This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Are British Prime Ministers As Powerful As Is Sometimes Claimed, [40]

1212 words - 5 pages

Are British Prime ministers as powerful as is sometimes claimed?
[40]

It is often argued that in this day and age, Prime ministers are almost untouchable within the British political system, due to the shear number of powers that the Prime minister holds, and the prerogatives that he utilises. However, due to a handful of checks and balances on the government, and the Prime minister not being separated from the political system, which means he or she is liable to these checks and limitations, the Prime minister may therefore not be perceived as all that powerful.

As previously mentioned, the Prime minister enjoys a collection of powers within the UK political system. Firstly, the ...view middle of the document...

Another example of this might be John Major, who only had a 22 seat majority. Another, more recent example that could be used is of David Cameron, when he was in coalition with the Liberal Democrats.

This meant that he did not have a majority in the House of Commons so would therefore have to try and change his policies in order to gain the support of the other leading parties. In some ways, this was more suited to Cameron than most, due to his quite pragmatic style of leadership.

Many argue that British prime ministers are surely as powerful as is sometimes claimed, due to the way in which they can dominate a cabinet. For example, Tony Blair. With his huge landslide majority, he did not need cabinet meetings, as the decisions he made would almost definitely be supported by most in cabinet, regardless of whether he had truly discussed it with them previously. This is why Blair used something known as Sofa Politics which implied that Blair ran his government through unofficial and off the record meetings with select cabinet members. Rather than consulting whole departments, or calling full meetings with the whole cabinet.

Lastly, because of the powers that Blair had as Prime minister, he was able to appoint who he wanted to his cabinet, so he could ensure the support of his decisions as he would appoint mainly Blairites who would mostly agree with his policies. Thatcher can also be used as another example of this, as she was often criticised for surrounding herself in Thatcherites in an attempt to pass everything she put through the commons.

But contrary to these ideas, some would argue that not all Prime ministers possess that dominant personality like that of Margaret Thatcher or Tony Blair, so would therefore find it more difficult to control cabinet, and on top of this, it may also result in the loss of faith of the public and media. For example, Gordon Brown was a highly intellectual man, but clearly lacked the qualities of a domineering leader. Compared to Blair, he sounded like a much less calm and controlled person, as well as coming across as quite frantic and disorganised. As a result of this, he became an attacking point for the media, as they saw him as a viable target for the blame of the recession. Due to the fact that he himself was not elected as PM he decided that he would therefore be unable to control the cabinet he had taken control of. Because of this, he made the biggest cabinet reshuffle in the history of the UK political system. Leaving only one cabinet member in the same position as when Blair was PM.

...

Other assignments on Are British Prime Ministers As Powerful As Is Sometimes Claimed, [40]

The House Of Lords Is Now More Effective Than The House Of Commons In Checking Government Power. Discuss

1305 words - 6 pages in the House of Commons who have to be voting with their party or otherwise they will get sacked/kicked out or never be promoted. Another reason why the House of Commons is more effective in checking government power is Prime ministers Question Time, which is a weekly slot where MPs can ask one notified question of the Prime Minister and one unscripted supplementary question. These are also usually dominated by the PM and the leader of the

Institutions And Governance: A New Treaty, A Newly Elected Parliament And Anew Commission

9969 words - 40 pages , but agreed unanimously in the European Council in June 2009 that he was ‘the person they intend to nominate as President of the European Commission for the period 2009–14’, and asked the current and incoming Presidents of the European Council (the prime ministers of the Czech Republic and Sweden) to ‘have discussions with the European Parliament in order to determine whether the Parliament is in a position to approve that nomination at its

Parliament Carries Out None Of Its Functions Adequately (

619 words - 3 pages been recent changes to the House of Lords it still does not have the same representative functions as the House of Commons. Parliament has a main role in scrutiny and the role of accountability. The parliament holds the government, prime minister and other ministers to account on their decisions and actions. This is done through various methods such as ministers questions, select committees , debates as well as whips. Parliament is able to

Group Of People

2141 words - 9 pages them the "Babylonian Brotherhood." The Brotherhood is mostly male. Their children are raised from an early age to understand the mission; those who fail to understand it are pushed aside. The spread of the reptilian bloodline encompasses what Norman Simms calls the odd and ill-matched, extending to 43 American presidents, three British and two Canadian prime ministers, various Sumerian kings and Egyptian pharaohs, and a smattering of celebrities

Gandhi And Non-Violence

1556 words - 7 pages think about it from two different perspectives which are positive side and negative side. “non-violence” did beat the British badly. Nevertheless, it is limited sometimes. Gandhi sometimes used “non-violence” as a reason to stop the movement. This action always made people down. If there was a non-cooperation movement, people had to unite as one and fight against the British. The people’s disobedience made the British mad. Therefore the British

Classic Books

1040 words - 5 pages develops his proposition on the impacts of colonialism on the general population who are abused as well on the general population abuse individuals, also. The theme, of Shooting an Elephant is to uncover the issues between the law and one's ethical feeling of good and bad as this relates to British government solidly. One major key aspect that makes Shooting an Elephant a classical is that it deals with the evils of imperialism. Imperialism has been

The World Is Not Enough

2997 words - 12 pages “McDonald’s cannot flourish without McDonnell Douglas, the designer of the F-15. And the hidden fist that keeps the world safe for Silicon Valley’s technologies is called the United States Army, Air Force, Navy, and Marine Corps.”[5] Historically, this military protection of commercial interests has great precedence. As far back as the ancient city-states of Venice and Genoa, powerful navies were the basis of wealth.[6] In the seventeenth

Mcdonalds Csr

1091 words - 5 pages regulations are often rather vaguely written, giving officials plenty of opportunity to delay or assist an investor’s plans, but Mr. Nguyen has been able to negotiate these difficulties with ease. Having the second-most-powerful man in the country as father-in-law is like having a golden ticket and get-out-jail-free card all rolled into one.” -In a statement, Liam Jeory, a McDonald’s vice president for corporate relations, wrote: “The contract

Constitutional Reforms Making The Uk More Democratic

319 words - 2 pages There have been many constitutional reforms since 1997 that is progressive towards a more democratic system, however it is not a complete democracy and there are still parts of the constitution could be improved. In 1997 Labour government came to power, with tony blair as prime minister, later Gordon Brown came to power between 2007 to 2010 have made a series of constitutional reforms. This was due to the fact that many practices of british

Business Law

931 words - 4 pages for a new legislative act. The legislations are then stated as statutory Laws. So, against Scottish Parliament, Westminster Parliament is the more Superior legislative body. 5. Provide Two Examples of a Civil Dispute? A: 1. Injury Claim 2. Divorce Claim 6. Name the four most important institutions of the European union and give a brief explanation of their function. 6.1 The Council of Ministers: A: The body represent 27 Member States

Upload1

6579 words - 27 pages functions, except those of ministers. Any other public functionary elected deputy is free to accept or refuse; but, in case of acceptance, he must resign his functions. Art. 68. The following are ineligible as deputies: 1. Those who do not belong to the Ottoman nationality; 2. Those who, by virtue of the special regulation in force, enjoy immunities attached to the foreign service to which they belong; 3. Those not understanding Turkish; 4. Those not

Similar Documents

As Time Is Near Essay

357 words - 2 pages This analytical essay will provide an analysis and interpretation of american writer Eowyn Ivey’s short story “As the Time Draws Near” (2012). The readers are introduced to the main character, Piper, who grew up in Alaska but later moved away. The short story follows her at a time when she has returned to Alaska in order to spread her dead father’s ashes under a particular spruce tree. She has a lot of thoughts about death and she is almost

Inflation Is Key Risk As China Sees Surge In Trade

1268 words - 6 pages internal medium of exchange and unit of account in the economy.( Cited from: en.wikipedia.org, 15 April 2011) .As inflation is a problem for many reasons ,the main one is that once it takes hold ,it is unpredictable. Unpredictable inflation is a problem because it redistributes income and wealth, and diverts resources from productive activities to inflation forecasting. At its worse, inflation becomes hyperinflation, many workers are paid twice a day

A 25 Year Old Individual Is Working Full Time As A Volunteer In A Charity Organization. His Daily Job Is To Distribute Leaflets Door To Door And Take Part In Charity Events. He Is Now Preparing For A...

1915 words - 8 pages teaching |Internal Verifier Name: | |team. |Mr Hasa Ram | Rules and regulations: |Plagiarism is presenting somebody else’s work as your own. It includes: copying information directly from the Web or books without | |referencing the material; submitting joint coursework as an individual effort

Explain How Variables Such As Social Interactions, Cognitive Processes, Environmental Variables, Cultural Context, And Biological Factors Shape What Social Psychology Is All About And How It Is...

319 words - 2 pages Social psychology is the scientific field that seeks to understand the nature and causes of the individual behavior and thought in social situation. Social psychology investigates the ways in which our thoughts, feelings, and actions are influenced by the social environments in which we live. Social interactions help to shape who we are and how we act in different situations. The factors affecting social interaction fall into five major