Case 2 Essay

1552 words - 7 pages

Alyssa Anderson
PLS 300 (2): Introduction to Law and Civil Procedure

Eilers v. Coy
2 F. Supp. 1093 (D. Minn. 1984)

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

MacLAUGHLIN, District Judge.

The plaintiff in this case, William Eilers, has moved the Court to enter a directed verdict against the defendants on his claims that the defendants falsely imprisoned him.

The evidence in this case has established the following facts. The plaintiff William Eilers was abducted from outside a clinic in Winona, MN in the early afternoon of Monday, August 16, 1982 by his parents and relatives and by the defendant deprogrammers who had been hired by the parents of the plaintiff. The plaintiff was 24 years old.

...view middle of the document...

The plaintiff was held at the Tau Center for 5½ days and was the subject of the defendants’ attempts to deprogram him. Shortly after his arrival at the Tau Center (and after a violent struggle with his captors), the plaintiff was handcuffed to a bed. He remained handcuffed to the bed for at least the first two days of his confinement. During this initial period, he was allowed out of the room only to use the bathroom and was heavily guarded during those times. On one occasion, the plaintiff dashed down the hall in an attempt to escape, but was forcibly restrained and taken back to the room.

The defendants and the plaintiff’s relatives had agreed in advance of the abduction that the plaintiff would be kept at Tau Center for one week (regardless of whether the plaintiff consented to their actions). At no time during the week was the plaintiff free to leave the Tau Center, nor at any time reasonable means of escape were available to him. Three of the eight people hired by the parents were designated “security men”. These individuals (described by witnesses as at least six feet tall and weighing over 200 lbs) guarded the exits on the floor at all times.

On the evening of Saturday, August 21, 1982 as the plaintiff was leaving the Tau Center to be transported to Iowa City, IA for further deprogramming, he took advantage of his first opportunity to escape and jumped from the car in which he was riding. Local residents (attracted by the plaintiff’s calls for help) assisted the plaintiff in making his escape and the police were summoned.

The evidence has also shown that within three weeks before the abduction occurred, the plaintiff’s relatives had contacted authorities in Trempealeau County, WI in an attempt to have the plaintiff civilly committed. Family members have testified that they believe the plaintiff was suicidal because of a letter he had written to his grandmother before joining the Disciples of the Lord Jesus Christ in which he wrote that demons were attacking his mind and telling him to kill himself rather than go to the Lord. Joyce Peterson (a psychiatric social worker) interviewed the plaintiff in person on July 26, 1982. After interviewing the plaintiff and consulting with the Trempealeau County Attorney, Peterson informed the plaintiff he showed no signs of being a danger to himself or to others. The defendants in this case were aware of that information at the time they abducted and held the plaintiff.

DISCUSSION

[1] In considering the plaintiff’s motion for a directed verdict, the Court is required to view the evidence in the light most favorable to the defendants and to resolve all conflicts in the evidence in the defendants’ favor like Dace v. ACF Industries, Ind., 722 F.2d 374, 375 (8th Cir. 1983). A directed verdict motion should be granted only when reasonable jurors could not differ as to the conclusions to be drawn from the evidence.

[2] The plaintiff’s first claim is that the defendants’ conduct in...

Other assignments on Case 2

Hr In Action Case Incident 2

526 words - 3 pages HR In Action Case Incident 2 1. What should be the format and final form of the store managers’ job description? The store manager is responsible for directing all store activities, therefore the job description should include a short overview about the tasks, employees, standards and procedures. His particularly branch always refer to individually performance given by his job needs. Writing or pointing out job descriptions for trained employees

Case 1-2 Giles And Regas Essay

1396 words - 6 pages Case 1-2 Giles and Regas 4/21/2015 1.Facts Ed Giles, 35 year old CPA and a partner at Saduga & Micha accounting firm Susan Regas, 25 year old senior accountant in the same firm Giles and Regas been dating for four months They well know firm policy does not permit different ranks to date Most of the staff seem to know about their relationship Regas was assigned to audit CAA industry under Giles

Case Study 2 Acct504

993 words - 4 pages clear guild-lines and standards are established and clearly understood by its employees. 2. Ensuring the completeness and accuracy of financial records. All financial transactions are fully and accurately recorded, assets and liabilities are correctly identified and properly valued, and that all revenues and costs are fully accounted for.  3. To prevent and detect fraudulent activity. Controls are necessary to show up any operational

Tanglewood Case 2

532 words - 3 pages 1. Answer b) Forecast of availabilities Job Category Current – 1 -2-3-4-5 Exit (1) Store associate 8500 4505 510 0 0 0 3485 (2) Shift Leader 1200 0 600 192 0 0 408 (3) Department Manager 850 0 0 493 102 0 255 (4) Assistant store manager 150 0 0 9 69 12 60 (5) Store Manager 50 0 0 0 0 33 17 Answer c) According to data some factors show that Tanglewood will have some difficulty with hiring because retail work is

Case Study 2: Zara International

809 words - 4 pages one year, the company was able to bring in $2 billion of revenue. Secondly, Zara arranged an ‘organization’ that allowed them to obtain the resources in order to foresee their company. They understood the demand for the quality and quantity of workers to be able to uphold their mission of the fast fashion technique. Not many retailers are savvy enough to create and/or imitate trends within a matter of weeks, get the items to their stores within a

Scenario 2

719 words - 3 pages and alimony payments in order to determine what data to collect from Mr. Charles to prepare an accurate tax return. Determine what other key deductions and credits, based on the circumstances, Mr. Charles should consider. Provide a rationale for your response. I believe that it is true that not all taxpayers are familiar with tax codes, but in Mr. Charles case he needed to meet certain requirements. As for his home office expense, the amount

Chapter 2

2315 words - 10 pages . 2. Undistributed Expenses: Examples might include electricity, energy, and water expenses. For, usually the hotel receives a total energy bill to be paid. In the old days, some hotels went for allocating this amount according to certain factors (ex. Surface, Department Usage…). However, this practice proved to be misleading, since it might under-allocate energy expenses for some departments and over-allocate it for others. Nowadays, most of

Socoteco 2

2280 words - 10 pages telephone number (083) 552 396. The cooperative is engaged in the retail of electricity throughout its service area. It is the sole provider of electric service in its area of operation and is considered a mega-large electric cooperative. The cooperative designates three (3) area of operations, namely: East Area, West Area and Central. The cooperative has 14 substations with a substation covering each major sectors. Chapter 2

Chapter 2

3462 words - 14 pages CHAPTER 2 REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES This chapter discusses foreign and local that can be attributed in the success of this undertaking. Difference and similarities with the previous studies are presented in this chapter. The following researches and studies greatly influence on the conduct of this study; the researchers have made consideration in drawing the final conclusion in the study. Foreign Literature Facebook is an

Legal Encounter 2

412 words - 2 pages work in. (2) Quid pro quo, in which Sam used to maintain power over Paula after the broken relationship between them abusing his power as a supervisor. (3) The violation of the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA). Sam used the gender of Paula as an excused to allow her transfer to another department where Sam would not have control of Paula. The violations above have both statutory and case law, the statues in place assist the courts, and however it is the case law that determines the interpretation of the case at hand. Because many statues have different interpretation, many judges use other cases in similar situations to determine the proper ruling.

Psyc3001 - Assignment 2

5786 words - 24 pages treatment, followed by group discussions and support—except in the case of the control group. Participants from the control attended seminars, held week 5 of the intervention according to designated levels of exposure: low (3-hr seminar), medium (6-hr seminar) and high (2 x 6-hr seminars). Seminars taught how to manage stress and involved general physical education but did not involve the opportunity to exercise skills, nor the support given

Similar Documents

Case #1 (Ch1, Case 2) Essay

892 words - 4 pages deal with my parents’ constant complains about the troubles they have to go through when sending money to the United States. As I was reading the case, I was amazed how innovative its service is. PayPal’s app would be excellent for going out with friends because the app will allow us to split our bills almost instantly. We could avoid asking a waiter/waitress to split the ticket. I think this app has a lot of potential for the future and it

Kim Fuller Case 1 2 Essay

332 words - 2 pages Case 1-2 & 2-3 Anthony Case 1-2 & Anthony Case 2-3 Anthony Case 1-2: Kim Fuller 1. In order for Kim Fuller’s plastic bottle grinding business to get off the ground she will need to manage the business with non-accounting and accounting information. The following information to run the business is non-accounting information, as it is not owned by the company did not occur through a monetary transaction: 2 grind machine workers, 1

Erica Carson Case 1 2 Essay

541 words - 3 pages Case 1-2: Erica Carson Name: ________________ Group: ___A or B________ Date: ________________ ------------------------------------------------- Situation: * Erica Carson is PM for Wesbank, a financial institution (note: You are Erica) * Reports to VP Supply * Unsolicited bid from Art Evans, Sales Rep. Killoran Inc. * 10% reduction on printing and mailing of checks * not current supplier

Ac 505 Case Study 2

570 words - 3 pages opportunity to obtain a new route that would be traveled 20 times per month. The company believes it can sell seats at $ 175 on the route, but the load factor would be only 60 percent. Fixed cost would increase by $ 250,000 per month for additional personnel, additional passenger train cars, maintenance, and so on. Variable cost per passenger would remain at $ 70. 1. Should the company obtain the route? 2. How many passenger train cars must