Business Decision Making Essay

2349 words - 10 pages

Technical bulletin

professional information for CILA members

TB 16 August 2003

The following article appeared in Herbert Smith's Insurance Update Newsletter (May 2003) and they have kindly given permission for it to be circulated to CILA members.

Policy conditions: legal classification and consequences of breach

On at least three occasions last year the Court of Appeal considered the issue of the interpretation and status of conditions where insurers were seeking to rely upon terms to obtain a declaration of non liability for a particular claim. In any policy, determining the status of a contractual term is vital to establishing the insurer's rights ...view middle of the document...

Whether or not a breach of such a condition gives the insurer the right to set aside the policy in its entirety, refuse to indemnify an insured with regard to a single claim or simply seek damages for any loss incurred as a consequence of the breach, will be influenced by whether the policy specified the effect of breach of that term or not. In the absence of any express term outlining the effect of breach, the question will be whether a breach of the term in question can be said to go to the heart of the contact and is in effect fundamental to the entire risk, or whether it is clear that the term is of a minor nature and will not affect the existence of the policy. In the former case the insurer will cease to be liable for any losses arising under the policy after the date of the breach, whilst in the latter insurers will remain responsible for losses accruing after the date of the breach, and will only have a right to seek damages if the breach of that condition has resulted in any actual loss.

Breach of an innominate term

It is possible that the status of the condition cannot actually be established at the outset of the policy, and in such cases it will be treated as an "innominate" condition. As such it is necessary to look at the consequences of the breach of that condition before determining whether or not the insurer can set aside the policy or seek damages. It is evident, however, following Alfred McAlpine plc v BAI (Run Off) Ltd. ([2000] Lloyds Report IR 352) that the Court of Appeal (obiter) has established a third possible remedy for insurers, namely that if an insurer can show that in linking the condition to the particular claim the breach was of such a serious nature that it in effect repudiated that claim, then the insurer can reject that claim, whilst the policy and risk in respect of other claims remain unaffected.

Recent cases

In light of the severe consequences to an assured of a breach of a condition precedent, issues as to the identification and status of these terms are often raised in Court. The following cases highlighted how difficulties can arise, and in turn demonstrate the Court of Appeal's reiteration of the well established principle that whilst it is open to insurers to express a term to be a condition precedent to liability or to risk, in doing so they should ensure that the condition so expressed is drafted in clear and unambiguous language because if there is any ambiguity, the condition will be interpreted in favour of the assured.

In George Hunt Cranes v Scottish Boiler and General Insurance Co Ltd ([2002] Lloyds Rep IR 178) the defendant insurer agreed to indemnify an engineering company against all sums for which it would become legally liable to pay under any contract of hire for compensation in respect of loss and damage to plant hired to it. The claimant's crane had been hired to the company and suffered damage whilst in its possession. The company subsequently went into...

Other assignments on Business Decision Making

Thinking And Decision Making Essay

1623 words - 7 pages Thinking and Decision Making Adults face opportunities to make decisions constantly. Each day, people decide how best to solve issues, plan for the future, make ethical decisions, and more. Some decisions require little to no extra thinking, with minimal consequences or benefits; whereas other decisions require much more time due to the magnitude of the decision, and its potential impact on the wellbeing of self or others. Important decisions

Financial Decision Making Essay

1251 words - 6 pages RMIT FINAL EXAMINATION FACULTY OF BUSINESS SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS AND FINANCE BAFI-1100 FINANCIAL DECISION MAKING FIRST SEMESTER 2004 DATE: TIME: INSTRUCTIONS: 1. This is a CLOSED BOOK EXAMINATION 2. The examination represents 60% of the assessment in this subject. 3. All answers are to be made on the examination paper. 4. All questions should be attempted; there is no choice between questions

Forms Of Strategic Decision Making

2964 words - 12 pages development, which in its core should be progressive and dynamic, are leaving people to work on projects that do not take into account any possible substantial changes in the micro or macro environment, often under the influence of the planning system (Mintzberg and Quinn, 1998). In other words, some aspects of the business progress cannot be predicted nor planned and formalised strategic decision making is lacking flexibility in dynamic and uncertain

Decision Making

319 words - 2 pages When it comes time to make a decision, I am one that thinks very hard and carefully about the choice I should make. I use critical thinking skills when I make a choice, especially with it come to something large like a job, home and school. Making the choice to return to school was a big decision for me. The first step to decision making is “to recognize that a problem exists and must be solved” When I was in the thinking process of go I want

Decision Making Process Paper

545 words - 3 pages Decision-Making Process Paper 1 Decision-Making Process Paper Connie F Dents February 14, 2012 MGT/230 Steve Rosales Decision-Making Process Paper

Decision Making Process

694 words - 3 pages Decision-Making Process Debra Burton MGT 230 March 3, 2014 Dave Ball Abstract Individual makes decisions every day. Many do it without even realize they are using the decision-making process steps. There are six steps in the decision-making process that will help the individual to come up with the best choice on the decision that has to be made. In this paper, the decision-making process will be discussed along with an

Decision Making Steps

1055 words - 5 pages Decision Making Steps Step 1: Identify the decision to be made. You realize that a decision must be made. You then go through an internal process of trying to define clearly the nature of the decision you must make. This first step is a very important one. Step 2: Gather relevant information. Most decisions require collecting pertinent information. The real trick in this step is to know what information is needed, the best sources of this

Decision Style Making

304 words - 2 pages eciDsion Making Styles Decision making style basically depends on managers' approach to decision making. Decision making style propose that people differ in two dimensions when they approach decision making. The first is an individual's way of thinking and second is individual's tolerance for ambiguity. On the basis of the way of thinking and tolerance for ambiguity, decision making styles may be classified as directive, analytic, conceptual

Decision Making Process

574 words - 3 pages Decision-Making Process MGT/230 July 15, 2013 Decision-Making Process Summary Making decisions for career promotions or career changes can be difficult for one in the decision. Recently I was challenged with a career change. I had to make a decision to stay at my present employer, or switch careers to a different company. The reasoning behind a possible career change was because the present owner of the apartment complex has sold the

Ratio Analysis In Decision Making For Health Care Organization

845 words - 4 pages Ration analysis Financial statements paint a picture of financial health of an organization. Important aspects of the financial statement of a health care organization are ratios. Analysis of ratios show how two numbers relate or compare to one another. Ratios are a way for organizations to make comparison. These comparisons not only encompass what is happening presently but can also be used to make comparisons about numbers and ratios over

Strategies For Decision Making: Definition Of Critical Thinking

815 words - 4 pages Strategies For Decision Making: Definition Of Critical Thinking Definitions Conceptualizing- If you have an idea for something, or if you understand something fully, you conceptualize it. Analyzing-Is to study or examine something carefully in a methodical way. Synthesizing- The combining of two or more things to create something more complex. Definitions in My Own Words Critical Thinking- When an individual can

Similar Documents

Decision Making Essay

823 words - 4 pages Business Information Systems Learning Outcomes Week 5 DECISION-MAKING SYSTEMS 1. Explain the importance of decision making for managers at each of the three primary organisation levels, along with the associated decision characteristics. * Meaning of decision making * Decision making is a process of selecting the best among the different alternatives. It is the act of making a

Decision Making Essay

2819 words - 12 pages of financing are available. Choosing the right financing source is based on these vital points; business condition and the interest rate or the other cost of the finance. Some sources of finance are more flexible than the others, according to the business situation, external source of funds is the best possible way. List of References Colin, G. Bill, N. and David, M. (1983). “Business decision making” 2nd ed. Indiana University:P. Allan

Decision Making Process Paper

362 words - 2 pages to the ones described in the text and how that decision could have been different if you had used the same steps included in the text. Decision making is the process in which companies organize a business. The right decisions reflect leadership There are numerous factors that influence decision making. Significant ones like past experiences factors include, a variety of cognitive biases, an escalation of commitment and sunk outcomes, individual

Accounting For Decision Making Essay

765 words - 4 pages GSM5301 Accounting for Decision Making MID TERMEXAMINATION 3 July 2013 8 pm - 10 pm Instruction: Answer ALL questions. Show all workings and answers in answer book provided. QUESTION 1 (10 marks) If you are looking to invest in a publicly listed company, what are the types of financial and non-financial information inside the annual report of that company that are important for you? Why are these two types of information important for