism And Criminal Justice

Criminal Procedure Policy Essay

1105 words - 5 pages There are two models to the criminal process: due process and crime control. They serve as the basis for regulation and freedom as it pertains to the application of criminal justice and criminal law. The models are in constant opposition with each other to impose their importance to the system as it pertains to principles in the criminal justice process. Even with the dissimilarity between these two models of criminal law, they both have several

Criminal Sentencing Essay

700 words - 3 pages L. Elise Bowling Criminal Sentencing CRJ 301 Juvenile Justice Timothy Koester September 20, 2010 Criminal Sentencing Over the years, there has been great debate over the purpose of sentencing criminals, but it generally all boils down to the importance of deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation, and retribution. All four plays an important role in sentencing, and each vary on a case-by-case basis

Provide A Brief Overview Of The Juvenile Justice System In Ireland And Analyse Its Response To Young Offenders Making Reference To The Children Act 2001 In Your Answer

1224 words - 5 pages detained in custody for criminal charges. The campus can cater for up to 44 males and 8 females who have been convicted or placed on remand by a court. “The principal objective of the schools under the Children Act 2001 is to provide care, education, training and other programmes with a view to reintegrating the child into society.” (Irish Youth Justice Service, 2005) Minister Fitzgerald also holds responsibility for the Child Care Aspects of the

Fraud Paper

1711 words - 7 pages officiating judge has the final say. 4) In a criminal court case, the sentence can be a fine or jail time, or both. While in a civil court case, the defendant cannot go to jail, but can be forced to pay monetary damages to the plaintiff, or to return property. In the civil justice system, the primary purpose of a civil action is to recover losses and possibly reap punitive damages. In fact money and other similar damages are the main outcome in

Criminal Law

882 words - 4 pages Criminal law is something that is very important because it protects the good people in society from the ones who tend to break the law. Each jurisdiction has its own laws and the way things are handled, but overall each jurisdiction has the same basis of criminal law to protect the people and to prosecute the criminals. Criminal law sets procedures for arrests, searches and seizures, and interrogations. It also establishes the rules that are

Due Process And Crime Control

2336 words - 10 pages and federal level, the Court sent a clear signal to law enforcement and criminal justice officials. Convictions not made in conformity with the “fairness” standard would likely be overturned. Constitutional guarantees of due process for the accused had to be upheld. The Court heard a number of similar cases at the same time that it heard Miranda. The Miranda decision distilled the several “fundamental fairness” standards into one succinct

Criminal Justice System Paper

2630 words - 11 pages Introduction The criminal justice system in the United States is multifaceted and is best understood when dissected into individual parts. There are the components of the criminal justice system, classifications for crime, due process, types of punishment and the process of the criminal justice system, all of which only scratch the surface. When studying and working in the criminal justice field it is important to remember that without each

Victimization In The Criminal Justice System

1204 words - 5 pages Victimization in the Criminal Justice System Ian Gallagher CJA/534 May 18, 2015 Lora Terrill Victimization in the Criminal Justice System In ancient times, victims of crimes, and their kin, were responsible for the sentencing and implementation of the offender. This trend did not reappear, in a more lawful form, in modern criminal justice systems until the 1970’s. Recent years have seen growth and attention in victim’s rights and advocacy

My Cousin Vinny

1191 words - 5 pages My Cousin Vinny The movie “My Cousin Vinny” is a comedy film of 1992, which is an amusing interpretation of the processes of the criminal justice system. The film depicts the procedures and processes of the court and criminal justice system. There are many things that have been depicted in the movie wrongly, but some are the correct depictions of the court proceedings and the criminal justice system. Many professionals have criticized the


1560 words - 7 pages rehabilitation for people who are too young to bear criminal responsibility for their actions (US Dept. of Justice, 1974). The Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice has a set values statement, which determines the attitude to juveniles in criminal justice and respectful treatment provided by law enforcement officers to them. Juveniles in criminal justice are Virginia are treated as a specific group and have extended rights compared to adult offenders


2538 words - 11 pages Crime is something that impacts everyone, whether directly as a victim or indirectly through societal and economic costs. From the early 1960s, in the United States, criminological research resulted from individual efforts. The reliance on individual investigators to conduct and oftentimes fund their own research agenda was primarily a function of a lack of funding sources devoted to issues surrounding criminology and criminal justice. However

Similar Documents

Narcotics And Criminal Justice Essay

1556 words - 7 pages Narcotics and Criminal Justice CRJ 311 Forensics Instructor: Paul Stein December 3, 2012 Narcotics and Criminal Justice We hear the word Narcotic and most everyone knows this means a mind altering drug of some type but it is what we do not know that can hurt us. The Merriam-Webster online dictionary tells us that a Narcotic is the following: “1a: a drug (as opium or morphine) that in moderate doses dulls the senses, relieves pain, and

Criminal Justice System Essay

872 words - 4 pages Criminal Justice System By: Kari Baublit UOP Online Criminal Justice 2 There are many things that happen in society today that have to do with crime. There are things that are considered small crimes or offenses and there are things that are considered large crimes or offenses. Crime happens everywhere all

The Criminal Justice System Essay

642 words - 3 pages The Criminal Justice System The United States criminal justice system is perhaps the most intricate process in the developed world. It consists of three parts; the legislative body (responsible for creating laws), corrections (responsible for imprisonment) and the court system. The legislative body is self-explanatory and the bulk of the legislative process is through Congress. The corrections division of the justice system is vital as it

Disparity And Discrimination Essay

828 words - 4 pages There is no hiding the fact that both disparity and discrimination are alive and well in the criminal justice field. When reading the words disparity and discrimination, at first glance one might think of them being the same. When we take a closer look at the two the definitions when it pertains to the criminal justice system, they become quite different. It is an important task to identify the two definitions in the criminal justice system, and