This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Blood For Sale Essay

1262 words - 6 pages

Blood for Sale: A Discussion from Multiple Ethical Dimensions
To make money by selling blood is an issue and discussion for ages. The most vital factor is its ethical implications. When an egoist is asked about this topic, he presents his own valuable ideas. According to the ethical egoist, selling blood is not at all unethical. He presents a strong notion that if an action produces positive consequences for the doer, then it must be considered as ethical because it meets his own self-interest (Blackburn, 2003). If a person offers his blood to some patient in return of some money, then it should be important to analyze the type of consequences. The money or other benefits that he gains or ...view middle of the document...

It is also evident in some cases that such donors donate blood only for money. Therefore, such actions violate the utilitarian norms that direct a person to act emotionally for the well-being of the others (Mizzoni, 2009). According to this theory, the donor must not only focus on the money, rather he should also develop an emotional bond with the patient.
The third consultant tries to assess this matter from the points discussed in Kant's Categorical Imperative. This individual states that the perfect duty does not allow a person to sell blood as the basic duty of a human being is to help others. If it were universal, then every person in this world would intent to sell his blood to the patients in need. This violates the basic norms of the perfect duty. He also believes that a person must do everything needed to survive and maintain existence. As imperfect duties are circumstantial, an individual is allowed to sell his blood for money when a patient is in need. Such imperfect duty should be supported until it clashes with the perfect duty (Paton, 2010). In this case of selling blood, the imperfect duty contradicts the perfect duty. Therefore, it can never be accepted that blood would be put for sale.
The fourth consultant tries to assess this case based on Ross's theory of Prima Facie Moral Obligations. The primary and principal use of Ross's theory is to determine between the prima facie and the contradictory duties. The prima facie duties clearly direct people about what they should do under a specific circumstance. But, prima facie duties can conflict with some contradictory duties in some cases. When someone sees an old person collapsing on the ground and no other person is around there, he will certainly be influenced by prima facie duties. If he sees a bike standing nearby, his sense will convince him to take the bike and take that person to the hospital. Here the duty of harm prevention contradicts with the duty of not causing injury. But, harm prevention should be given priority in this case. The individual adheres to the theories of non-injury, harm prevention, and beneficence. The first theory suggests that the duty of a human being is not to harm any other individually either physically or psychologically. The second duty states that the duty of a person is to prevent any possible damage to another person or to himself. The third obligation suggests that a person should act and perform to promote and ensure his own good (Ross, 2002). These three theories exclude any unethical implication in this matter. The donor sells the blood but he meets multiple prima facie duties.
The fifth consultant advocates the theory of Virtue ethics. According to this perception, a person's decision should be evaluated according to...

Other assignments on Blood For Sale

Laws Essay

7217 words - 29 pages obligated to honor their implied warranties and grant corresponding remedies to consumers. Logical reasoning and appropriateness of cause are part and parcel of consideration in imposition of the consumer law. While consumers have the right to choose and make a canvass of prices, once a sale is done and the product has no defect, one cannot return the goods nor ask for a refund. Consumers are entitled to either an exchange or refund, as long as

Great Lakes, Great Decisions (Case Study)

4668 words - 19 pages company. The dilemma arises in the fact that TEL is a huge financial success for Great Lakes; the company controls 90% of the market and the product accounts for 59% of their annual profit. Great Lakes should cease all operations involving the sale of TEL and focus on being a responsible corporate citizen. They will need to reinvest their resources on penetrating new markets, using their existing products as well as new products made possible by

Comp

2216 words - 9 pages June 30 and $.235 per mile afterwards in 2011 can be used for driving one’s own automobile. * The cost of meals en route is not deductible as a direct moving expense. * Expenses incurred by members of the taxpayer’s household are deductible. 5) Indirect expenses: a) Indirect expenses are not deductible. b) Include house hunting; temporary living expenses and expenses related to the sale, purchase or lease of a residence. Q2

Happy Feet Line Dance

2452 words - 10 pages . Happy Feet Soul Line Dance Group will serve the Tampa Bay Area. We will help individual to learn to dance through line dancing while improving their health. There is not a line dance studio for people, who want learn to line dance and meet other people who have similar interest. African-Americans suffer from high blood pressure, hypertension, diabetes, and heart disease, line dance give them the opportunity to improve these health issues. Happy

Bactol Alcohol Marketing Plan

6716 words - 27 pages and 0.04 respectively.8 2.3 Diagnosis Self-diagnosis for cold is frequent and isolation of the actual viral agent is rarely performed. It is differentiated from viral upper respiratory tract infection by the location of symptoms. As for typhoid, body fluid or tissue culture of blood is carried out to confirm the presence of S. typhi. The sample is placed on culture, incubated and checked for the presence of the bacteria. Among the

Consumers Receive More Benefit Than Risk From Marketers Knowing Their Personal Information

1950 words - 8 pages affordable to all. Additionally, the public welfare and interest are well protected because it ensures that the firms who are engaged in the sale of goods and services meet their demand. This is achieved by the provision of an ample environment for businesses to experience fair competition resulting in good business practices in all industries in the United States. This is achieved by cultivating the culture and the belief that the economy, the

Now Compared To Then

1865 words - 8 pages employee that comes to work for the Great Northern American Company can be very over whelmed by the environment that is of the work place. Decisions need to be made on the “fly” in order to close certain sale deals with customers, because all the workers understand that the effort that one puts in is rewarded at the end. Learning Theory With The Great Northern Company being such a financial success for the past 35 years, it has a lot to do

I Don't Have One

2129 words - 9 pages ) Italy (E) France The immediate reason for Luther’s protest against the Catholic Church was (A) the church’s practice of excommunication (B) the church’s ban on usury (C) the Papal refusal to permit Luther to marry (D) church-sponsored sale of indulgences (E) his support for German nationalism Which of the following expresses Martin Luther’s main philosophical disagreement with the Roman Catholic Church? (A

Wow Qceva

2399 words - 10 pages it new or used? Which model or make will you most likely use? Will you lease it or buy it? 7. Which ads do you like and which do you dislike? How do they influence our purchase decisions? 8. Did you donate blood this year? Do you give time or money to help people with personal, medical, or economic problems, or do you leave those problems for other people to solve? 9. Did you vote in the last election? For whom

Minicase

5748 words - 23 pages robust solutions for desktop, laptop, physical access, and point-of-sale environments.20 Another advantage of finger-scan technology is accuracy. Identical matches are nearly impossible since fingerprints contain a large amount of information making it unlikely that two fingerprints would be identical. Even with large databases, it is possible to eliminate false matches and quickly reduce the number of possible matches to a small number

Small & Medium Enterprise

6649 words - 27 pages collect from customers is the problem, and the solution is cash flow management. At its simplest, cash flow management means delaying outlays of cash as long as possible while encouraging anyone who owes money to the business to pay it as rapidly as possible (How to better manage your cash Flow?, Apr 14, 2014, www.entrepreneur.com/article/66008). For any business enterprise weather it is product/service oriented cash flow act as blood circulation. A

Similar Documents

The Character Of Ghashiram In The Play Ghashiram Kotwal

1186 words - 5 pages is for the sexual folly that Ghashiram is able to be use to Nana. Ghashiram Kotwal buys power through sex. He scarifies the virtue of his daughter in the altar of worship of power. Like a typical tragic hero he suffers from imprudence and fails to have an integrated view of the truth of life. Having purchased power through sex Ghashiram grows muddled thoughtlessly. “The way a wounded tiger becomes addicted to blood, so the Kotwal has

Recent Changes In The Breakfast And Lunch

1134 words - 5 pages crucial in our children nutrition and health. Especially as childhood obesity is a big concern in our nation and it is a cause for many chronic illnesses like type 2 diabetes, blood pressure and high cholesterol. Different studies and researches have shown that school meals are risk factors for childhood obesity. In an effort to stop obesity and the associated health risks, the Healthy Hunger-Free Kids Act (HHFKA) was signed into law by President

Nurse Essay

1134 words - 5 pages feel that the quick fix of a fast food meal is less costly. If the consumer were to factor in the overall cost to that person’s health such as prescription medications needed to control blood sugar for the diabetic, or cardiovascular medications for the person with high blood pressure, perhaps they may see that purchasing a whole chicken when on sale for $0.49/pound, an average 4 pound chicken can provide a protein source to a family of four for

Thoreau On Work Debt And Slavery

1039 words - 5 pages this passage, Thoreau clearly provides an example of how man works his life away. The inherited land given to the new “serf of the soil” must be constantly worked and tilled to produce crops for consumption and for sale. Thoreau argues that man eats his “sixty acres”, but “man is condemned to eat only his peck of dirt (8).” Men labor in vain for only by necessity is he employed. Men pour their sweat, blood, and tears into working the land so much